4 ms·
I think that we won't be able to have full self-driving on standard public roads, for a while, where non-self-driving vehicles (and pedestrians and cyclists) mi
by ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago
I think that we won't be able to have full self-driving on standard public roads, for a while, where non-self-driving vehicles (and pedestrians and cyclists) mix with self-driving cars.
I think, if we had fenced-in and dedicated roads for self-driving cars, we could have had them yesterday.
But that ain't gonna happen anytime soon.
And we definitely won't be getting flying cars (for the general public), until we have full-self-driving.
- lm28469 4y ago> I think, if we had fenced-in and dedicated roads for self-driving cars, we could have had them yesterday. We could put them on rails and have overhead cables providing electricity efficiently, and make them go up to 300kph too, damn the future looks bright !
- jraph 4y agoMake them bigger so they can hold many people for one trip, while we are at it.
- melling 4y agoIt’s likely profitable and better for the environment if we get electric self-driving trucks on private highways. 70% of freight is moved by trucks. https://www.trucking.org/economics-and-industry-data https://www.trucking.org/economics-and-industry-data
- YawningAngel 4y agoThis analysis is immensely US-specific
- melling 4y agoIt would also work in China, of course. In fact, I would expect them to implement it first. https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2022/07/28/self-driving-tech-company-ponyai-plans-to-deliver-robotrucks-in-china.html https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2022/07/28/self-driving-tech-compan...
- acdha 4y agoTrains are an order of magnitude more efficient, however, and there’s a huge cost & environmental impact to building those extra highways. What we should be doing is more intermodal work where long-distance trucking is replaced with rail & local delivery.
- melling 4y agoYes, everyone knows trains are more efficient. They’re at full capacity and have been for decades. It’s very difficult to add train capacity. So, let’s not derail the conversation with your better idea that’s never gonna work
- acdha 4y agoThis is not even close to true unless you’re going to rescope your comment to focus on a few very specific chokepoints. There’s tons of unused mainline capacity because years of crew efficiency improvements mean the railroads are running fewer longer trains. More importantly, however, climate change means that we can’t continue to ignore externalities. Redirecting road expansion projects into rail construction would be necessary even if it wasn’t cheaper.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoGood one! I've always been a fan of trains. I seem to be in a minority, in the US, though...
- doubled112 4y agoTrains are awesome. My thinking is that the implementation sucks. I've been on a train twice in the last ten years. On the one ride, it was hot so it expected to arrive about 45 minutes late. You can't go full speed on hot tracks. On the same ride, there was construction, so we sat and waited for about 45 minutes in the middle of no where, in the dark. It was long enough they told us to just let our kids run around and brought the snack cart around for free. That's a lot of delay for a 3.5h ride. Ontario, Canada. My in-laws use trains to travel between cities a fair amount. More delayed trips than not. If you’re not talking about long distances, don’t get me started on the LRT in Ottawa and the months of downtime it has had.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- stephen_g 4y agoI was on a trip to Switzerland last month - across a couple of dozen train, tram, trolley-bus and regular bus rides, I had just a handful that were delayed - three to four minutes late (mostly on intercity trains that I'm going for an hour or so journey on, so it was basically nothing). But mostly they were bang on time. It's ridiculous, they're absolutely nailing punctuality, cleanliness, frequency, interchanges, mode changes etc.
- soco 4y agoAnd if you happen to miss the connection, no worries there's the next train in 30 minutes.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoIf you are in Tokyo, it's more like 3 minutes.
- OJFord 4y agoYes, if trains had roughly the frequency of hopping in your car whenever you want, and the density of roads, they would be used a lot more and many more people would not have cars. Cf. The London underground.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI traveled to Tokyo for twenty years. The Tokyo rail system is an official Wonder of the World. I never looked at schedules, and the trains were reliable and cheap. Crazy good.
- Mountain_Skies 4y ago
- matthewmacleod 4y agoThere is no possible good-faith way to draw that conclusion from a statement someone was making about the rail system in the world's largest urban area.
- RootKitBeerCat 4y agoYou’re a monoculture
- lm28469 4y agoAnd efficient trains can't exist in multi cultural societies ? Is that what you're trying to say ?
- acdha 4y agoWhat exactly is your point? This seems like a bizarre take on a massive city having good transit and it’s not like it’s some global oddity without parallel. Cars don’t scale and they have massive negative impacts for cities (health & safety, pollution, noise, inefficient use of space, etc.), and it’s not like there’s some unique trait which makes people recognize that.
