4 ms·
Do we really know if this isn't an over-zealous bot that say big names like P. Diddy and Snoop Dogg and decided that it was time to issue a notice? I still thi
by pyre 15y ago
Do we really know if this isn't an over-zealous bot that say big names like P. Diddy and Snoop Dogg and decided that it was time to issue a notice?
I still think it's an abuse of the DMCA power to have bots out there mining for things and sending notices without a human ever looking over its shoulder, but there's a difference between negligence and malice.
- chairface 15y agoI see no practical difference between a human issuing illegitmate DMCA takedown notices, or using a bot to do the same. The difference to the affected party is nil. "The bot made me do it" is not a legal defense.
- pyre 15y ago> "The bot made me do it" is not a legal defense. Please re-read my post instead of tearing down a straw man.
- burgerbrain 15y agoWhy should we care about the difference between negligence and malice? Should we respond differently? I would not be comfortable with that. Besides, let's not forget Grey's Law... (http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Greys_Law http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Greys_Law)
- pyre 15y agoFrom http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Greys_Law http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Greys_Law : > There is currently no text in this page. My point is not to get carried away by making claims like this: > “Dirty tricks in an effort to stop our massively > successful viral campaign.” If these claims turn out to be false, then you just end up looking stupid, even if UMG is still on the wrong side of the law.
- burgerbrain 15y agoHN seems to be eating an apostrophe between the y and s in that link. http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Grey's_Law Regardless, nobody reasonable is going to fault anybody for assuming malice from class acts like the MPAA. And if you apply Grey's Law, then they deserve the criticism regardless.
- chairface 15y agoI reread it. It still looks like you're drawing a distinction between a person flagging an "infringing" work, and a bot doing the same. I still think that there is no practical use for this distinction. Where's the strawman?
- pyre 15y agoThe strawman is that I'm not building a legal defense for UMG, whereas that seems to be what you've pegged me as doing. My message can be summed up as: Don't get carried away with conspiracy theories that UMG saw this successful viral campaign and felt that they needed to do something illegal to stop it. This video just ran afowl of UMG's "shotgun approach" to take-down notices, which just happens to be an illegal activity of theirs. I also find it highly probable that this was a targeted effort to get the video into the sights of whatever process it is that UMG uses to issue notices. UMG's 'shotgun approach' to take-downs is not limited to just UMG, and it is also nothing new. This has been going on for a long time. If you're only getting outraged about it now you're years late to the party.
- chairface 15y ago> Don't get carried away with conspiracy theories Followed by a conspiracy theory of your own: > I also find it highly probable that this was a targeted effort to get the video into the sights of whatever process it is that UMG uses to issue notices Classy.
- pyre 15y agoThat's not a conspiracy theory, no matter how much you think that you want to 'win' this Internet argument with me. You think that there was no thought put into the fact that if they put a video up on YouTube with a bunch of well-known artists in the name that they might get taken down for 'copyright violations?' It perfectly demonstrates their case, and with all of the publicity around the video itself brings the issue to a lot of the general public. Even if it wasn't a targeted effort, it seems like it turned out really well for them, IMO.
- rcthompson 15y agoIf a boot does it, then it is much more difficult to pin the crime on any one person, therefore much less likely to result in any consequences for any of the guilty parties.
- burgerbrain 15y agoIt's easy really. The person that authorized the bot to work on their behalf is responsible.
- rcthompson 15y agoI'm not saying it's logically more difficult, I'm saying that in practical terms, it puts one more hurdle (or maybe several) in the way of anyone who wants to hold the culprit accountable.
- sp332 15y agoNo. The bots might find the videos, but the DMCA requires a statement made under penalty of perjury to be submitted along with the takedown. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DMCA_safe_harbor#Takedown_example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DMCA_safe_harbor#Takedown_exam...
- alexcoomans 15y agoI'd have to agree with sp332, since I don't see how a bot would be able to legally sign a document - the legal backlash could be significant if a bot signed a document and that document was submitted without any human checks. Then again, it doesn't always seem like the media has regard for the law unless it is benefitting them, so it wouldn't surprise me.
- pyre 15y agoPeople seem to be misunderstanding my post. I'm trying to differentiate between: "I hate those MegaUpload people. I'll issue a false take-down notice to shut them up! Bwahahaha! <twirls mustache>" and "Oh. Another hit from our crappy YouTube crawler bot. <rubber stamps take-down notice>" There is a difference between malice directed towards MegaUpload and (willful) negligence. [ Also, don't reply with something stupid like, "but that won't hold up in court." Because a careful reading of the above text will reveal a lack of me making any such statement. ]
- bdonlan 15y agoTo be honest, I don't think it really matters. The point is, Universal is blocking access to content they (allegedly - I don't know if the artists involved have copyright assignment agreements or something) don't own. Whether or not this was intentional, it shows that the system is broken, and that we cannot afford to give them any more power than they already have.
- NegativeK 15y agoDMCA takedowns are done under penalty of perjury. I can't imagine a judge or a bar association taking a liking to a lawyer whose defense is "I was just rubber stamping these things."
- pyre 15y agoIt's a little frustrating that all of the responses to my post are "THAT WOULD NEVER HOLD UP IN AS A DEFENSE IN A COURT OF LAW! BLARG!" It's been long-suspected that these DMCA take-down notices are just being rubber-stamped, yet not one penalty has been handed out. Color me disillusioned with the legal process.
- wnight 15y ago> there's a difference between negligence and malice. Initially, maybe. But when it keeps going on because it's profitable, it's malice.