14 ms·
Why I use Jellyfin for my home media library
- PaulHoule 4y agoI got so annoyed when Plex started bombarding me with spam for third-rate streaming services I'd never heard of. If I wanted to use a streaming service I wouldn't be using a home server to do it. Jellyfin is better in numerous ways but I can only get it to work sporadically with my Denon HEOS speakers, though it turned out I could just copy some music to a USB stick and stick it in my receiver to make a music server that works with HEOS.
- bshep 4y agoFWIW you can now disable the other streaming services, they annoy me as well and just today found a way to do it ( Settings -> Online Media Sources -> set all to 'Disabled' ).
- tomnipotent 4y agoExcept it's per-user. There's no way for a Plex administrator to disable it for all users.
- drexlspivey 4y agoBecause users can have access to multiple servers and each server admin don’t get to change their account options
- lostlogin 4y agoThis is part the problem. Plex for me is for accessing a specific server. Or maybe one more if I added it. It shouldn’t require internet access and shouldn’t break if internet goes down and the server is on my LAN. It isn’t for grabbing some stuff off the Plex site.
- dgllghr 4y agoI just started using Jellyfin and have been loving it! It works great and it has an impressively professional and polished UI for an open source project. The Jellyfin team is doing great work!
- chomp 4y agoI want to move to Jellyfin, but the network effect is strong for me. I'm in a pool of about 10 of my former coworkers and we've all pooled our Plexes together for years. Moving to Jellyfin would cause me to lose access to that.
- nepthar 4y agoWhy's that? I use both.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoSame. Jellyfin has been rapidly improving but I still mainly use Plex.
- Handytinge 4y agoI run a Jellyfin server, but I also run a Plex server for my non tech friends or friends already invested in Plex. You can have both.
- Fervicus 4y agoMoved from Plex to Jellyfin and have never looked back.
- c0brac0bra 4y agoThis is like worlds colliding. I only know Jeff Geerling because he apparently wrote every Ansible role in existence.
- ohthehugemanate 4y agoOh, man - Jeff is a giant in the raspberry pi and adjacent homelab and NAS spaces. I met him at events in the Drupal space, where he was a maintainer at the time, just showing off his first "bramble" (pi based kubernetes cluster). He is my favorite kind of open sourcer: genuinely curious with a love for explaining/helping people. Oh, and he's often on HN. Hi, Jeff!
- Handytinge 4y agoI also knew him from then, back in my days of administering thousands of macs, his roles were a godsend. Now I see him here all the time doing cool stuff with Pis and drives. I hope I bump into him one day, as our interests heavily cross, and he seems like a really nice guy.
- Daunk 4y agoBut I love my Plex! I can search for basically any movie, click "add to watchlist" and some magic happens behind the scenes and an hour or two later; that movie is in my library, ready to watch with subtitles and all. All my work buddies have the same system setup as well, so we're all sharing libraries to create an insane network of media, fit for any taste.
- curiousgal 4y agoYou can do the same with Jellyfin, to some extent. The free mobile app is the cherry on top.
- acoard 4y agoHave a docker-compose to share? I have Plex and love it too, but that "add to watchlist" type setup seems very interesting. Any links to point me in the right direction? I used to use sonarr and radarr in the past but used those directly, not via Plex, and to be honest I sometimes ran into issues with them but generally they worked fine.
- joshstrange 4y agoIt looks like Radarr (and I assume Sonarr) both have features to monitor that the watchlist in plex https://github.com/Radarr/Radarr/issues/5705 https://github.com/Radarr/Radarr/issues/5705 It's a clever way to do this without leaving Plex. I've used Ombi or PlexRequests in the past but they weren't my favorite and I finally gave up and used the sonarr/radarr UI directly.
- debacle 4y agoI dislike Plex's deceitful in-app advertising, but when I tried to set up Jellyfin there were some issues. That was about a year ago, probably worth the revisit.
- entropicdrifter 4y agoIt's in a much better state than a year ago
- philjohn 4y agoPlex pass makes it worth it for me with the native app on my LG CX OLED - if JellyFin could crack that I'd look to switch in a heartbeat.
- xienze 4y agoMight not be the answer you’re looking for, but Apple TV + Infuse is a fantastic media player. It has support for basically every codec so your server doesn’t have to be beefy — you can just direct stream everything. I stream full 4K UHD rips this way. And it supports Jellyfin, naturally.
- izacus 4y agoThat's a lot of money to pay just to get back functionality the previous poster already has.
