5 ms·
You might want to reconsider broadly slurring a bunch of your fellow citizens as "know-nothings" while writing a comment seemingly ignorant of the fact that the
by twoodfin 15y ago
You might want to reconsider broadly slurring a bunch of your fellow citizens as "know-nothings" while writing a comment seemingly ignorant of the fact that the Berlin Wall was designed mostly to keep people in.
- philwelch 15y agoActually, probably unintentionally, Know-Nothings isn't a bad term. The Know-Nothings were an anti-immigrant political party in the 1840's and 50's. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_Nothing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Know_Nothing
- anigbrowl 15y agoIndeed so. They were named as such not because they didn't know anything, but because of their habit of saying 'I know nothing' if questioned about their political activities. Immigration is kind of my specialty knowledge domain, actually :-) As for the Berlin Wall crack in the grandparent, of course I know the Berlin Wall was meant to keep people in. That doesn't stop people who want to militarize the border with Mexico from explicitly holding it up as a model. Read the comments on any Wall Street Journal story about immigration and you can be pretty sure of seeing it cited approvingly within a few pages.
- chernevik 15y agoSo it should be easy for you to provide a link to one.
- anigbrowl 15y agoActually not, because their commenting system uses flash so you can't search for/link to individual comments. As you can see from a simple Google search, though, I am far from the first to make the comparison: https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ie=UTF-8&ion=1#sclient=psy-ab&hl=en&safe=off&site=webhp&source=hp&q=%22berlin%20wall%22%20mexico&pbx=1&oq=&aq=&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=&gs_upl=&fp=d6a6b13212a1ff43&ion=1&ion=1&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_cp.,cf.osb&fp=d6a6b13212a1ff43&biw=1280&bih=866&ion=1 https://www.google.com/webhp?sourceid=chrome-instant&ie=...
- yummyfajitas 15y agoAll the examples on the first page of google (except maybe for the youtube and facebook links - didn't bother reading those) consist of proponents of increased Mexican immigration stupidly comparing a proposed border fence to the Berlin wall. However, I'll admit that I've also seen proponents of secure borders making Berlin wall comparisons under one circumstance. Often proponents of increased Mexican immigration claim a secure border is impossible to construct, and the Berlin or Korean DMZ is brought up by their opponents to prove they are incorrect.
- anigbrowl 15y agoWe just had a candidate that flamed out in the race for the GOP nomination speak with approval of an electrified fence. I have never claimed this to be the majority position on the right (it isn't; about 40% of GOPers support restriction ist policies), but if you think immigration restrictionists aren't in love with the idea of walling off the border you're in denial.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI never disputed that many people want to secure the border. I disputed that "people who want to militarize the border with Mexico [...] explicitly hold[...] it [the Berlin wall] up as a model."
- anigbrowl 15y agoPer your own comment, you are ignoring some sources, including those which present counterexamples. In any case, I suggest you back up from this indivudal tree and take a look at the whole wood.
- mlinksva 15y agoIndeed, "Apartheid 2.0", not "Berlin Wall 2.0".
- Samuel_Michon 15y agoI was thinking "Hadrian's Wall 2.0". http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadrian%27s_Wall http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadrian%27s_Wall
- abracat1 15y agoHmmm... That is a really bad comparison. I suspect that you misused the word Apartheid because of its emotional connetation (which circumvents any rational reasoning that a non-emotional argument might entail). Apartheid was concerned with the area people lived in the same country (in this area it might be seen as unjust - since people had citizenship to the country. Then again, SA is a country that should not have existed in the first place - the only ties that bind South Africans together is that they were all subject to British colonialism and their mutual dislike for each other). In any case, the Apartheid regime tried (very successfully) to prevent illegal immigration from neigbouring countries (since for some strange reason South Africa was the only industrialized country). This was done with fairly great success. The motivation for this was twofold: to prevent insurgents from infiltrating the country and protect the jobs of black people (the white minority government was fearful of black unemployment - for this reason unemployment of black people were far less than 10% then and regularly 30-50% after '94). Typing on i phone, continued below.
- abracat1 15y agoTo come back to my point - after '94 illegal immigration significantly increased. There are several reasons for this, e.g. The military was no longer responsible for enforcing the border (which fell to the police), liberal policies wrt immigration, Mugabe's experiments in Zimbabe, etc... Post '94 there were two patterns of migration - skilled people left the country (e.g. to Usa, Canada, aus and new zealand), and unskilled people immigrated to South africa (mostly from other African countries). The size of the illegal immigrant population is difficult to estimate, but probably 10% of the population. What was the result of this 'free' immigration? Higher unemployment for the poorest of South Africans, increase in crime (with a large part of crime done by unemployed illegal immigrants) and then of course the fairly recent xenophobic killings(which saw a return of the brutal necklacing killings). I think it would be justified to say that illegal immigration is the biggest threat to stability in SA today. TL;DR: South Africa should be used as an example of why immigration control is absolutely necessary. illegal immigration threatens the poorest of the poor (those struggling to find employment), leads to higher crime and threatens societal stability. Ps: typed on iPhone, please forgive typos. What is