9 ms·
Bumble bees play, according to new research
- chomp 4y agoFrom the original study: > We found that ball rolling (1) did not contribute to immediate survival strategies, (2) was intrinsically rewarding, (3) differed from functional behaviour in form, (4) was repeated but not stereotyped, and (5) was initiated under stress-free conditions. ... > We suggest that the behaviour observed here has actual hedonic value for bumble bees, which adds to the growing body of evidence of a form of sentience in these insects
- nescioquid 4y agoThe researches adduce from those five findings that ball-rolling holds hedonic value for bumble bees. One of those findings was that ball-rolling is "intrinsically rewarding" to a bee. Isn't this what you call "begging the question"? It's hedonic because it is intrinsically rewarding. The article ends with the quote: "We are producing ever-increasing amounts of evidence backing up the need to do all we can to protect insects that are a million miles from the mindless, unfeeling creatures they are traditionally believed to be." It gives me the impression the findings are driven by the agenda to save the bees. Which makes me feel conflicted since I support the aim and have lay interests in philosophy of mind.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- comfypotato 4y agoBegging the question is when you conclude one of your assumptions. “That it’s intrinsically rewarding” is a finding not an assumption. The study was definitely influenced by the popular notion of saving the bees, but that’s not a problem! I’d rather read about bees having fun than any other insect! I hope others feel the same and a friendlier sentiment towards bees (because of the study, a little bit) helps the whole problem.
- nescioquid 4y agoThey said that because there's no apparent reason for the behavior, it must be "intrinsically rewarding". Is that really a proven conclusion, or a working premise? It's listed on equal footing with the observation that bees don't engage in the behavior under stress (also a finding). The later can be observed, while the former seems to need access to the inner experience of the organism.
- comfypotato 4y agoYou sound interested enough that you might enjoy bits of the actual paper [1]. They didn’t exactly say the bees stopped playing under stress. Instead they said the behavior isn’t a stress response (they know this because they eliminated stress from the environment). Also, the evidence that it’s inherently rewarding is bolstered by the pattern of interaction with balls. It increases over time and then drops (typical of play), and it is unrelated to mate/food finding. It’s very difficult to know what animals are thinking. The scientists say multiple times in different ways that none of this is conclusive (the longest section regarding knowing the behavior isn’t function-related). That being said, it’s a well designed experiment in my opinion. I think they did a good job of setting it up so that we can conclude: “why else would they roll the balls?” 1. https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Samadi-Galpayage/publication/364433874_Do_bumble_bees_play/links/635abaf16e0d367d91d13cca/Do-bumble-bees-play.pdf?origin=publication_detail https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Samadi-Galpayage/public...
- nescioquid 4y agoOkay -- thanks for being patient; appreciate the link to the paper and additional detail. I see the "question begging" emerged from me misconstruing the quotes from the paper above. I think I was especially skeptical because I wanted to believe the conclusion.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 4y ago
- Sharlin 4y ago> Isn't this what you call "begging the question"? It's hedonic because it is intrinsically rewarding. I think what they mean is that it was not connected to an external reward (at least not one that the researchers could identify). For example, they did not train the bees to roll the ball in order to get sugar water or something.
- LegitShady 4y agoI guess the question is how you would describe something like listening to music for a human. It would be 'intrinsically rewarding' and 'hedonic'. Why? because of our brain structures? Hard to say.
- pvaldes 4y agoSometimes things are not what they seem. We know that dolphins smiling are being aggressive for example. > "Bumblebees play because we humans think that they play" Or maybe they are just brain-wired to explore any strange object and instinctively clean any movable peeble, fruit, and object in the path of the entry of the colony. Cleaning the colony is a very common behavior reported in bees "We observed the pleasure centers in the brain activated in a scanner" is not the same as "we think that the pleasure centers in the brain activate because the bumblebee seems happy". One is an objective claim, the other subjective (and looks like designed to sell animism 2.0 and happy feelings). Subjective and tainted by the positive image that we had from bumblebees. Try to sell "happy spiders play football with fly heads" for example and everybody will conclude that spiders are the worst
- cad1 4y agoThere used to be a bumble bee that, I was convinced, would come around to play with my dog, a Labrador. It was entertaining to watch. When the dog was outside the bumble bee would hover near his face to get his attention. Once he noticed the bee he would growl, jump, and bite at the bee but not in an aggressive manor. It was in his playful tone, the same as when I played with him and his toys. Every time he lunged at the bee it would dart back and always stay just out of reach. Then the bee would zoom in closer and they would repeat this for a few minutes until one of them would get distracted. As far as I know they never made direct contact. RIP good boy
- silisili 4y agoAre you sure it wasn't a male carpenter bee? That's pretty standard(annoying) behavior for them.
