3 ms·
That essay is full of incorrect statements. 1) The Earth is not "just within Sol's habitable zone" since the estimate of that zone is between 0.75 and 3.0 AU. 2
by dalke 15y ago
That essay is full of incorrect statements. 1) The Earth is not "just within Sol's habitable zone" since the estimate of that zone is between 0.75 and 3.0 AU. 2) "there is no other satellite closer in size and composition to its mother-planet (if one discounts the dwarf-planet Pluto)" ... so if you throw out any of the counter-examples then it's true! In any case, 8 examples gives a large error range. 3) "the Earth/moon system is the only tidally locked pair"; but quoting Wikipedia "Most significant moons in the Solar System are tidally locked with their primaries."
4) "All of the other worlds either lack satellites or have captured them from other places" ... this after saying that the Earth captured its satellite from another body in Earth's L-4/5 point. Also, Wikipedia claims "co-formation ... does not explain the depletion of metallic iron in the Moon