3 ms·
My comments here to Psychology, Psychiatry and drugs vs CBT generally cause a lot of people both outside and inside the field to say "you don't know what you're
by ggm 4y ago
My comments here to Psychology, Psychiatry and drugs vs CBT generally cause a lot of people both outside and inside the field to say "you don't know what you're talking about" and I think at one level, its good feedback. I surely don't.
But I also know from personal experience, that "the science" here is often shallow, and badly thought out, and carries way more consequence for mis-interpretation than it should. Even the jokes about "... in mice" don't really convey the problem. "In 20 young women from mid-california, in the early 2000s" gets more to the feel of it, or ".. in a group of intensively mentored 16 year old men, being rescued from the prison system and sent back if they didn't participate" or "amongst students who accepted the test for a $90 fee"
Since the arguments are used to justify CBT (which I like) and drugs (which I dislike, although I do acknowledge they work for some people) or radical treatment options like ECT (which nobody likes, but which may be the gold standard to judge other approaches simply because we have so much data about it over time) -I think this is doing the field a huge disservice.
I now expect a torrent of "you don't know what you're talking about" comments which will be from Pharmacology experts, pedants who want to point out I am not discussing psychology or psychiatry "properly", self-experimentors who are trying nootropics, mushroom freaks, gym freaks, clean eaters, dirty eaters, dirty 94 year olds in Iran who live in a barrel and eat food waste...
But truly: any field which does bad science is doing itself a massive disservice. If the field is on the fringes of social policy, medicine, public health, treatment, its not just a massive disservice to the field, it has life-harming consequences for individuals. Really, it needs to stop.