- 4y ago
- bayesianbot 4y agoJust a heads-up if you need subtitles, for me and apparently many others with Jellyfin the subs get easily out of sync. The issue in Github[0] has been open for 2.5 years and seems dead.. Only option seems to be re-transcoding and burning the subtitles into the video (which is an option, but consumes some system resources). [0] https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin/issues/2547 https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin/issues/2547
- atchoo 4y agoI don't have any issues watching subtitled material straight through but I think I've seen it after skipping around and the workaround was to close the video and reopen it so it resumes from the right spot - not ideal but not a show-stopper at least.
- Avamander 4y agoYou can use an another player such as Infuse to avoid that issue.
- layer8 4y agoWhat’s currently the best alternative for video with subtitles? Ideally with the ability to control the position (subtitle shift) and timing delay.
- TheSpiceIsLife 4y agoVLC has the features to adjust subtitle timing. I've tried a few other players and media centre type options but always found them a poor dit for the few things I like to fiddle with from time to time.
- yamtaddle 4y agoFWIW I've never had trouble with the subtitles in Jellyfin on the Roku app, or on Infuse (AppleTV client). In fact I've practically never had any kind of trouble at all, aside from my Roku devices not supporting h.265 encoding. Android TV (a Shield, in my case) did have bad audio sync problems with several common audio codecs. My bad for trying to cheap out, should have just gotten the AppleTV to begin with. Bites me in the ass nearly every time I try to save money in that way.
- aleksiy123 4y agoThis only partially related. I recently killed all my subscriptions and swapped over to a plex + seedbox + sonar/radarr set up. The experience is good but not quite up to par with real streaming service. There are still rough edges. I always have issues with plex subtitles. https://overseerr.dev/ https://overseerr.dev/ is a nice addition for content exploration to the set up but for me the missing piece is being able to stream on demand. Does anyone know if it's possible to bridge the gap between streaming torrents and tv? Maybe webtorrents + casting?
- drexlspivey 4y agoFor subs you should use bazaar, it will download and even synchronize your subs automatically
- Cyph0n 4y agoSeconded. Just setup Bazarr and disable all forms of subtitle grabbing in the arrs and your media server.
- Avamander 4y agoOn-demand is discouraged and bad for the swarm, sorry. Though with a fair connection the delay before a full download shouldn't be too long. With a nice native frontend to Jellyfin/Plex (ex. Infuse) maybe you don't really need that? Maybe, just asking.
- rosnd 4y ago>On-demand is discouraged and bad for the swarm, sorry. Not optimal, but not bad in any way.
- f1refly 4y agoThere shouldn't be any reason for on-demand to be bad for the swarm, given that the downloading node continues to seed afterwards, no? If the user can watch the content because it's downloaded on-demand and automatically lets it stay on the drive until a ratio has been reached, isn't it win-win for both sides?
- raffraffraff 4y agoI stopped trying to get it to work over a year ago. This old Reddit thread is one of many where users are asking why the scan is so awful: https://www.reddit.com/r/jellyfin/comments/q3k3be/how_to_troubleshoot_hung_scanning/ https://www.reddit.com/r/jellyfin/comments/q3k3be/how_to_tro... That's basically why I stopped trying: the media scanner was atrocious.
- jeroenhd 4y agoHow puzzling; full rescans take my old i3 server less than five minutes and incremental scans are done in minutes. I wonder what's making the scans so slow for some and so fast for me. Maybe it's the file system?
- encryptluks2 4y agoA lot of people mount cloud storage for their media and scans take a long time to traverse and update that.
- raffraffraff 4y agoFor me, the experience was similar to the Reddit comments. I ran it in a raspberry pi 4 and had media on a USB attached disk. It would take hours, giving no feedback as it progressed. When finished, lots of movies and series would be missing, but there wouldn't be any failure log, so all I could do was inch my way through my whole collection on disk, checking which ones made it in and which didn't. I just gave up and installed Kodi. On the exact same hardware and media, it scanned quickly, giving updates as it went, and told me about failures when it was done.
- rodgerd 4y agoI generate NFO files with Ember Media Manager and that solves for anything that I want to use.
- GOATS- 4y agoJellyfin seems to struggle a bit with my anime library when the files don't follow a typical western TV show structure, but I'm otherwise very happy with it!
- Macha 4y agoHuh, anime is my primary use for jellyfin, it seems pretty fine for me with a Show/Season X/SXXEYY - whatever you want.mp4 structure. The one issue I've had is with Danganronpa but that's because the backing service for data (TheMovieDB) wants to insist that DR3 Future arc is part of DR1 and not related to DR3 Despair arc.
