5 ms·
I feel like I am completely opposite of this dude. He hates dropshadows around windows. He hates the minimize-to-dock effect in OSX, saying it "wastes time". I
by egypturnash 15y ago
I feel like I am completely opposite of this dude. He hates dropshadows around windows. He hates the minimize-to-dock effect in OSX, saying it "wastes time". I just hit the minimize button and it took all of one second - one second in which my hindbrain was given a strong visual cue that I am switching out of one context. I use it regularly and I've never stopped to think about it.
I mean, a lot of the stuff he's saying feels "condescending"? It's all stuff that has preferences. You can change the size of icons. I mostly navigate my Mac's filesystem in the 3-column view.
He's bemoaning the fact that the OSX menu fades out when you leave it versus the System 3ish menus that just popped in and out. And honestly I can't say I notice the fade consciously either - but subconsciously I like it. It's instantly responsive when I ask for it, and it's got a nice slow visual effect as I'm done with it.
But then again, for all that I'm an artist with a bent towards minimalism, the OSX address book really doesn't bug me either. I quit using the iPad's calendar - but that's because it had a design directly taken from the revised OSX one, with that unusable-on-tablets row of tiny buttons for changing weeks. I really don't see supposed horrid UI sins like Calendar's torn page, it's just chrome that's vanished into the background.
He basically seems to be saying that all modern polish is crap and we should be happy with the looks that were pretty much required back in the 90s due to limitations. He disses new experiments like Metro as well, but really doesn't manage to articulate what his dream UI would be. Besides "oh god I wish I could use BeOS". Which looks... god, I feel like I'm using my Amiga when I look at that screenshot. Which I loved at the time but I've moved on.
- richcollins 15y agoWhere do you draw the line when it comes to distracting details in UI? Is the level of detail in current Apple products perfect? Should they move towards more skeuomorphic designs or more typographical designs?
- egypturnash 15y agoHonestly I am not a fan of the skeuomorphic stuff - that way lies the hundreds of ugly-ass mp3 player skins that look like some little physical device sitting on your desktop - but the Apple stuff has been relatively inoffensive. The version of iCal that I ditched is the one on the iPad, because it requires me to poke at tiny buttons on the bottom of the screen to go to next/previous month/day/week instead of just doing a nice easy swipe like every other iPad app trains me to do. (Or even like I can do in iCal on my Mac, if I'm interacting via the trackpad instead of my Wacom tablet!) I think it's worth noting that the latest version of iBooks on the iPad has an option to drop the semi-skeuomorphic* borders. It's a thing they tried. I wouldn't be surprised to see the cute borders vanish sometime. I'm also not a fan of PURELY TYPOGRAPHIC ui designs, as those require a TON of whitespace to work. There's a medium to be struck. Usually Apple does pretty well, I think; OSX as it stands now (Lion) is really, really good at quietly conveying information without screaming it. Maybe I just have a different idea of what's pleasingly minimal than the author of the piece at hand. I dunno. * I say semi-skeuomorphic because they don't change depending on how far you are in the book - if it did then it would actually be a pretty damn slick way of subtly delivering the same information as a scrollbar.
- richcollins 15y agoTypographical interfaces work well on mobile unless you're not a fan of navigation hierarchies
- jcampbell1 15y agoCommand-option-M should probably use a faster animation than the yellow button. I never minimize so it doesn't really bother me.
- mietek 15y agoThe OS X menu fade is a good example of a well thought-out UI animation. Note that the menu does not fade in, since this would actually slow the user down. Contrast this with certain other implementations.
- egypturnash 15y agoYeah, I'd never noticed it until this dude made me look at it. It's really, really nice! It also takes advantage of the way your brain works: you latch onto FAST changes, and kinda easily ignore slow ones. So when you open up a menu, BAM, hey, context switch time guys, here's a MENU. Then when you choose something or mouse out of the menu, it fades nice and slow - ignore me, I don't matter any more, your attention can go to the dialogue that just popped up because of fiddling with me, or back to whatever you were doing.