4 ms·
How did we manage to lose GUI editing of HTML, as in Dreamweaver, and GUI editing of user interfaces, as in Visual Basic?
by Animats 4y ago
How did we manage to lose GUI editing of HTML, as in Dreamweaver, and GUI editing of user interfaces, as in Visual Basic?
- noduerme 4y agoWe also lost GUI editing of interactive vector animation, as in Flash.
- Animats 4y agoI know. It used to be common to build the 2D UIs of games in Flash. The Adobe design tools were OK, and there are third-party libraries for running Flash. There's even a Flash runtime in Rust.
- noduerme 4y agoYes. I was one such designer. You could do a UI in Flash and then export all its animations to cryengine. The actual design tools in Flash were mediocre, but some animators really loved them. For designers, it played well with Illustrator... if an illustrator vector file updated you could re-import it and reuse the animation. You'd just draw your UI gizmos / HUD / whatever, assign anything to be a sprite and hook it from code. Any complex vector animations could be created visually and then triggered. It even had full 3D capabilities, worked really well on mobile chipsets and could leverage a GPU, although in the UI-as-export for games context it would run on the CPU.
- trevyn 4y agoIt's tricky to do GUI editing when your design is expected to be responsive to different aspect ratios, input methods, and screen sizes. :(
- dmitriid 4y agoThe myth of "omg only html has different screen sizes" is so pervasive, it's mind boggling. Desktop apps have had "different screen sizes" forever. This is called "resize your window in any way you want". I have a rant/thread on this: https://twitter.com/dmitriid/status/1424052193951354881?s=20&t=N4TR_MQjS8tr3rB6N82cFg https://twitter.com/dmitriid/status/1424052193951354881?s=20...
- phtrivier 4y agoSure, but I don't recall many programs / games / thick clients that would reorganize the layout of the application (adding or removing elements, reorganizing rows as communs, etc...) At least not 90s era windows programs, and certainly not dos. Résolution was taken into account in games, to compute a scaling factor, maybe add some screen bars, and that was nearly all - fundamentally, because hardly any program was going to be used in a small, top to bottom screen at all. So html was just the first one to have to do it pervasively because of desktop + mobile web browsing of the same source - but it could have happened before.
- mpweiher 4y ago> (adding or removing elements, reorganizing rows as communs, etc...) The main reason you don't recall apps doing that is that it is a pretty horrible idea in virtually all cases.
- noduerme 4y agoRemoving big nav bars and moving their contents into drop-down menus is pretty much the standard way of handling resizes across the web. Same goes for multi-column layouts. It would be a horrible idea to keep those things on a phone, just like it's a horrible idea to scale up a phone interface to a desktop browser window.
- mpweiher 4y agoHaving distinct layouts for mobile devices can be a good idea. Having the interface add/remove elements for this dynamically is (a) obviously not necessary, as my desktop doesn't suddenly turn into a phone while I am browsing, and (b) not a good idea. It seems like a neat generalisation, but it really isn't.
- noduerme 4y agoJust to point out why your statement is misinformed, your tablet turns from a desktop to a phone when you rotate it. I've been designing web frameworks from the ground up since 1995. Two sizes is not how it works. You don't read the initial size of the browser window, or parse the device data to see if it's mobile, and decide from there which of two layouts to draw (mobile or desktop). You read it on the fly and redraw as necessary. All parts of the interface and the content working together. Bootstrap, for instance, has xs, sm md lg xl classes and mixins. Often you don't hide interface elements but simply resize them. Font leading and size may change 20 times subtly as you resize a window. If you don't believe me, load any major website in a desktop browser and play with resizing the window from narrow to wide.
- mpweiher 4y agoNo. NeXTStep had resizable windows. NeXTStep had Interface Builder. Worked like a charm.
- trevyn 4y agoOk, how about "scrollable page" as the underlying mental model?
- ithkuil 4y agoIt's still there in MacOS's XCode
- gcanyon 4y agoWhen I've looked in the past, Interface Builder was (as far as I could tell) a first-step-and-don't-return thing. Meaning you could lay out an interface visually, but when you want to start coding it becomes a code definition of that interface, and once you start updating that, you can't (easily) return to the visual interface-definition interface. Has that changed, or was I wrong?
- mpweiher 4y agoSadly, that's what it has turned into. Used to be a lot better.
- gcanyon 4y ago
- noduerme 4y agoNot tricky if you spend the time. I'm always speechless when people claim that lack of responsive screen adjustment was the death knell of Flash/AS3. Any language or stack is going to suck on some screens unless you test it on those screens and write code accordingly. Nothing had better performance in this than Flash, up until Google decided to stop letting Chrome fire off new window boundaries on resize until the click/drag was let up. I wrote practically a whole operating system with window managers and apps in a resizable browser window in 2008 using that tool in under 300k. And large portions of the graphical elements were done through the GUI. Do you realize how much more boring and time consuming it is to write every media size CSS subclass and have to test it compared with just drawing multiple sizes of things and changing their positions and filters?