- throwanem 4y agoThey have no stingers and, if you hold still, so will they. Fascinating to watch, although one did once try to crawl into my ear.
- silisili 4y agoYep. I hate all flying insects as they make me tense up like some fight or flight response... probably from being stung by hornets a billion times as a kid. That said, I learned to tolerate the carpenter bees on my deck because they'd bonk all the wasps away.
- sodapopcan 4y agoAt an old apartment there were some bumble bees that lived in my neighbour's fence (or at least that's what it seemed like) and every time I'd sit outside, they' come out and fly around all chill. Nothing aggressive ever, they'd just fly in front of me and sometimes I watched them and otherwise I'd just sit and work. I don't know what my point is anymore... bumble bees!
- jvm___ 4y ago
- lloydatkinson 4y agohttps://theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/16/bees-are-really-highly-intelligent-the-insect-iq-tests-causing-a-buzz-among-scientists https://theguardian.com/environment/2022/jul/16/bees-are-rea...
- he11ow 4y agoPaying it forward: An article by David Graeber I first saw here, where he argues the utilitarian evolutionary view (every action witnessed in animals is there to somehow increase changes of survival) is a relic of the industrial revolution. Instead, he says, playing is a key feature of life. https://thebaffler.com/salvos/whats-the-point-if-we-cant-have-fun https://thebaffler.com/salvos/whats-the-point-if-we-cant-hav...
- abfan1127 4y agowhat says play doesn't increase the chance of survival?
- guerrilla 4y agoIf you spend any time researching play at all, you'll find that's pretty much a universal view among scientists who study it. It's essential training and learning for survival. Love Graeber, RIP, but if that's something he claimed then he's unfortunately off on that one.
- abfan1127 4y agosorry, the universal rule is play isn't important, or the universal rule is play is important? Also, do you have some leads on sources? I'd be interested on reading up on this.
- guerrilla 4y agoI don't understand your first question... I think this[1] would be your definitive resources but if you can just search for "evolution of play" then you'll find a lot of stuff. Wikipedia has a hodgepodge of perspectives in section on the purpose of play [2] but you might be better off tracking down those citations. 1. https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/cambridge-handbook-of-play/evolution-of-play/9EAFEDC059FB72E575809219BDB444E0 https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/cambridge-handbook-... 2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Play_(activity)#Development_and_learning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Play_(activity)#Development_an...
- ethbr0 4y agoIn other bee-related, but different type, news today: "Honeybee Swarms Can Produce as Much Electric Charge as a Storm Cloud" https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/honeybee-swarms-can-produce-as-much-electric-charge-as-a-thunderstorm-180981005/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/honeybee-swarms-ca... Note: Title is incorrect. They're actually talking in terms of charge density. "As far as electricity generation goes, a bee swarm’s charge isn’t too impressive: It would take about 50 billion bees to power an LED light, Popular Science reports. But compared to the charges produced by common weather events, the bees’ charge density was six times greater than an electrified dust storm and eight times greater than a thunderstorm cloud."
- beebeepka 4y agoNot very surprising. We, as a whole, do not recognize intelligence in other creatures because it makes it so much easier to do anything with or to them. Damn shame for a number of reasons
- csallen 4y ago> …insects… are a million miles from the mindless, unfeeling creatures they are traditionally believed to be. Is it truly a common belief that insects are mindless and unfeeling? I would imagine the vast majority of people, when polled, would guess that insects have some form of consciousness and feeling. Of course, that doesn't stop people from squashing or swatting them when they get in the way. In fact, it hasn't fully stopped people from killing other people either.
- contravariant 4y agoThe word 'drone' refers to male bees or ants and seems to derive from an old Germanic word for insect. Not saying etymology is the best indication for what people think, but there is a connection there.
- scoofy 4y agoI think it's extremely hard to say, but I'd say it's hard to argue for sentience when the neural system is so small. This is a serious problem in philosophy. The concepts of "philosophical zombies" is a hard problem. The fact is that we could have perfectly "sentient behavior" from creatures/beings without any sensible consciousness involved. The sentience of humans is debatable, even though it is readily apparent that we experience qualia. Unless you're willing to accept that a rock, or a series of silicon chips, or even a massive mechanical computing machine can have consciousness, the blurry edge of where neural systems go from being electric discharges to a vehicle for qualia is an extremely difficult question.