- 4y ago
- weberer 4y agoIt is technically possible, but every time someone suggests self driving trams/trains/metros here, the public transport union threatens a strike.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoFind a way to eliminate mode switching and you might be on to something. Even transit activists recognize the high cost of mode switching and how much of a negative it is for practical use.
- teh_klev 4y ago> And we definitely won't be getting flying cars Seems I'm going to have to downgrade my New Year disappointment about "still no flying cars" to "still no self driving cars" (for the general public).
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI think we already have a couple of viable flying cars, but the issue is that we really don't want Bubba Beer Blaster driving in 3D, when he can't even handle 2D.
- oldandtired 4y agoEven if you have fenced in and dedicated roads, there are system control problems that will always arise. The more vehicles the greater the opportunity for failure of the system. Even today, simple systems like automated industrial plants have to have humans monitoring them closely to ensure that any errors that arise are actually handled properly. Once you put a large number of vehicles in play, the entire dynamics of the system would become unmanageable. You would require multiple hot redundancies at every level with human monitoring to at least minimise the things that could go wrong. It would only take one coding error for the entire system to fail and that coding error might only ever be found after some disaster has occurred. It might be nice to have self-driving vehicles but the cost may be so prohibitive to make it infeasible.
- RamblingCTO 4y agoThis always had the taste of being too US-centric anyway. European countries (and I guess the rest of the world as well) has very steep, narrow and weird roads and don't run on neatly organized grids. So it's even harder to achieve then just fencing cars and separating traffic.
- vidarh 4y ago> And we definitely won't be getting flying cars (for the general public), until we have full-self-driving. The irony here is that "flying cars" (which really means eVTOL planes) is in many ways an easier problem to solve in terms of navigation, because the notion of strict air corridors and tracking of every vehicle coupled with fewer annoying pedestrians wandering around makes it far easier to make those accommodations (e.g. virtual "fenced-in and dedicated roads")
- bigbacaloa 4y agoFlying cars aren't and won't ever be viable because of fuel consumption. We're already worried about ordinary cars in this regard.
- vidarh 4y agoThere has always and will always be a high end of the market, and that high-end will pay extra irrespective of fuel/electricity consumption. So in the sense that they'll likely never replace "ground cars", you're right. But that does not mean there won't be some space for them. The far greater problem for eVTOL companies than energy use is noise and safety which for the medium term at least will exclude them from the most attractive end-to-end options and prevent them from being a real car-replacement option. E.g. Lilium originally touted themselves as a sort of "flying Uber" on the basis that it could in theory land almost anywhere. But they dialled it back on the basis that being able to is very different from being allowed to e.g. land in a residential area without a dedicated, secured platform and following all kinds of regulations on both noise and safety. Now, they're instead focusing on partnerships (e.g. with Ferrovial for Florida[1] and Saudia for Saudi Arabia [2]) willing to operate networks of what they call "vertiports", so more of a replacement of a segment of helicopter services than cars. [1] https://lilium.com/newsroom-detail/ferrovial-and-lilium-develop-us-vertiport-network https://lilium.com/newsroom-detail/ferrovial-and-lilium-deve... [2] http://www.tradearabia.com/news/TTN_402471.html http://www.tradearabia.com/news/TTN_402471.html
- bigbacaloa 4y agoThere will never be a regulatory framework in which flying cars are allowed in urban airspace/ground space except perhaps in certain very special locations (like Saudi Arabia and maybe Florida) where there is rule of the rich rather than rule of law.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PinguTS 4y agoMy take on this is always: we will see first fully automated airplanes and railroad trains before we will see a widespread of autonomous cars. Airspace is an highly controlled area. We have many years of actual autopilots. We have many years of guided take-offs and landings. But still we relay on the skilled human. The same applies to railroads. Here in Nuremberg we have an highly automated train running on a railroad track that is even partly shared with trains operated by a driver. But the costs of running the automated trains seems not to benefit so that further development has been stopped, because of costs reasons. Even has we have a huge shortage in drivers, which would suggests that automation would be the solution. AFAIK there are only isolated airport shuttles that run fully automated. That means, if can't run automated systems in highly controlled areas. Then why would it work with cars in highly uncontrolled areas?
