2 ms·
Please stop trying to condense my arguments, as you seem to keep doing so and augmenting them with incorrect analogy. Your example with the Microsoft web browse
by angersock 15y ago
Please stop trying to condense my arguments, as you seem to keep doing so and augmenting them with incorrect analogy. Your example with the Microsoft web browser is disingenuous, as it involves a closed, proprietary system, and your suggested patch involves a workaround on the part of users.
This is a direct patch applied to an open codebase, which in turn allows users to reasonably expect that, there being no technical or resource obstacles to implementation, a platform port could be expected.
Your critique of my 5th statement is not unfair--I should've elaborate on the connection between "not important" and "no demand". I was in error. Your analogy using the iPad simply muddies the waters.
Your critique of my 6th statment is also unfair. The decision was arbitrary (we know that technical constraints don't exist, and that it isn't "free work" being asked for unreasonably). Asking people to just build it from source is not good for users, and forcing the creation of a fork of a codebase is not good for developers. You are being unreasonable, I believe.
The reasoning given for the decision is heavily based in arbitrary judgements not backed by valid engineering concerns (a lot of that low-level OS stuff? Yeah, actually pretty standard across operating systems, though the incantations may be different).
You sir, are either an idiot or a masterful troll -- I would pick the first, if only because it makes me feel better to think I haven't been trolled :)
I wasn't attempting to troll here, and I prefer not to think of myself as an idiot--then again, I also prefer to debate with people who can structure arguments without excessive namecalling or misleading strawmen.
- beagle3 15y ago> your suggested patch involves a workaround on the part of users. EXPLICITLY BECAUSE microsoft refused to patch internally, which is what you think antirez is doing wrongly! > Your example with the Microsoft web browser is disingenuous, as it involves a closed, proprietary system, and So? Where is the contract, written or social, that antirez signed, which predisposes him to accept patches that go against his philosophy of keeping the code base lean, simple and efficient? > This is a direct patch applied to an open codebase, which in turn allows users to reasonably expect that, there being no technical or resource obstacles to implementation, a platform port could be expected. THERE ARE TECHNICAL OBSTACLES, CLEARLY DETAILED BY ANTIREZ. You might disagree with them, but they are not empty words. And furthermore: WHY? WHY SHOULD IT BE EXPECTED? > The decision was arbitrary (we know that technical constraints don't exist, PLEASE READ ANTIREZ AGAIN (AND AGAIN (AND AGAIN)) THERE ARE LEGITIMATE CONCERNS WHICH YOU FAIL TO ACKNOWLEDGE > The reasoning given for the decision is heavily based in arbitrary judgements not backed by valid engineering concerns (a lot of that low-level OS stuff? Yeah, actually pretty standard across operating systems, though the incantations may be different). So please explain to everyone how easy it is to do copy-on-write from memory to disk without pausing and without fork() -- because THE GUYS AT MICROSOFT WHO SUBMITTED THE PATCH DON'T KNOW HOW TO DO IT. THEY THINK THEY MIGHT HAVE A SOLUTION BUT HAVEN'T POSTED ONE YET. > You are being unreasonable, I believe. The only unreasonable thing I am still doing is replying to you. We apparently live on different planets. ANTIREZ HAS NO COMMITMENT TO THE GOOD OF USERS OR DEVELOPERS. Furhtermore, ANTIREZ BELIEVES AT THIS POINT SUPPORTING WINDOWS WITHOUT FORKING IS AGAINST THE GOOD OF USERS, DEVELOPERS AND HIMSELF, as he has clearly stated. > I also prefer to debate with people who can structure arguments Funny ! I'll come back to this post when I need another laugh!