- throwaway3838g 4y agoOne could imagine that human’s would appear unconscious to a hyper intelligent alien species. Perhaps it’s all relative.
- scoofy 4y agoYou're conflating consciousness with intelligence. The two are not the same. One is the experience of qualia, and the ability to hold preferences. The other is the behaviors associated with making predictions and intentionally manipulating the world to achieve tasks. We have a hyper-intelligent chess engines that cannot be argued to be conscious. We also have small mammalian minds, like Koalas, that are dumb as a brick, but are very likely conscious.
- scoofy 4y ago"Play" as a concept, is a clear social construct. The behaviors we call "play" is very obviously an innate instinctual behavior for humans, and is entirely plausible the same for bees. I see little here to suggest that this implies sentience apart from simple anthropomorphism.
- brnaftr361 4y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but in the framework of the evolutionary dogma as I know it, this behavior wouldn't make sense. It comes at the expense of energy and time, yielding no benefit, and thus is a net detriment and should therefore be bred out of the species with the one exception being some sort of higher process like emotional gratification. At least I can't imagine any sort of logical pattern where this improves fitness other than because it is emotionally gratifying, which I would posit necessarily intersects with biology beyond the very simplistic instinctual-automaton model.
- scoofy 4y agoI mean, I'm no expert, but I think this position is more than a bit rigid. We know that evolutionary development probabilistically yields maximized efficiency, but we also know there is plenty of room for drift and it can be a bit random. E.g. anti-fragile behaviors likely yield the best outcomes, even if they are less efficient, because the ultimate evolutionary failure is extinction (not death). Highly regular, efficient behavior are great for the individuals survival, but terrible for the species survival.
- comfypotato 4y agoThe play could also have benefits evolutionarily. While the behavior take energy, it teaches motor skills (which is more relevant to the younger bees who played more). I’m just using this (admittedly weak) example to show that play isn’t necessarily less than optimal behavior.
- brnaftr361 4y agoDon't get me wrong, I agree with you. I can recall several instances having arguments in my head when someone totally oversteps the probabilistic nature of evolution - those people were my professors. As to antifragile behaviors, I don't know that I agree completely. For instance there's a pretty considerable difference in strategies we observe with r (antifragile) and K (fragile) selection. But also hyper-specific species, for instance the famed Darwin's Hawkmoth: a moth previously unknown but predicted to exist by Darwin who posited that the pitcher flower with a narrow neck necessarily had some animal evolved to correspond to its adaptive strategies. That to me reads as the precise opposite of antifragility, an exclusive dependence would be fragile, and yet monophagy (very fragile)/oligophagy (fragile) is fairly common, and omnivorism (antifragile) is not. Though I suppose you could point to, in some instance, antifragile outcomes over the long run the sum risk for some of these organisms I intuit, outweigh the benefits of antifragile strategies. There are some interesting and definitively antifragile, some of the niche partitioning strategies are really quite ingenious. I would indicate the most antifragile creature is the human (literally real-time evolution), our wont towards ecosystem engineering may actually be our downfall. I've actually thought for some while a golden mean exists in antifragility, and too much investment in that direction leads to insensitivity to critical structural weaknesses through a couple of different pathways.
- stvnbn 4y agoI don't know why we believe animals are so different than us and then we get so surprised when they do things like us. We're like them!
- bmitc 4y agoI agree. It’s like we forget that we’re literally one of millions, billions, or trillions (it seems the estimated count is an open question) of species on this planet. No other species could possibly share analogous behavior.
- moosey 4y agoLacking evidence otherwise, I would say that we have to assume the internal experience of most life with central nervous systems are remarkably similar to ours, because we are remarkably similar. The next step is to take this into account in ethics, but I fear this is a leap that humanity in totality will not make easily.
- rhaps0dy 4y agoWatch the video of the bumblebee rolling a ball, it is incredibly cute.
- pseudolus 4y agoThe Washington Post ran an excellent story a few months ago about bee cognition: https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2022/07/29/bee-cognition-insect-intelligence-research/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/2022/07/29/bee-cognit...
- 1-6 4y agoPerhaps ML models should be able to ‘play’ as well.
- gverrilla 4y agoAmazing animals! I strongly recommend everybody interested in play to read Huizinga's Homo Ludens.
- nomilk 4y agoIs the evolutionary explanation for 'play' due to it honing motor skills and exploring environments, thus improving survivability? And if so, is it not reasonable to expect every species that benefits from honing and/or exploration to also 'play'? I don't find it surprising.