- GOATS- 4y agoI don't bother renaming files after I download them so they're left looking something like this: [group] anime name - 01 [fileinfo] [crc32].mkv This becomes problematic when you have shows like New Game, where the first is stylized as NEW GAME! and the second season is NEW GAME!!. Jellyfin shows them both as the first season of the anime, where as Plex with the Hama TV scanner can distinguish between them.
- cmeacham98 4y agoConsider installing Sonarr. Even if you don't use it to automatically search for episodes (its primary usecase), then you can use it to copy over from your download client to Jellyfin and rename the files to something sane that Jellyfin will always pick up.
- GOATS- 4y agoI already use Sonarr - I'm not a fan of maintaining separate libraries for original/renamed collections.
- mqus 4y agoTheir weird content/metadata detection is also what turns me off. Even just having a sane 'files' view with an arbitrary depth would be fine, bit it just does not work. They don't scan metadata like id3 tags. At least this is how I remember my impression when I tried it a year ago.
- BLKNSLVR 4y agoI migrated from Emby to Jellyfin pretty soon after the fork, and Jellyfin seemed a bit wobbly fit the first year and a bit, but then really kicked off and it's been stable for me for a long time. Primarily used through Android TV app connecting to a docker instance of the server.
- rodgerd 4y agoIt's interesting that he talks about anti-free software FUD with Plex vs Jellyfin, but Emby vs Jellyfin is pretty illuminating; I have a paid license of the former, and it's pretty telling that not only do they lag in many features, the support is remarkably for being unpleasant and rude, which is an interesting choice for paying customers. Even where they have a nominal advantage, such as clients, they're often remarkably limited in terms of things like Dolby playback or performance with UHD, so it's not clear what you're paying for.
- NTARelix 4y agoOver the last decade or so I've switched between Kodi (even back when it was XBMC on a literal Xbox [the original]), Plex, Emby, and Jellyfin; currently settled on Jellyfin for maybe a year and a half. I've also had a great experience with Jellyfin and love that it doesn't hide features behind a paywall. I agree that it has caught up with the competitors in terms of necessary features, but it occasionally feels a little buggy or in need of some UX polish. Perhaps one of my free weekends I'll see if I can contribute. One of the primary features I appreciate that the others have behind a paywall is the ability to download content for offline use. 1 less reason to open up my network's SSH port to the world. The feature is great for trips where connectivity is limited, or just at a friend's house with terribly unreliable wifi. I run Jellyfin on an Athlon II X4 (12 or 13 years old) with several other self-hosted services. Transcoding anything above 720p causes the entire system to come to a screeching halt, so I've pre-transcoded all of my content with handbrake to allow direct-play 4k content on all my home devices (Firefox, Shield TV, Chromecast, Android client, desktop client).
- joshstrange 4y agoI've said it a million times before but I'll say it again: You cannot pay for an experience that rivals Plex (or in this case Jellyfin). It's not about being cheaper, that ship sailed for me a long time ago, I've easily spent over $10K on hardware alone over the years but being in total control of your media is amazing. Want to share a clip? Just cut it and share it. Want to watch media on any device online or offline? No problem. Want to share with friends/family? Easy. I buy all my audiobooks on Audible but I rip the DRM off them, put them in Plex, and then listen to them through Prologue (amazing iOS audiobook app) because it gives me full control. I know this method is not for everyone (it does require a non-zero amount of technical knowledge, though I have set up systems for others that have worked with nearly no issues for years) but it's by far the best watching experience. No ads ever, instant playback, 1 UI/UX to learn, never asking "What service was that show on?", etc. If there was 1 streaming service that had literally everything and I could pay $300+/mo or so for then I'd probably jump at the chance. Instead you have to piecemeal together a slew of services that all have different UIs/paradigms and they remove/shift around content. I had high hopes for Amazon's "Channels" and Apple TV (The app, not the device, not the service, come on Apple....) but neither really got all the way there for me. I'd even pay each individual company if they gave me (aka Plex) an API to suck down the content without using their apps/websites.
- poglet 4y ago> I have set up systems for others that have worked with nearly no issues for years The two issues I had over the years was: My SSL cert expiring (not really a Jellyfin issue). My FireTV updated the Jellyfun app to a version that no longer supported the server version, this was pretty frustrating becuase I just wanted to sit down and watch some TV instead of messing around with a upgrade. In saying that; Kodi also ran fine for years without issue. My main issues with Jellyfin are scrubbing difficulties and subtitles going out of sync or not being able to change their timings, same with audio timings.
