3 ms·
> There is no law of the universe that says it has to be possible to generate human-level sapience with less than one kilogram of processing mass. In all likeli
by ben_w 4y ago
> There is no law of the universe that says it has to be possible to generate human-level sapience with less than one kilogram of processing mass. In all likelihood we are never going to create a server with a whole city of intelligences in it, ever.
A computer with five times the mass, five times the volume, and five times the power requirements of the human brain, that can run an uploaded copy of a human brain at merely half the speed of a human brain, would still render Pluto and Mercury trivial to colonise with machine intelligences.
And if it cost a $100k (inflation adjusted) to build, and lasted 80 years before you had to melt down the hardware and reforge from scratch, it would still be cheaper than Musk's target for a human to Mars.
- sokoloff 4y agoThat’s for the computing power, not for the physical actuators which would be needed to provide power, other environmentals, and repairs.
- ben_w 4y agoThose are the easy bits. We've already got all of those, because that's how we make the machines we already use even today, and we would need them in any scenario other than genetically engineering ourselves to eat the moon, not just the uploaded brains scenario.
- sokoloff 4y agoDo you spot us all the supply chain that underlies today’s technology economy? Mere COVID disrupted that here; imagine what a few hundred million miles of space would do.
- ben_w 4y agoWe know what all that stuff is and how it works, making a fresh supply chain in a new place isn't handled by magical mystery cult of the gods… oh, Plutus, and Mercury are the gods of wealth, that's a coincidence.
- sokoloff 4y agoHow a lot of that stuff works on Earth is using abundant fossil fuels for mining, refining, and fossil fuels and biological material as feedstocks. In particular, it’s not obvious how to make volumes of virgin steel from iron ore without coke. (Electric arc remelting is fine for recycling steel to steel.) Much of the plastic supply chain starts as oil or gas. Wood is a major building component as well.
- ben_w 4y ago> In particular, it’s not obvious how to make volumes of virgin steel from iron ore without coke. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322275580_Electrolysis_of_iron_in_a_molten_oxide_electrolyte https://www.researchgate.net/publication/322275580_Electroly... > Much of the plastic supply chain starts as oil or gas. Wood is a major building component as well. If we really needed those things (why would we even want to use wood as a structural element on a space habitat?), we can build bioreactors from metal, glass, and water. Oil and gas do occur non-biologically e.g. Titan, but they can also be made from algae grown in a transparent tube exposed to sunlight and provided with the necessary minerals and CO2, which is trivial to make. IIRC the two limited resources if you needed biology and couldn't do it all with a clanking replicator are nitrogen and phosphate, everything else is easy to find basically everywhere.