3 ms·
I'm beginning to wonder if Facebook – along with online games and other free diversions like YouTube – could even be contributing to economic malaise and unempl
by gojomo 15y ago
I'm beginning to wonder if Facebook – along with online games and other free diversions like YouTube – could even be contributing to economic malaise and unemployment.
It's cheaper and easier than ever to acquire a minimal sustaining reward-drip of novelty and even 'social' strokes via the free net. If savings, family, or public support are enough to keep someone fed, sheltered, and online… then perhaps their willingness to seek and accept a paid job has gone down.
Even if this is not the case for most unemployed, at the margin, there are likely to be some people who, without Facebook/Farmville/YouTube/WorldOfWarcraft/etc., would feel so bored and isolated they'd take on drudge work. Because these diversions are available, they don't.
What if 'gamification' and long-term unemployment/underemployment are connected?
- prodigal_erik 15y agoMcDonald's held a "National Hiring Day" this year, and accepted 62,000 applications out of a million. Even near-minimum-wage drudge work is scarce compared to the number who will take it. http://thecashflowisking.com/2011/04/30/1000000-applicants-for-mcdonalds-gives-a-representation-of-the-national-employment-situation/ http://thecashflowisking.com/2011/04/30/1000000-applicants-f...
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThat's a statistical fallacy along the same lines as "we only hire the top 1%". http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2005/01/27.html http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2005/01/27.html
- hello_moto 15y agoI'm trying to connect the dot here... What's the scarcity of job has anything to do with hiring the top 1% fallacy?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoFollowing Joel Spolsky's logic, there could easily be 938000 people who are unqualified for any job. On the other hand, every single one of the 62,000 qualified people who applied was hired. Thus, all employers will have low hiring rates, and yet finding a job is easy for qualified applicants. If you want to talk about scarcity of jobs, look at JOLTS data or even traditional BLS timeseries. Talking about how one particular employer rejected a lot of applicants tells you virtually nothing.
- ryanklee 15y ago> any job This is McDonalds. I'm having trouble thinking of employment for which more people are qualified if at least (1) able-bodied and (2) have at least a middle-school education. There is virtually nothing beyond those requirements that needs to be taken into consideration. If 938000 applicants were rejected, I can only assume that the majority of the rejections were for reasons other than lack of qualification.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoYou are missing one important qualification to work at McD's: (3) conscientiousness. When the boss says "someone pooped in the urinal", a McDonald's employee needs to say "yes sir" and go put on gloves. They also need to show up to work on time, take the 6AM shift when asked to, etc. Not all people are willing to do this. According to many sociologists, a large number of lower class Americans lack conscientiousness. Go read this dead-tree book, for example (sorry, online sources are hard to find): http://www.amazon.com/Promises-Can-Keep-Motherhood-Marriage/dp/0520248198/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1323532894&sr=8-1 http://www.amazon.com/Promises-Can-Keep-Motherhood-Marriage/... The focus of the book is on why poor single women choose to become single mothers, but it gives a great look into the work habits of the lower classes as well.
- ryanklee 15y agoInteresting, but doesn't the act of applying for a job itself guarantee to at least some extent that an applicant is conscientious?
- zubr1768 15y agoI think most people lack the fortitude. It's better to sit in silence for a moment and think, and take your time, than to 'check out' into the reward drip novelty as you so well described it. The next level, for me anyway, is to focus on creating stuff and making a business that contributes to the person who agrees with the above statement, rather than working to create the crap that sustains those who don't. How could such a perspective be integrated into gamification? In other words where the objective of the game is to make something that doesn't just rake in high profits and make one rich, but sustains and exemplifies an integrated, engaging existence on all levels?
- AznHisoka 15y agoThey are connected. Human beings need structure and a sense of purpose in their life. Games provide that structure when nothing else does. The problem is real life, overall is not as black and white as games. You don't become successful by following X, Y, and Z. There are circumstances we can't control. Whereas in RPG games, we know we can go to the next level, or beat that boss if we just keep grinding, just keep working. Real life doesn't work that way. It's frustrating.. there's no framework (well, there's a lot, but lots of choices = frustrating). RPG games, you just grind. Life is fuzzier.