- actionfromafar 4y agoHad the same with an LG TV. Workaround by running with http (not https) on local network.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoI've had issues with seeking in Jellyfin that have kept me on plex (even though plex's codec support is much more limited)
- skippyboxedhero 4y agoSame. Jellyfin is so close, but scrolling to the middle of a show (even over local network) would take a minute or not work at all at the show would snap back to start. I dislike Plex so much.
- tempest_ 4y agoDespite the others in this thread Jellyfin works fine for me basically out of the box. I just run it in docker compose and there have not really been any issues.
- snoopy_telex 4y agoI want to use Jellyfin, however, I require mobile app downloads/syncs. I load up my iPad with content for trips and I'm not willing to give that up.
- m0ngr31 4y agoYou can download things in the Jellyfin app. You'll just have to use a different app to play the files (on Android at least. Not sure about iOS)
- Handytinge 4y agoThis is not the case on iOS. It is possible in Safari however.
- stock_toaster 4y agoI do this with the infuse client on ios, and it works quite well.
- Handytinge 4y agoThe iOS app is open source, so you are welcome to contribute a PR: https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin-expo https://github.com/jellyfin/jellyfin-expo It's maintaned by a single developer in his spare time, so I'm sure he'd appreciate it!
- syntaxing 4y agoJellyfin + Tailscale is absolutely fucking amazing. It easily replaces everything Plex does without any risk like Plex exposing your network from a bug.
- encryptluks2 4y agoUmm. Tailscale isn't going to offer a lot in terms of protection unless you're using a semi-reputable seedbox.
- contravariant 4y agoYou mean privacy wise? Because security wise I don't see how giving a third party access to your home network is better.
- Jaepa 4y agoYou can use tailscale + WireGuard as well. It just takes a bit of extra configuring.
- skippyboxedhero 4y agoThe whole network situation with Plex is totally f'ed. I used Plex for years, must have been ten years ago, and it all worked (how Jellyfin works now). As soon as they did plex.tv/relay, it all stopped working. I run Plex in Docker with Tailscale on the host, I have never managed to get Plex working properly on the Tailscale network. I have checked, it seems you can put TVs onto Tailscale...so may try Jellyfin again. But I remember subtitles also being buggy and awful scrolling perf...if I can get it on my TV, I would switch back. Plex's networking is just over-engineered trash.
- graftak 4y agoWith Jellyfin I used: - a ngnix reverse proxy container - a free cloudflare account - a free .ga/.tk domain name Now I can access Jellyfin (among other apps) over cloudflare proxied https wherever I am. It works flawlessly, in Jellyfin I did make sure to: - disable user login tiles - require strong passwords - disable admin rights from outside of my LAN.
- entropie 4y agoI have written a telegram bot (via node-red) that is basically a proxy for yt-dlp that allows my mother to download audio only from youtube videos/audiobooks and sort them into jellyfin for later download or to just listen. She has downloaded like 250gb so far and loves it.
- addandsubtract 4y agoI've written a couple of telegram bots to automate / scrape things for me. However, I haven't used node-red. What does it do for you?
- entropie 4y agoIts connected to home assistant and I do manage all my (home)automations via node-red with HA backend. It just made sense to use node-red.
- contravariant 4y agoI'm still somewhat unclear precisely what problem Jellyfin and Plex are supposed to solve. If you combine Jellyfin with something liks Radarr/Sonarr and Kodi then what do you need Jellyfin for? You could just cut out the middleman and connect Kodi to Radar/Sonarr directly.
- Cyph0n 4y agoThink of Jellyfin as a multi-user, centralized version of Kodi. Thanks to this, you get the ability to access (and give others access to) your Jellyfin instance remotely from virtually any device. Kodi can serve as either a Jellyfin client or as a local replacement. One thing to note is that the Kodi plugin ecosystem is much larger than that of Jellyfin, or any other media server solution for that matter.
- BeetleB 4y agoHa! I have the same question except for Kodi. Never could figure it out. My use case(s) for Plex: 1. I have media on my HD. Plex organizes it, figures out what show/movie it is, gets relevant metadata, and remembers how much I've watched it. 2. I then watch it on my TV. I don't want to watch it on my PC. 3. It lets me watch said media when I'm away from home (e.g. from a hotel room when I'm traveling). This is critical for me and what got me on to Plex. 4. It lets me share media with other users. 5. DVR: I pick the shows I like, and it records them for me. This is critical for me as well.
