4 ms·
A lot of people are going to hold up this renewed discussion as vindication, and that is somewhat correct. But the hard truth is that now is the right time to f
by mindslight 4y ago
A lot of people are going to hold up this renewed discussion as vindication, and that is somewhat correct. But the hard truth is that now is the right time to focus on this, and the beginning of the pandemic was simply not.
The intelligence of groups scales something like the inverse of Metcalfe's law. More people means more memetic mass repeating poor local optima, severely curtailing everyone's ability for rational thought. So in a large group the bandwidth to quickly converge on nuanced truths just isn't there.
We couldn't even get wearing a basic respirator, as demonstrated in countless movies about pandemics, to become accepted as common sense until 22 months into the pandemic. That's how paralyzed we were as a society. The last thing we needed was even more energy being dumped into jingoistic (and other zero-sum) red herrings rather than taking basic care of ourselves.
- origin_path 4y agoYour evidence for masks working is ... movies? This has come up so often, but clearly, repetition must continue. Masks and mask mandates had no effect on COVID at any point. Even a cursory amount of time spent with the case graphs and start/end dates will show that to be clear. You simply cannot find inflection points in the case graphs that correlate with mask mandates being added or removed. The reason is, masking assumed SARS-CoV-2 spreads via large water droplets. The mask was supposed to catch these droplets if you were infected and coughed. But actually SARS-CoV-2 spreads like a gas, via invisible aerosols that can float in the air. The article discusses this briefly: Animal experiments to test the efficacy of vaccines generated highly infectious aerosols that are “difficult to detect,” the interim report says, adding that “there were concerns about conducting this type of research in a BSL2 laboratory.” and Two and a half months earlier, according to the interim report, procurement officials at the WIV posted a call for bids on a government website seeking a costly air incinerator. The post was dated Nov. 19, 2019, the very day that the visiting CAS safety official arrived to address a “complex and grave” situation there … If somehow the HEPA filter system failed, because there was a tear or breach … then your quick fix would be to bring in an air incinerator. This was actually known from the start by people paying attention. The Diamond Princess cruise ship proved it. The whole ship was placed in lockdown, where people weren't allowed to leave their cabins, and the initial infections were also confined to quarters. Yet very quickly COVID was cropping up all over the ship despite the lack of contact. Therefore it must have been spreading via the air ducts as a consequence. This sort of thing was to be expected because SARS-1 was found by investigators in Hong Kong to have spread within an apartment building placed in lockdown via the drain pipes connecting bathrooms, and even between buildings, via aerosol spread. Search for "Environmental transmission of SARS at Amoy Gardens" to see. The outbreak on the Diamond Princess revealed not only that lockdowns wouldn't work, but also that lots of people appeared to have prior immunity, somehow. Unfortunately even though this rather 'useful' outbreak happened very early on, the results were ignored by epidemiologists. The reason is fairly clear if you read their papers: they have developed a culture of ignoring inconvenient data and replacing it with assumptions. Epidemiology papers and models will routinely have dozens or even hundreds of assumptions in them, even about variables that have observational data available, and always to the same end of exaggerating both severity of an epidemic along with the ability to control it. Aerosol spread would have rendered epidemiologists entirely useless, as there's no known way to contain or reduce the spread of such a virus, so they'd have had nothing to contribute. Hence the replacement of observational data with the assumption of highly localized droplet spread, to which several different containment strategies could be applied.
- mindslight 4y agoAnd here we go, again. > Your evidence for masks working is ... movies? Not evidence. Graphical demonstration of common sense behavior by other humans that can be mimicked, because if someone is operating at the level of "masks don't work" or "a cloth mask will protect" then that is apparently what's needed. An individual doing a menial task of spraying paint or grinding metal and then blowing out black snot quickly understands the purpose of air filtration, but social media is a hell of a drug. "Masks" having no effect on Covid isn't an indicator of much, because >90% of the population never wore real respirators that provided actual incoming air filtration. You're essentially beating the strawman of the people wearing cut up t-shirts to "protect others", which I agree was also dumb tribal behavior. Putting it simply - why has air filtration been standard operating procedure in bio labs, long before Covid? The question about Covid specifically isn't some "yes/no", but ultimately an engineering problem of what type of filtration is effective.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- taolegal 4y ago> >90% of the population never wore real respirators Because doing so is not practical, all these "pro-science" people are divorced from reality, operating in some absurdly idealized world that doesn't account for whether a system is literally able to be practiced by normal people. Our evidence for whether it's possible is whether anywhere even close to a majority of people did over the course of the pandemic. Not even close.
- mindslight 4y ago"It's not practical because nobody did it because we told them it's not practical" If everyone had that kind of outlook, we'd still be living in caves.
- taolegal 4y agoBut surely if everyone is doing absurd things to avoid death, like quarantining & wiping down their mail & groceries. Surely they’d have used better respirators.
- mint2 4y ago“But the hard truth is that now is the right time to focus on this, and the beginning of the pandemic was simply not.” You’ve hit on one of the biggest issues of the debate. Early on many of the posts acted like if everyone got on board with a lab leak theory or if it turned out to be a lab leak, then we would be able to get back to normal and also the government would be blameless for their terrible prep. Neither of those made sense. The virus could have been from a lab, from a meteor, from an angry pine cone god willing it into existence, or from evolution making a virus jump species. It wouldn’t effect the proper response or change the situation. While the virus is still a concern, we’re out of the acute phase so now it’s appropriate for a retrospective cause analysis in order to prevent it from happening again. The start it would have served no purpose except distract from what actually needed focus. Also, even today it seems almost moot whether it was from the market or the lab. That both are very plausible scenarios really should be enough to take appropriate measures for making sure neither could spawn a new one.
- jorgesborges 4y ago> But the hard truth is that now is the right time to focus on this, and the beginning of the pandemic was simply not. That’s not what happened. We didn’t shelve the discussion to focus on other priorities, we created a propaganda campaign to prohibit the discussion from taking placing and actively censored and stigmatized well-meaning individuals who explored it. There’s so much condescension in the post-rationalization of these decisions. We couldn’t tell people that masks might not work, or that the virus may have come from a lab. Why? All it did was destroy the credibility of our institutions.
- taolegal 4y ago> All it did was destroy the credibility of our institutions. They're stuck in a death spiral too, cause admitting fault now would unravel years of digging themselves into a hole, insisting that they make no errors and if they do it's cause "the science changed."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]