3 ms·
The Bill of Rights is particularly brilliant in its conciseness. A lawyer once said that "show me a contract that's one page, and I won't be able to break it.
by WalterBright 4y ago
The Bill of Rights is particularly brilliant in its conciseness.
A lawyer once said that "show me a contract that's one page, and I won't be able to break it. Show me one 20 pages long, and I'll break it."
- the_only_law 4y agoYet somehow it still gets broken.
- dragonwriter 4y agoSo, by your standard, the Bill of Rights can’t be “broken” by a lawyer, that is, they can’t get a court to apply it in something other than the intended manner. But virtually every significant phrase in the Bill of Rights has been applied in multiple different ways by different courts over the years, so clearly lawyers have had no trouble breaking it.
- stale2002 4y ago> so clearly lawyers have had no trouble breaking it. You are missing the point. The point is comparing it to a hypothetical constitution that is 20 pages long, instead of 1 page long. So, the 20 page long constitution, is probably easier to break, despite you misleading focus, on the irrelevant point, of the exact way the statement was phrased.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe BoR has been under continuous and relentless assault for well over two centuries. It is battered and bloodied, but has held up surprisingly well.
- candiddevmike 4y agoThe recent abortion ruling disagrees with you. Same with the Patriot Act.
- dbsmith83 4y ago> The recent abortion ruling disagrees with you. How?
- dragonwriter 4y ago> The recent abortion ruling disagrees with you. While it is in many ways the main provision that gives meaningful impact to rights both in and beyond the BOR (though the 13th Amendment competes with it on that front, since if people can be treated as property instead of people, they have no rights) by applying them to the main locus of government authority, the states, which the BOR itself neglected to do, the 14th Amendment, which was at issue in Dobbs, is not part of the Bill of Rights. So Dobbs doesn’t illustrate an assault on the Bill of Rights so much as its irrelevancy in the absence of subsequent amendments.
- christophilus 4y agoYep. It’s like software in that sense. Show me a concise program, and I may be able To find some bugs. Show me a complicated behemoth, and I guarantee it. The founders understood the nature of power, and thus the importance of decentralization and diversity.
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoThis lawyer must not have been aware of the marvelous legal doctrines of mental gymnastics and motivated reasoning that often get applied to such phrases as "persons and effects" or "shall not be infringed". And let us not forget the definition tricks that get played with words like "search" and "speech". edit: Sarcasm should be obvious. Point is if enough key parties want to ignore the law it gets ignored and upheld.
- WalterBright 4y agoOh, I'm aware of that. I have a bone to pick with a lot of the SC rulings. But also consider that nobody has yet been put in jail for harshly criticizing the President. And you can still buy a gun.