3 ms·
Texas is likely to pass California in total renewable energy resources soon, which kind of annoys me. I would like California to step up its construction game,
by jeffbee 4y ago
Texas is likely to pass California in total renewable energy resources soon, which kind of annoys me. I would like California to step up its construction game, and not just rest on our head start.
- nappy-doo 4y agoHave you met PG&E?
- jeffbee 4y agoI have but for the audience who might not know much about California: PG&E are not players in the renewable energy construction game. Other entities build and operate the plants, and the utilities buy the energy. My impression is the main hurdle for us is CEQA, which gives every homeowner, misguided Sierra Club member, and union goon a way to stop or delay the projects.
- mistrial9 4y agothere is a quiet non-profit based around Palo Alto that builds long-term residential solar installations, directly under the wing of PG&E. The tradeoff is that they put three "phone home" operators in your solar controller, and reserve the right to shutoff power back into the grid for their own reasons; high-quality installs though.
- shagie 4y ago> The tradeoff is that they put three "phone home" operators in your solar controller, and reserve the right to shutoff power back into the grid for their own reasons. The ability to push any substantial power back into the grid always comes with that. Consider Hawaii's solar options: https://www.hawaiianelectric.com/products-and-services/customer-renewable-programs/rooftop-solar https://www.hawaiianelectric.com/products-and-services/custo... > Customer Grid-Supply Plus (CGS Plus) systems must include grid support technology to manage grid reliability and allow the utility to remotely monitor system performance, technical compliance and, if necessary, control for grid stability. > Smart Export customers with a renewable system and battery energy storage system have the option to export energy to the grid from 4 p.m. – 9 a.m. Systems must include grid support technology to manage grid reliability and system performance. > Customer Self-Supply (CSS) is intended only for private rooftop solar installations that are designed to not export any electricity to the grid. Customers are not compensated for any export of energy. --- Having too much power on the grid can be as damaging as not enough. There are systems that take longer to power up and down and corresponding issues with environmental regulations. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jonbruner/2011/10/20/the-high-stakes-math-behind-the-wests-greatest-river/?sh=455c0a5b222b https://www.forbes.com/sites/jonbruner/2011/10/20/the-high-s... > But as large as the dams are, their margins are minuscule and operating them takes unerring foresight and subtle management: let too much water fill reservoirs and a rainstorm might flood Portland; keep the reservoirs too empty and you’ll parch farmers. Send too much water over a dam’s spillway and you’ll suffocate fish with dissolved gases; send too much through its turbines and you’ll overload the electrical grid. > ... > It’s also brought about tension when the BPA hasn’t been able to change its output. Both wind and hydro generation are subject to nature at the extremes. In May 2011, with near-record snowmelt swelling the Columbia River and spillways at their limits under environmental regulations, the BPA had to keep the Columbia’s hydro turbines spinning. It told regional wind power producers to curtail their output by 6%. The producers howled, and in June the BPA ended up the subject of a complaint before the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission. At issue is what happens when too much electricity is on offer. The enormous supply of hydroelectricity during spring runoff can push electricity prices to zero—the BPA gives away electricity to local utilities for free when it’s forced to produce more than it wants to. Since wind producers enjoy production subsidies, they can push rates below zero, effectively paying other utilities to switch off their generators. Last winter, the BPA told wind producers under its balancing authority that it wouldn’t pay negative rates to them during high-water events. Making sure that the water doesn't go over the spillways in a hydro plant during a spring peak to avoid killing fish means turning off power from other sources. In that example, it was primarily wind
- chiph 4y ago> reserve the right to shutoff power back into the grid for their own reasons. That's not unreasonable. They might shut off your PV panels as a safety measure to prevent backfeeding into the local lines when utility crews are working nearby. Or when there is a supply glut - it's faster/cheaper/causes less wear to turn off several thousand[0] residential PV panels than to shut down a major generating plant for a few hours. [0] Or maybe only a few hundred if that's all that is needed to balance the system.
- bradknowles 4y agoI don't mind cutting off the feed from the solar panel to the grid, if there are crews working on the lines, or other reasonable events. I don't want them cutting off my solar panels from being able to feed my house or my batteries, unless all my batteries are all full and there's no power draw from my house. If they don't want my solar power, then it's fine for them to refuse to accept it, but the decision of what to do with that remaining power should be left entirely on my end.
- mistrial9 4y agoagree -- no experimental evidence but I suspect that the power cutoff is "no more power from those panels" not "power is available but no grid connection"; secondly it is annoying to not have any say over when or how long that connection is off. I tend to view the relationship in cynical terms, I admit. The quality of the physical equipment though, is notable.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoOne thing about Texas, if you have money to build whatever you want to build and line the pocket so of some politicians, you can get around regulations, property rights, and taxes
- Aloha 4y agoWe also just have fewer regulations about what can be built and where, and there are fewer block points in the approval process here.
- dexterdog 4y agoThat is common in Texas but it is far from being a unique thing.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoThis is a bullshit, low-effort comment (to be fair, this article seems to be attracting tons of them). If you have specific examples of places where corruption, unenforced regulations and disrespect for property rights allowed a wind or solar farm to get built, especially in a way that shows more corruption than other locales, speak up with a source, otherwise you're just bullshitting. It's not that hard to see why Texas is a leader in solar and wind: 1. There is a lot of land in Texas, and there are tons of "in the middle of nowhere" places where wind or solar farms aren't subject to NIMBYism. 2. Texas actually has extreme respect for property rights (many might argue too much). In contrast to many Western states, there is comparatively little federally owned land - most of it is privately owned ranch land. 3. Texas already has lower regulations and business taxes than many other states - Texas doesn't need corruption to get around stringent regulations. Texas simply makes it easier to put up a wind or solar farm on any of the huge swaths of privately-owned "emptiness" that cover most of our state.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt wasn’t a very detailed comment, but let’s be real here. Resource extraction and energy industries own Texas politics, and have for over a century.
- macromaniac 4y agoTexas is more wind focused too (24% wind vs 6% solar) which is better for the local economy. 80% of solar panels come from china.
- HWR_14 4y agoTexas is, in many places, a wind-swept desert. Texas gets more direct sun because it is closer to the equator. Texas is also 70% larger in area. If it didn't surpass California in total renewables, that would be an amazing story.
- lost_tourist 4y agoBut if you compare it by population it also makes perfect sense, as it only has 2/3 the population of California.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoTexas has a LOT more land that can be used for wind in particular than Calif (probably solar too)
- scifibestfi 4y agoIs land the limiting factor? Did Calif already fill up available space?
- jeffbee 4y agoIt really is not. Just Edwards AFB by itself could power the entire state all year long if it was replaced by solar panels and batteries.
- qwerasdf5 4y agoCA has a huge amount of empty desert, and wind to go along with it.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoI didn't say CA was small, just the TX has a lot more available land (CA is .6 the size of TX). CA pop density is 2.5x TX's. And unlike TX, nearly half of CA is covered by mountains.
- lob_it 4y agoAfter visiting california, they have a bankrupt economy problem. It looks like the water woes are coming to a head and the chinesium import money will run dry there too very soon. Texas has an illiteracy problem too, with fiction and faith in a cesspool swirl. I had a 3 day visit this year and the meth problem outside of their large cities was noticeable too. The wind turbine arrangements have always impressed me though, driving through the state. The methane leaks from oil/gas prospecting in both of those states also doesn't bode well for environmental stewardship. They still have to cap their greenhouse gas leaks to be 21st century compliant. The commisions have already been paid and the services rendered. The cleanup for the 20th century is someone elses problem :p Morbidly obese losing 5 lbs is not news.