3 ms·
In the US you can't claim free speech if you yell "fire" in a full theater. In Germany you also can't claim free speech if you yell "kill all the jews" on a str
by wongarsu 4y ago
In the US you can't claim free speech if you yell "fire" in a full theater. In Germany you also can't claim free speech if you yell "kill all the jews" on a street corner. I'm not sure those are that different. They are both about the right to physical integrity winning out over the right to free speech once the latter threatens the former.
With insults it's important to note that European constitutions commonly protect not just physical integrity, but also dignity or honour. You again have to balance which right weights more. England goes a bit too far in my opinion. In Germany insulting someone is also technically illegal and can get you up to one year in prison, but in reality, results in nothing at all or a 3-4 digit fine (German courts are quite reasonable, most of the time).
- pyuser583 4y agoIf you honestly believe the theater to be on fire, you absolutely have the right to shout “fire” in a crowded theater.
- karatinversion 4y agoNote that the “shouting fire in a crowded theatre” argument comes from an overturned 1919 Supreme Court case which held that the federal government could ban the distribution of anti-draft pamphlets during WW1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_t...
- canjobear 4y agoAnd that Supreme Court decision was overturned later in Brandenburg v Ohio.
- canjobear 4y agoSpeech is substantially more restricted in Germany. The US only bans immediate incitement to violence (that is, contrary to the folk belief, yelling “fire” in a crowded theater is ok). Whereas in Germany certain symbols such as the swastika may not be displayed.