19 ms·
> Machines that learn, sure, but conscious machines, no way. If we're trading compelling arguments, then there is one for consciousness not only being unnecess
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
> Machines that learn, sure, but conscious machines, no way.
If we're trading compelling arguments, then there is one for consciousness not only being unnecessary, but also a drawback that evolution would happily optimize away given time, and basically not worth the energy it burns.
I don't have a handy list of papers to support this, but I can recommend two novels by Peter Watts, Blindsight and Echopraxia, both of which deal with this idea (apologies for sort-of spoiler), and which both do come with references to academic publications backing this and other ideas used in the books.
- naasking 4y ago> If we're trading compelling arguments, then there is one for consciousness not only being unnecessary, but also a drawback that evolution would happily optimize away given time, and basically not worth the energy it burns Considering we don't know what consciousness is or what it does functionally, any such argument is a fairy tale at best. It might contain some interesting insights or lessons, but don't mistake it for reality.