3 ms·
> Don't we know that at 7bn people this hasnt been true for millenia? What has been true for millenia? That we need electrical machines to survive? Because tha
by sph 4y ago
> Don't we know that at 7bn people this hasnt been true for millenia?
What has been true for millenia? That we need electrical machines to survive? Because that's what I was talking about.
> This strange "nature utopianism" I have always found profoundly pesimissitic and "evil-projecting", since it locates evil in all the solutions to the problems of nature we have struggled to create.
Please do not rationalise your total misunderstanding by saying I am projecting evil. My comment was a simple reflection that a solar flare is one of those massive natural disaster with no direct (again for those in the back: direct) threat to life, yet has somehow sparked some ferocious disagreement as if I was calling for the end of times. Weird. Sorry I spoke out of line I guess.
That said, your comment is ripe with pessimism and fatalism, as if humanity in its entirety would be wiped out if we stop having light, hot water and stocked shelves in stores. We are more resilient than you give us credit for.
You went on a complete tirade that one should be grateful of modern life, because without it the only fate is unmitigated disaster, mayhem and apocalypse. We have thrived without medicine, massive child mortality and wolves roaming the woods. I never said if it were to happen today it would be easy, nor I called for the end of times, geez. I guess I'll stop here, I had no idea I would strike such a nerve with a simple observation.