4 ms·
TFA in this case is called "The Unamendable Constitution", which has some bearing on the way that changes in the relationship between the federal government, th
by PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago
TFA in this case is called "The Unamendable Constitution", which has some bearing on the way that changes in the relationship between the federal government, the states and the constitution have come to pass. I personally would prefer amendments that codified the current role of the federal government (and probably expanded it even further). But no such amendment process is feasibly within reach, and consequently, the evolution of US society has taken place largely outside the constitutional amendment process.
> A small federal government ensures that what the people of one state want has absolutely zero effect on any other state.
This is ridiculous oversimplification. The people of the states move, they travel, they do business, they have family and friends, across state lines. They also dump waste, use water, pollute the air, kill the wildlife .. across state lines. Recently, procurement of health care across state lines has also become a matter of increased necessity, thanks to the decisions of some states.
> A large central government is costly, ineffective and overbearing.
and is also the only thing that can provide an effective counterweight to interstate and transnational corporate power.
At the big picture level, I think you're fundamentally missing that the context that provided most of the reasons for the original existence of states at all has morphed so dramatically that continuing to insist that the only true conception of the USA is as a rather limited aggregation of states is just denying both time and reality.
We had a civil war to deny some of the people in some of the states the opportunity to hold others as slaves and/or leave the union. When the disagreements between states reaches certain levels on some issues, it is not possible for the union to continue unchanged. Those disagreements will lead either to war or dis-union. That was true long before the federal government expanded as it has in the C20, back when we were much closer to the loose aggregation that you seem to prefer.