3 ms·
Abstractly, a planet is just a really really big starship. With technological advances, we could even eventually theoretically move planets. So phrased in anot
by somenameforme 4y ago
Abstractly, a planet is just a really really big starship. With technological advances, we could even eventually theoretically move planets.
So phrased in another way, why would one choose to live their entire life in a small starship instead of a big one?
- Sharlin 4y agoBecause of the square–cube law. Planets are an unfathomably inefficient form factor in terms of material use to available surface area/volume ratio.
- ben_w 4y agoCounterpoint I’ve been thinking about recently: Imagine you have a fancy self-repairing spaceship, so good that even accounting for the slow wear and tear of micrometeorites, outgassing, and the motion of feet slowly polishing grooves into walkways, it still only looses 1% of its mass to the outside vacuum every thousand years. A Dyson swarm of those still becomes a mysterious cloud slowly puffing away from its parent star, and after just 2150 millennia, it’s declined from a Kardashev II to a Kardashev I civilisation. A planet-based civilisation may live or die, but it won’t burn out quite like that.
- chongli 4y agoThe usual definition of starship is a ship that travels between the stars. Earth is stuck orbiting one star so I wouldn’t classify it as a starship. Maybe the label would better suit a rogue planet?
- Qem 4y agoThe sun moves relative to the neighboring stars. That means we have periodic close encounters (d < 1ly) with other stars, and effectively the Earth starship argument holds. The lazy way to travel the stars is to figure how to avoid killing ourselves for tens of thousands of years, while the stars come to us. See the list of future close encounters at https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nearest_stars_and_brown_dwarfs https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_nearest_stars_and_br...