4 ms·
I'm a long way from Texas. Should I note this as a win for the free market or is there something going on here?
by roenxi 4y ago
I'm a long way from Texas. Should I note this as a win for the free market or is there something going on here?
- jeffbee 4y agoOnly if you’re a blind ideologue. The wind boom in Texas is the result of raising their renewable energy portfolio laws to require a certain amount of it, and by establishing renewable energy zones which give power plant builders expansive powers to condemn and take private property. You see it’s quite the opposite of free market forces.
- phrz 4y agoThat begs the question: if oil and gas is steeply subsidized, does government support for renewables simply create a level playing field?
- anecdotal1 4y agoYou're not supposed to mention that there is no free market / price discovery with fossil fuels :)
- kodah 4y agoAt least on the ground, that's what I saw. Turbines work a lot like someone asking to use other types of rights on your property. Unfortunately, iirc most of the windfarms are owned by a few people, but people are getting paid for wind instead of fracking. I don't think wind and oil are at competition in Texas though. Most oil drilled in Texas isn't destined for Texas, or the US really.
- patrick451 4y agoMost of what passes for a "subsidy" in this conversation is writing off normal business expenses, the same way ever business in the country does. https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidblackmon/2013/01/02/oil-gas-tax-provisions-are-not-subsidies-for-big-oil/?sh=1299b3b852e8 https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidblackmon/2013/01/02/oil-ga...
- vkou 4y agoBeing able to dump dangerous waste into the environment for free is not 'writing off a normal business expense'.
- patrick451 4y agoYes it is. People write off vehicle mileage or depreciation all the time.
- bumby 4y agoMaybe you can help me understand by adding some details and nuance. The percentage depletion part of the tax code is specific to oil and gas, so it's not quite the same as saying it's what "ever [sic] business in the country does." I agree it's not a subsidy, but it seems like a very specific carve-out for a very specific industry and a specific commodity. It feels to the layperson that it's an odd fact that the percentage depletion can exceed the cost of the well, which makes non-viable wells suddenly viable again. That seems like favoring a specific industry in legislation. A dairy farmer cannot, for example, depreciate "future reserves" of cows milk to make a non-viable farm suddenly profitable, can they? (Understanding that there are true subsidies for farming, that may not be a good analogy).
- epistasis 4y agoI'm not quite so sure about that interpretation... there was an early Renewable Portfolio Standard around 2000, yes. But that was for tiny amounts compared to what independent generators are putting on to the grid these days. Compared to a standard utility, which is a regulated monopoly that does five year planning based off old data and the inertia of a large corp with no competition, the Texas energy market is the Wild West. Nearly anybody can connect their project to the grid and sell at the prices they want to sell at. And that's why Texas is installing massive amounts of battery storage, wind, and solar, compared to new natural gas. There's no mandate for GW of battery capacity, it's just people thinking they can make a buck on arbitrage of all the wind and solar electricity.
- bradknowles 4y agoThe wind boom in Texas is bankrolled by guys like T. Boone Pickens, a man who made his billions in oil (and perpetrating some of the shadiest schemes on the planet), and then wants to use the same schemes to make even more billions in wind. He's the guy who is buying off the politicians so that they create the zones where he can get excessive powers to do whatever he wants.
- legitster 4y agoPart of it is very favorable geography. But part of it, yes - You can throw up a wind farm in Texas cheaper and with less red tape than just about anywhere else.
- themitigating 4y agoCan you prove that? This "less red tape" is brought up constantly but is that the case for all situations ?
- legitster 4y agoHere's the entire report on the wind market: https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-08/land_based_wind_market_report_2202.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/default/files/2022-08/land_base... Difference in regional costs starts on page 42 (Texas is ERCOT).
- philjohn 4y agoIs part of that red tape elsewhere that you need to winterize your turbines just in case?