- contravariant 4y agoI think Kodi covers 1 and 2. Maybe Plex is slightly better at connecting to stuff like Chromecast / Smart TV? Those kind of walled devices aren't to my taste so I haven't tried them, well that and they didn't exist when I set things up. Do you use Plex as a client in all cases? There's a decent chance I just don't get it because I'm excessively particular in how I want things set up. Using a different video player on my PC is a non-starter for me. As is granting a third party access to files on my local network. So I've built my own solutions for pretty much any feature Plex has, except possibly user friendliness (which is the most likely reason I may use jellyfin, but not for personal use).
- nobody9999 4y agoI wanted to like jellyfin. It seemed like a great option for playing music. But the 17,000 music tracks in my library crashes the jellyfin server every time I tried to play music. Plex and Emby phone home all the time (why should they need to do that when all my media is local? No thanks!) And so I stick with Mythtv[0] (which really seems out of favor with folks these days) which has awesome codec support (I haven't had to transcode anything, it just plays -- probably because ffmpeg is their back end). It plays my music library, it plays and manages my 10,000+ item video library, supports a real remote control (in my case an Inteset 422[3]) via IR or Wifi. I can keep my backend (server) (VM with multiple data sources) and frontend (playback/library management) version sync'ed with normal update processes via the appropriate software repositories (in my case, RPM Fusion on Fedora, but other distros[1] have the same). It doesn't support streaming from Android/IOS/etc, but I just make my libraries externally available via Nextcloud[2], which meets my remote streaming needs. No, it's not perfect. Yes, the add-on ecosystem is pretty awful. The devs seem much more interested in the DVR functionality (which I don't use) than the video/music library functionality. That said, it's under active development with regular bug fixes and feature releases and has a fairly active user community. But there's zero external communication required (unlike Plex or Emby), nor are there any commercial integrations (well, if you want to use the DVR functionality you do need to buy a yearly subscription (IIRC ~USD$15) for the guide data, but I don't use the DVR functionality, so I don't need it). There certainly are limitations: 1. No streaming apps, but I don't care about that. If I want a streaming client I'll just use my roku; 2. Grabbing video metadata can be a pill if file naming conventions are too different from themoviedb.org and/or thetvdb.com; 3. No direct torrent integrations; It's not fabulous, but it works for me. And if you just want something to host/play your local media, it's pretty darn good. Did I mention that I have yet to transcode anything to get video (with or without subtitles) to play? [0] https://www.mythtv.org/ https://www.mythtv.org/ [1] https://www.mythtv.org/wiki/Packages#Targeted_Linux_Distributions https://www.mythtv.org/wiki/Packages#Targeted_Linux_Distribu... [2] https://nextcloud.com/ https://nextcloud.com/ [3] https://www.intesettech.com/product/4-in-1-int422-universal-backlit-ir-learning-remote https://www.intesettech.com/product/4-in-1-int422-universal-...
- hatware 4y agoJellyfin is terrible for music. MythTV? What decade is it? Try Navidrome, or Gonic.
- dan_quixote 4y agoSo far I've been happy with Jellyfin with one exception - the lack of AppleTV app. I've been using a third-party tool (MrMC) with limited success.
- domy 4y agoI'm very happy with the Infuse app connected to Jellyfin (also paying the $10/yr for the extra features).
- yamtaddle 4y agoAnother Infuse user here, can confirm, it's very, very worth it. The official app with have to be entirely perfect to lure me away, even if it's free.
- Jaepa 4y agoThere is a AppleTV client in the works that has a semi public TestFlight. I’m unsure how far along it is, however.
- kennend3 4y ago> So far I've been happy with Jellyfin with one exception - the lack of AppleTV app. Isnt this a reason to be unhappy with Apple? Jellyfin runs perfectly fine on MacOS, Linux, android set-top boxes and my Amazon firesticks.... Perhaps the app store and the walled garden is the real issue here? Without an ability to "side load" the app Jellyfin is forced to use the store?
- graftak 4y agoThere is a TestFlight Swiftfin app that is pretty decent. The only reason I still prefer Infuse (another Apple TV app that works with Jellyfin) is the more polished UI.
- Vaslo 4y agoI’ve wanted to love Jellyfin and it looks so nice but I have found for my Home Theater that Kodi is just better. I like Jellyfin for streaming on my iPad and for putting my downloaded tutorials. But Kodi just seems to have a lot more compatibility and handles HDR better. Just my 2 cents.
