5 ms·
And here we go, again. > Your evidence for masks working is ... movies? Not evidence. Graphical demonstration of common sense behavior by other humans that ca
by mindslight 4y ago
And here we go, again.
> Your evidence for masks working is ... movies?
Not evidence. Graphical demonstration of common sense behavior by other humans that can be mimicked, because if someone is operating at the level of "masks don't work" or "a cloth mask will protect" then that is apparently what's needed. An individual doing a menial task of spraying paint or grinding metal and then blowing out black snot quickly understands the purpose of air filtration, but social media is a hell of a drug.
"Masks" having no effect on Covid isn't an indicator of much, because >90% of the population never wore real respirators that provided actual incoming air filtration. You're essentially beating the strawman of the people wearing cut up t-shirts to "protect others", which I agree was also dumb tribal behavior.
Putting it simply - why has air filtration been standard operating procedure in bio labs, long before Covid? The question about Covid specifically isn't some "yes/no", but ultimately an engineering problem of what type of filtration is effective.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- taolegal 4y ago> >90% of the population never wore real respirators Because doing so is not practical, all these "pro-science" people are divorced from reality, operating in some absurdly idealized world that doesn't account for whether a system is literally able to be practiced by normal people. Our evidence for whether it's possible is whether anywhere even close to a majority of people did over the course of the pandemic. Not even close.
- mindslight 4y ago"It's not practical because nobody did it because we told them it's not practical" If everyone had that kind of outlook, we'd still be living in caves.
- taolegal 4y agoBut surely if everyone is doing absurd things to avoid death, like quarantining & wiping down their mail & groceries. Surely they’d have used better respirators.
- mindslight 4y agoThat's conflating a bunch of memes in a non-falsifiable way. From what I've seen, most people apparently just listen to what TV/Faceboot/etc say their tribe should do and then rationalize it. And what really messed the respirator issue up was being completely fucked by politics. First the CDC lied to preserve supply for hospitals. Then the topic got politicized into two moronic camps of "masks don't work" and "wear your mask to protect others". What was missing was "protect yourself and your family by wearing a quality respirator". Personal responsibility used to be a bastion of the Republican party, but went completely AWOL for this issue. FWIW a 3M 8293 is a P100, more comfortable than your run of the mill cloth or surgical mask, breathes cool and easy thanks to the check valve, looks basically the same as a common technical face mask, and only costs $10. Of course you have to know to look for these to even find them, and you're much less likely to do that when given a thousand reasons not to by competing choruses of ignorance.
- taolegal 4y agoI'm sorry but this is deluded. This isn't happening because it's impractical. No one is listening to you because it's insufferable and abnormal. If you want to put your plans into practice, you have to convince people to follow you and so far you've drastically failed. This isn't a failure of imagination or even will. It's monomania. Left-leaning people seem to have mostly decided that the answer is totalitarianism. That if people don't do what you want you have to dominate them with force & otherwise shame. That all-too-popular option is odious. > Personal responsibility used to be a bastion of the Republican party, but went completely AWOL for this issue. Oh ok. We should all tip-toe around afraid about whatever butterfly effect will cause harm to someone in the world. Let's make "the floor is lava" and "step on a crack and break your mother's back" a way of life.
- 4y ago
- origin_path 4y agoWell at least you accept that mask mandates were wrong, even though you also attack people "operating at the level of masks don't work". Seems like a contradiction. Germany mandated FFP2 masks quite a while ago. They didn't have any effect there either, and that is exactly as expected. To repeat: these viruses can spread through drainpipes connecting apartments. They can drift on the air between buildings. They can be suspended for hours in rooms and hallways. They can spread through air ducts in living quarters whilst people sleep. It's obvious why masks of any kind had no effect given this fact, nor could they have done. You seem to be believing that if only everyone had worn a slightly tighter fit of higher grade mask, things would have been different. But, people aren't ever going to wear gas masks 24/7 including in bed and in the shower. That's the whole reason that even biolabs use filters integrated into the building, not strapped to people's faces. That's why the idea you can fight respiratory virus epidemics with masks is just directionally wrong. You keep acting like this is the fault of the public, but it's just straightforward common sense given what the data says.
- mindslight 4y agoIf viruses are spreading through the drainpipes into your apartment, you really need to call a plumber to make sure that all your drains have traps, and that they're full of water. I guess this would explain your over familiarity with "gas masks" too. Seriously, sewer gas is no joke, regardless of Covid.
- origin_path 4y agoSpread through drainpipes isn't some theory I made up, it's the conclusion of investigations into how SARS-1 spread in Hong Kong. The drains in questions were floor drains, so presumably had didn't have per-apartment traps in that case. At any rate, if you think it's obviously wrong then take it up with the people who wrote the paper I cited. The bigger problem is probably not floor drains of course but air ducts, hallways and other building areas that expose the uninfected to aerosols hanging in the air in ways that masks won't affect because people don't wear them at home. I get the impression from your other post you may have been making your family wear respirators, perhaps even at home. If so then yes, this message will be hard to hear, but it's not generalized stupidity amongst the population that we didn't all follow you in that. It's that the droplet model of spread was invalidated very early on and the immediate failure of mask mandates confirmed what was happening. Respirators with valves are especially incompatible with either model, and in fact got banned pretty early on where I live. You had to use masks without valves.