- matthewmacleod 4y agoAFAIK there are only isolated airport shuttles that run fully automated. There are several fully-automated rail systems worldwide. Paris M14 and the Copenhagen Metro among others are fully automated; things like the DLR in London are level 3 (driverless with a staff member on board).
- martindbp 4y agoIt doesn't make economic sense to automate trains and airplanes because 1. Much smaller part of the cost and 2. Very high stakes. Driving is high stakes too of course but two orders of magnitude less so. That said, we are seeing massive amounts of money being made in ADAS systems (Tesla FSD, MobilEye) while robotaxi plays are losing billions. Self driving cars will grow out of increasingly capable ADAS systems rather than robotaxis because they are already profitable and there's a gradual path to full autonomy. In the coming recession I expect most robotaxi companies to go under (Argo being the first yesterday), with Waymo being perhaps the only player left. Even Waymo may have to reduce spending quite a bit if Google is facing headwinds.
- f1shy 4y agoAnd what is the reason why most rail transport in the world is not already 100% autonomous?
- techdragon 4y agoNot saying this as a negative thing. Because having well paid, healthy and rested employees looking after stuff like maintenance, safety, stuff like trying to stop the train when some idiot parks the car over the tracks, or when a badly loaded rail car breaks loose and derails suddenly, or just generally driving in places where fully autonomous operations can’t happen for various reasons. But it’s the Unions. World wide one of the major things train worker unions have pushed back hardest on is smaller train crews for both passenger and freight… and it should be obvious why. It means companies that move to smaller crews would lay off union workers. Plenty of this is actually justified by good arguments put forth by the unions, particularly in places like America where railroads have basically refused to spend money in capital expenses and try to run with the oldest railroad hardware possible in order to maximise their profits per ton per mile shipped, regardless of environmental impact, crew fatigue, or the long term degradation of the entire strategic value of a national rail network that can move the heaviest military goods efficiently in times of war. You could not physically do automatic freight rail in America without getting people killed. The hardware and infrastructure are literally not capable of it. For all the automatic signalling systems in place, it’s all duct taped together around having a human in the loop that can be made responsible for decision making in the train driver cab. In more modern environments like say Switzerland, they probably could get much closer, but they also have a well regulated railway system with incentives that ensure the companies don’t need to be so brutally effective to make enough money to meet corporate profits. Then there’s places like the trans Siberia railroad… good luck keeping an automated network of that size operating within safe automatic bounds over winter, or the parts of the UK where there are still physical mechanical based rock fall “sensors” in place to alert drivers to their being rocks on the track ahead that may have only landed there minutes ago… and they don’t run enough trains on the tracks to make maintenance of network of cameras and motion sensors worth it. Railways are, when run well, very automation friendly environments. But that breaks down the further you get from a tidy metro area and surrounding country/farmland, further out into long stretches between cities or states where you would need to maintain thousands of kilometres of fences to avoid accidents, loss of property (stray farm animals) and the larger the network gets the harder it is to have it all owned and operated by a single company that could even begin such a project… sometimes you have a nationalised owner/operator but then it’s government budgets deciding if the actual rails and signals need the upgrades vs the potentially private companies that may own the trains and haul freight on the government’s rails… The real world is messy. So the union does kinda have a solid point. But that doesn’t eliminate the fundamental fact that at the “big moving objects on continuously welded rails” level of controls theory, railways are very automation friendly and are in theory able to be nearly fully automated.
- defrost 4y agoJust as a note, one of the largest iron ore mining operations in the world has been runing autonomous supervised Trucks and trains since ~2015: > Autonomous trucks [1] > We run more than 130 autonomous trucks, part of our Autonomous Haulage System, across our Iron Ore operations. The trucks are operated by a supervisory system and a central controller, rather than a driver. The system uses pre-defined GPS courses to automatically navigate haul roads and intersections and knows actual locations, speeds and directions of all vehicles at all times. > In 2018, each truck was estimated to have operated on average 700 hours more than conventional haul trucks, with 15% lower costs – delivering clear productivity benefits. They also take truck operators out of harm’s way, reducing the risks associated with working around heavy machinery. In Australia though .. starting from sheep shearing robots in the early 1980s [1] https://www.riotinto.com/en/about/innovation/automation https://www.riotinto.com/en/about/innovation/automation
- gremlinsinc 4y agoI'd like little Jetson pods on some sort of maglev tracks... But we'd need a lot of infrastructure to make that happen.
- timeon 4y agoSeparating traffic feels so 60-80s.