- trevyn 4y ago>and write code accordingly That is exactly the point — now you have to write code, not use a graphical editor.
- noduerme 4y agoNo, but the sprite/graphic implementation was much less tedious when you could use a good GUI to set up all the small bits instead of relying on a mental map of flex/grid/css to resolve every little padding or margin. I often write 99% of an app now and spend days dealing with single-pixel discrepancies on screens whereas before, the layouts would likely be implemented before the code to swap between them even started being written. You always also had to write code.
- antonyl 4y agoHave you seen Retool (https://retool.com https://retool.com)? It feels familiar to HyperCard / Visual Basic, but now in the cloud. I’ve used it and like it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- trevyn 4y agoRelying on a SaaS today is not too bright.
- UweSchmidt 4y agoProfessionals in every domain like to maintain a certain level of difficulty to keep amateurs out. The tools of a trade can never be too easy, the tax code can never be simplified, legal writing and procedure has to be opaque etc. as professionals subconsciously reject job security threating ideas. This sabotage is subtle: A wide variety of technical decisions can be made at any time, with complex trade-offs, bounded by what the majority of developers is willing and able to handle. As we move our servers to the cloud to make our lives easier and get admins fired, the exact right level of complexity shows up in AWS and Azure to enable stable and well-paid cloud expert jobs. For that difficulty-goldilocks-zone, Visual Basic was too easy, and things like functional programming are too hard.
- Etheryte 4y agoThis is nonsense. The tax code is complex to close loopholes that smart money-motivated people find in it. Similarly, programs are complex because they solve complex problems. Of course you can write very simple programs, but they simply don't solve the complex problems. None of this is about gatekeeping anyone, all of this is about what value we actually provide.
- UweSchmidt 4y agoThere are some complex problems out there, but the vast majority of requirements are rather trivial, no? Heavy websites that don't do much, but with enough javascript to harm usability seem to be an issue HN readers agree on. Opening a car glove box is another simple problem that now has complex solutions (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lRB0gbYO3fE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lRB0gbYO3fE). Isn't it weird how those things come about? It can't possibly be incompetence, nor would it be outright evil. I suspect it's a subconscious process where we like to build a framework that appeals to us, where we get to be 'senior' and shape the world the way it is convenient for us. The antidote is a clear commitment to simplicity, to meditate over Picasso's Bull and apply that to our work.
- samatman 4y agoThe tax code is complex to create loopholes for the wealthy to exploit.
- tomjen3 4y agoWe didn't, of either. If you have a WordPress blog, you would be surprised how much you can edit in GUIs. .NET/Delphi/etc. are still around. Heck, you can GUI edit a Swing app right now if you want. The trouble is that GUI editing is super limited, so it is worth learning to write the code yourself. And frankly, HTML with CSS3 is not that hard to make by hand; organize div and spans and other tags around what you need, then open the page in Chromes dev tools and adjust margins etc., until it looks like what you want, then save the CSS file it generates. This is much better than fighting with a GUI tool.
- tluyben2 4y agoIt’s better than fighting with a gui tool if you care about gui. I just need something to work and then give it to someone. I still haven’t found anything productive outside something like retool (cannot use cloud for the work I do) that works for me. Most wysiwyg tools now use drag and drop to containers that are responsive etc which I find impossible and tedious to use. I want to throw stuff on a canvas and hook it up to the backend I made, test it and then throw the code to a frontend colleague. Found nothing usable like Delphi (used it for 10 years in the 90s/00s) but for html for that yet; it’s all tedious, slow and usually incredibly buggy. I am a senior (30 years+) software engineer and html/css really doesn’t work for me. I can do it but I find it boring and annoying.
- tomjen3 4y agoIf you just want to slap something together, why not use a GUI to edit a Swing frontend? Or do you specifically mean an interactive HTML front-end, something I don't think you could make in DreamWaver either?
- fredgrott 4y agoGoogle Web Designer which is closed source has Dreamweaver features including templates. see https://webdesigner.withgoogle.com/ https://webdesigner.withgoogle.com/
- gcanyon 4y agoLivecode offers exactly what you're describing: GUI editing of a live user interface, with code able to be built-in to every object. https://livecode.com https://livecode.com It's based on HyperCard, so the language isn't to everyone's taste. But it's updated to include color, unicode, more advanced coding techniques, database access, multi-platform and more. But the basic concept -- I want a button here, and a field there, and a slider there -- is still 100% there.