- 3np 4y agoThey play well enough together. You can use Kodi as a frontend to browse and stream from Jellyfin servers. There are two options depending on the level of integration you want with the Kodi library. https://jellyfin.org/docs/general/clients/kodi/ https://jellyfin.org/docs/general/clients/kodi/
- colordrops 4y agoThe nice thing about Jellyfin is that you don't need a special box connected to your TV. Jellyfin has various apps (e.g. WebOS and Roku, iOS, and Android), DLNA, and a web interface. I don't believe Kodi has those things but could be wrong.
- marcrosoft 4y agoI just dropped Plex for Jellyfin since they’ve been pushing their live crap in the menus and not focusing on user content. Jellyfin is awesome.
- MobileVet 4y agoI guess I don’t understand , You can unpin their channels right? I don’t see any of the Plex stuff, just my family’s media.
- marcrosoft 4y agoAre you on an old version by chance?
- 29083011397778 4y agoNot parent, but there is an option in settings that allows you to unpin (and therefore have to dig through menus to find) any media source on both Android and the web client.
- BeetleB 4y agoI echo what the other commenter said. There's a setting to not show Plex content on the main page. It's a total non-issue for me. I see the Plex content only when I intentionally select it.
- thinkmcfly 4y agoPlex interface used to be so good. I guess they can't un-shit in that bed now though
- faitswulff 4y agoI use Jellyfin somewhat reluctantly because of playlist management. If anyone knows an easy way to convert between directories and playlists (as in one directory represents one playlist) I’d be very grateful.
- BeetleB 4y agoJellyfin is very poor when it comes to EPG and DVR capabilities. Plex is king here, and is the main reason I paid for the Pass (very cheap for what you get). The last time I tried it was probably 6 months ago and it was still buggy for lots of basic playback - both on my Android and on my Roku.
- dexterdog 4y agoI never liked Plex for epg either. I use tivimate which is better than both of them and doesn't try to make me use the crappy Plex services.
- BeetleB 4y agoLooking at tivimate, it's not clear how I'd use it. I have a TV tuner card, and have an antenna plugged into it. How do I get tivimate to make use of it...? I'm sensing there's another piece in the middle that I'm missing.
- dexterdog 4y agoYeah, it's not for you. Tivimate is for IPTV. If I were just using antenna I'd have no problem using Jellyfin for it since there are not that many channels I would have active anyway, and I live between two major TV markets so I get plenty of OTA.
- tekchip 4y agoJellyfin's login system is a hot mess and makes it a non-starter for family use. Instead of going with the time tested login (saved) and then profile chooser (pin locked) they've decided that they would treat it like a PC with nothing but individual users. As a sort of after thought, they put in detecting if the user is connecting from the same network or not and letting a pin be used in place of the password. First Joe User has no idea if they're on an internal network or not and the UI doesn't disclose this (probably wise from a security standpoint). So the result is users just defaulting to using their long password (my security requirement) all the time. Inconvenient, but not a dealbreaker per se. Unless you, like me, don't appreciate hearing teenagers bitch every time they have to re-type their password. This issue is compounded greatly by the fact that the Roku app, and as far as I can tell, any other shared app situation, lets you either log the user out when closing the app, or save the login for some amount of time. In the first case we're back to the pain in the ass of every user typing their long password every single time they want to use the app (remember unsophisticated users who default to which method works every time). In the latter case in order to keep play history and such the previous user has to be logged out via a series of menus and then the new user has to type their long password circling back to where we started. They have implemented a profile page, but the profile page is BEFORE the login phase. Which means I had to advise my family to pick fake names and nondescript images for profile images because that profile page is accessible to anyone who finds their way to the page on the internet. Quite frankly absurd. I tried to outline this concern in the Matrix chat and the general take was "typing your password isn't that hard!" or responses that seemed to be strongly implying re-working this process would just be too hard or time consuming. I don't doubt the difficulty, but this situation makes an otherwise awesome system entirely unusable for an unsophisticated multi-user configuration.
- pwinnski 4y agoI've tried a few times with every alternative to Plex out there, but none of them seem to do a decent job handling the wide variety of video content in my Plex library. I've tried Emby, Jellyfin, and everything else. For someone starting from scratch, sure, pick whatever you want. But to migrate a set of gigantic libraries, ouch.
- merlincorey 4y agoCan you perhaps detail some of the issues you encountered for those of us who might be considering a change?
