4 ms·
Let a thousand Solyndras bloom! But seriously, exempting smaller firms and fundraising efforts from costly regulations is a good part of this initiative. Routi
by gojomo 15y ago
Let a thousand Solyndras bloom!
But seriously, exempting smaller firms and fundraising efforts from costly regulations is a good part of this initiative. Routing public funds through private investors, not so much.
While they're at it, they should completely eliminate the wealth tests for 'accredited investor' status. If some fig leaf of 'accreditation' is still needed, it should be experience-based or net-worth proportional. For example, everyone with certain business/economics/legal degrees or certifications (Series 7?) should be 'accredited' as knowledgeable enough for private investing. Or, anyone who has an equivalent amount of money in public investments or government-approved retirement accounts, should be able to invest that same amount with 'accredited' status in private investments.
- kevinpet 15y agoThe problems with proportional would be twofold: 1. How can the company taking the investment verify that the investor doesn't have other Angel investments? Remember: this is most important from a startup perspective to make sure you're able to do clean funding rounds without dealing with the fallout of non-accredited investors. 2. There's nothing to stop people from repeatedly losing 10% (or whatever percent you allow) on stupid gambles. I'm not convinced that academic credentials would be that useful either. I'd trust someone who's run a plumbing business for ten years far more to evaluate a startup investment than I would your average MBA. I thought it amusing that Swenson talks about university professors as if they are automatically financially sophisticated (one of the few points not backed up by data in Unconventional Success).
- gojomo 15y agoThere is nothing to protect someone who is reckless or gullible: they can lose all their money on currently-legal schemes, as well. If an investor provides false/incomplete documentation that their investment qualifies (as an acceptable proportion of their net worth or other 'government approved' investments), then that fraud should be the investor's problem when things go south, not the receiving company. Current 'accreditation' is not verified by the government, but rather asserted to the company/lawyers with enough credibility to convince them. Is someone who inherits a million dollars more qualified to invest $10K-$990K into a risky tech venture than someone who's actually earned $10K-$990K in the same field as that venture? Because that's the logic a dumb-money wealth test suggests.
- paul 15y agoI don't recommend angel investing for anyone who can't afford to lose a fairly substantial amount of money, which pretty much excludes anyone who isn't already an accredited investor. Finding the next Facebook or Google is a lot harder than you might think, and even if you did, they probably don't want your money. You are better off investing in your own self (education and the like). Eliminating the wealth test would mainly benefit scammers.
- gojomo 15y agoI wouldn't 'recommend' it either. But there's a difference between 'not recommending' and 'effectively prohibiting via a wealth test'. We don't prevent people from spending their entire net worth, and then some via loans, on poker or state lottery tickets. Nor do we include wealth tests against investing in public stocks, derivatives, real-estate, or dubious collectables – all of which can also 'go to zero' quite quickly, especially with easy access to leverage. Is private investing, especially in things like friends/family/personal-expertise-related startups, so much more treacherous than these other things that it alone needs special protections?
- paul 15y agoPublic stocks and the like are heavily regulated. If we let random people invest in startups, a bunch of people would get scammed out of their money, then there would be calls for more regulation to protect investors, which would only serve to hurt startups. Meanwhile, none of those little investors would make any money because the median startup is a bad investment (vs the median public company, which is an ok investment). Nearly all of the startup returns come from a small number of outliers, and those outliers will most likely continue getting funding from larger investors.
- gojomo 15y agoPublic stocks and the like are heavily regulated, yes, and they can still drive anyone's bankroll to zero. And via leverage or iteration you can make them as risky and rapid-loss-prone as private investments (or even outright scams). See for example: forex, real-estate, and casino ads in every medium. So this rule protects fools from losing their money in private investing, but they still have a thousand other ways to lose their money. Meanwhile, this rule also prevents lots of people of moderate means from making wise, moderate investments in areas they know well. These sorts of from-the-masses, for-the-masses investments wouldn't necessarily follow the valley hit-driven model of "nearly all of the startup returns come from a small number of outliers". But even if they did, why shouldn't people of all wealth levels be able to take their chances on finding an outlier? The current rule essentially says: the very best investments are only, by legal rule, allowed to the already-wealthy. Everyone else, here, buy a scratch-off.
- mkramlich 15y ago> Let a thousand Solyndras bloom! lots of alt energy companies? you bet. risky? of course. will some fail? always. do people make mistakes? yes. would you prefer instead that a thousand new Wall Street firms bloom? a thousand new oil companies? And Solyndra's cost to taxpayers, and impact on debt, is a tiny tiny drop in the bucket compare to what's been spent on Iraq and Afghanistan, or the Bush tax cuts for the richest Americans. put things in perspective, sorting by amounts, at the very least. I think we do agree on the idea that we should make it easier, or more meritocratic, to invest. And less bureaucracy. No arguments there. And there's a bill going through Congress now, I believe, and which Obama supports, to help do just that.
- Androsynth 15y agoI would rather the govt fund the research being done by the phds to develop the technology, then let them start their own companies. The US (especially the valley) has no shortage of funding for startups.
- mkramlich 15y agoagreed. well, somewhat. funding for software-centric startups is fairly easy right now. large capital/infrastructure-requiring startups is harder, and for mom-and-pop businesses it can be harder (though crowdfunding is shifting that, it appears.) making it easier for highly-skilled, rule-following foreigners (cough-Mexico-cough) to immigrate in and start at or work at US based startups, would be an easy win. And fixing the patent system. And defending the Internet from attack by big corporate interests. All would move the needle more than just making a little more money available for yet another shallow frothy "me too" web startup.
- DaniFong 15y agoThe biggest problems the government should be solving with energy are fixing the messed up regulation of the electric grid, and reducing subsidies for energy/oil. Currently, utilities have zero incentive to take any risks, and zero incentive to save money. They only act under duress -- essentially, when the PUCs force them to do something.
- politician 15y ago$2B, right? So, that'd be 4 Solyndras.