- pwinnski 4y agoThe last one I tried was Emby, sometimes during the pandemic, and it just flat-out didn't come up with a number of movies that matched the number of movie files in the directly I pointed it at. It also seemed to mis-match or fail to match many of them. Admittedly, I have a decent percentage of foreign-language movies, mostly in filenames with their English-translated titles, but Emby would often pick an English-language movie that did not match the filename exactly, while ignoring a Korean (for example) movie that did. IIRC, it was even worse when it came to TV. Fortunately, I was running it side-by-side with Plex, so after about a week of trying to get it to recognize my entire collection, I just gave up and deleted it. Your mileage may vary.
- washadjeffmad 4y agoDetection in Emby works but is... odd. I have Premiere. There's still definitely a "right way" to organize your library, but detection and settings have massively improved over the past year (I'm on 4.8.0.13). Probably 15% of my library has had to be manually identified, and 70% is non-English. Prioritizing the metadata sources helps a lot. Definitely a labor of love.
- heavyset_go 4y agoYou can use something like Radarr to put your movie collection into sane and consistent filenames and directory structures that apps like Jellyfin can parse well and store metadata in without issues. You can do the same thing with Sonarr for shows, and pretty much any ID3 tag editor with batch renaming for music. Both apps seem to have better identification and normalization features than Jellyfin does.
- heavyset_go 4y agoJellyfin has been great for managing my music collection after Google Music was discontinued, and it's also worked great for movies and shows. It would be great if Jellyfin could manage podcasts, too. There's a healthy client ecosystem for Jellyfin, and I prefer those clients over other podcast clients.
- faitswulff 4y agoUsing yt-dlp + Jellyfin has been a revelation for serving my kids safe, vetted video content. You can even download an entire YouTube channel at once. The kids aren’t at an age where they need that much novelty, so watching old favorites again and again is fine by them. I should probably also mention that we’re teaching them Chinese, so having an all-Chinese kids media library is invaluable. No English ads to break the immersion - no ads, period.
- throwthere 4y agoWe're trying to do the same with our kids-- finding kids friendly stations AND appropriate Chinese media. Could you share some of your favorite channels?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwthere 4y agoThank you!
- philsnow 4y agoI do exactly this (with emby instead of jellyfin though), with a cron job that runs this: #!/bin/bash -x export IFS="\n" find . -type f -name youtube-dl.batchfile | \ xargs -I {} -n 1 bash -x -c \ 'cd "$(dirname "{}")" && pwd && yt-dlp --config-location youtube-dl.config' each youtube-dl.batchfile is in a directory that corresponds to an emby library, and is a plain text file where each line is a link to something that yt-dlp understands (usually a youtube channel or playlist). The youtube-dl.config contains (among other things) --batch-file youtube-dl.batchfile to point to the batchfile, and --download-archive youtube-dl-archive.txt so that I don't re-download videos I've already retrieved, and also because it gives me a super quick way to exclude certain videos: either I can just go in and delete the file for a video I don't like (and instead of downloading it again, yt-dlp sees the ID in the archive and doesn't even bother trying to download it), or if I know of some I don't want it ever to download I can just pre-emptively put their IDs in the dl-archive file. So now when I find a channel I want to download for the kids, I just drop a line in a batchfile and either kick off the cron job by hand or wait.
- zeruch 4y agoJellyFin would be my server of choice if not for one nagging issue; it doesn't play nice with Chromecast OTB (also, subtitle management is a bit winky, but its been a while so maybe thats changed). Hence I'm still on the ever-declining Emby still.
- sergiotapia 4y agoGreat to see Jellyfin thrive. Ultimately after more than two decades of sailing the seas, I landed on a plexshare. I pay $20/month and get everything my heart desires in 4K Remux even, and it's so simple my wife can use it. The only way I see myself going back to self-hosting the content and media server is if hard drives suddenly become ridiculously cheap, like $100 for 16TB or something crazy like that.
- yamtaddle 4y agoIf you prefer shell for simple, solo services, over docker-compose: #!/bin/sh docker run -d \ --volume /opt/docker/data/jellyfin/config:/config \ --volume /opt/docker/data/jellyfin/cache:/cache \ --volume /mnt/Movies:/media/Movies \ --volume /mnt/TV:/media/TV \ --volume /mnt/Music:/media/Music \ --net=host \ --restart=unless-stopped \ jellyfin/jellyfin:10.8.5-amd64 Add and remove "--volume" entries as needed. You can have more than one movie or TV library or whatever, which is super-handy if you have kids because you can restrict their accounts to certain libraries. Consider using links from the main libraries to create the kids' libraries, if you want to have everything available, including kid stuff, on your adult account(s), as it's a little cleaner than adding both the adult and kid libraries to a single account. Left side is the host machine where the files actually live, right side is where it's mounted in the container. Replace the left side with whatever's right for your system. Names within the "media" directory in the container are arbitrary, but you will have to add each library in the web UI to make them show up, so it's worth giving them decent names. Replace the "/opt/docker/...." bits with wherever you want to store the config and cache on the host machine. It'll survive restarts/reboots with everything intact with just those two config-related mounts. the "--restart=unless-stopped" means you probably don't need to do anything else to get it to come back up on reboots. No messing with systemd or whatever, at least on many distros. Docker will take care of it. Version number's the latest release, I like to handle that manually so there are no surprises. I think they have a "latest" tag or similar that you can use if you don't care about that and just want it to always run the newest thing. Pro-tip: the youtube metadata plugin (not included by default) is far less smoothly-functioning than the rest of the system is (and also won't run on that docker image without some light modification—it needs youtube-dlp present) BUT many of the things from Youtube that you might want to watch on a real TV have entries on IMDB or thetvdb, so you can add them as TV shows, which is all-around a much better experience. For smoothest operation, organize movies like: /The Matrix (1999)/The Matrix (1999).mp4 /The Matrix (1999)/The Matrix (1999).en.srt /Star Wars (1977)/Star Wars (1977) - Special Edition.mkv /Star Wars (1977)/Star Wars (1977) - 4K77.mkv /Star Wars (1977)/Star Wars (1977) - Raw 35MM scan.mkv /Star Wars (1977)/Extras/From Star Wars to Jedi.avi I think you can define what you want the "Extras" directory to be called when you set up the library, and that's what it'll look for. "Featurettes" is another common name for that. If you do this, it'll automatically grab the right metadata like 99% of the time with no intervention. For TV: /King of the Hill (1997)/Season 1/S01E01.mkv /King of the Hill (1997)/Season 1/S01E02.mkv (et cetera) /King of the Hill 1997)/Season 0/S00E05 - The Making of King of the Hill.mp4 You can actually put almost anything you want in the actual episode file names, as long as it has that "SxxExx" pattern in it somewhere. Again, I think you can use other names for the "specials" folders if you configure it when setting up the library, but they're "S00E01" and so on in thetvdb, so I use "Season 0" If anything gets the wrong metadata, find its ID on imdb or thetvdb or tmdb or whatever, hit the hamburger menu on the thumbnail for it, click "identify", and enter your id in the matching field. That'll fix it. But this will very rarely happen if your naming is all correct. [EDIT] Nb. this may not be a great config for transcoding, I'm not sure it'll have access to hardware decode/encode with this. I avoid that by only using frontend devices that can handle all the codecs I have (AppleTV FTW) so nothing's ever transcoded, since my server can't transcode for shit in the best of circumstances, but that may matter to some people.
- dirtyid 4y agoDoes jellyfin have variable speed playback?
- ryankrage77 4y agoYes, 0.5x to 2x, in increments of .25x
- sandreas 4y agoDoes Jellyfin support audio books in a decent way? (I ask for your opinion and expierience - the docs state YES, but it is a huge difference between active support and being competitive with lets say audiobookshelf)
- psychphysic 4y agoMy only issue with Jellyfin is not freebsd support due to dotNet.
- baxuz 4y agoTried using Jellyfin but it doesn't play nice with a Windows machine as the server.
- compsciphd 4y agoI'm in the process of moving from plex to jellyfin (even though I have a lifetime plex pass). plex has some nicer things 1) skip intro built in and usable in all the clients I use (on jellyfin you can add it as a plugin, but not supported universally in clients) 2) the UI of plex is so much nicer/cleaner. Not a huge deal for me, but would be a show stopper for others 3) in all honesty, but much better library management (at a simple level, the ability to see what hasn't been "matched"/"identified") probably more, but I'm just at the start of my migration why did I switch? because jellyfin has 2 major features that plex seems to have no intention of adding 1) the ability to tonemap DV content to SDR (plex can tonemap HDR10 to SDR, but not DV, it be interesting in future if jellyfin would have the ability to tonemap DV to HDR10) 2) the abilty to have "external" transcoders. i.e. one can add cheap intel boxes (under $100) to get quicksync transcoding to an already existing installation. Can make it easy and cheap to scale.