3 ms·
I am not comparing vPro to Mao, and no reasonable person could construe my comment as comparing vPro to Mao. I am comparing vPro (and similar hardware backdoor
by kragen 4y ago
I am not comparing vPro to Mao, and no reasonable person could construe my comment as comparing vPro to Mao.
I am comparing vPro (and similar hardware backdoors) to the totalitarian central government control established by the PRC in the early 01950s, in compliance with widely accepted Communist doctrine, which resulted in inevitable atrocities several years later — in this case, the Great Leap Forward, which was the worst famine in human history. Mao was far from unique among heads of totalitarian states in carrying out mass atrocities. Like hardware backdoors today, totalitarianism was new enough at the time that reasonable people could disagree about its likely effects, but in retrospect the causality is obvious.
I do not have an iPhone or Android device in my pocket (although I do carry one on special occasions), watch "curated" TV content on a "Smart TV", drive a modern car, or use [Microsoft] Windows or OSX. Furthermore, there is no basis for you to suspect that I do these things; you are attempting to drag HN down into the slime of Twitter-style "gotchas" instead of attempting to rise to the level of collaborative exploration of the truth.
Moreover, even if I did suffer these afflictions, it wouldn't make my argument invalid — even if it were not so wide of the mark, your inept attempt at a rebuttal is at best an argumentum ad hominem of the same sort as those who dismiss Noam Chomsky's criticism of US foreign policy on the basis that he pays US income tax.
I am disappointed in your total failure to engage in rational argument. You're arguing at the animal layer of vague emotional associations rather than reasoning about causes and effects. Please, try to do better.
(I do use ISP-provided DNS, which is a problem but not in the same category.)
- Alupis 4y ago> I am disappointed in your total failure to engage in rational argument I really fail to see how one could believe it rational to discuss Mao, Holocaust, and Stalin in the same conversation as computer processors. This conversation can only be taken as extreme hyperbole.
- kragen 4y agoDismissing the argument because you're not familiar with it doesn't demonstrate anything but your own ignorance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_and_the_Holocaust Undoubtedly when Mao drove the Kuomintang out of the Mainland, there were people who "really fail[ed] to see how one could believe it rational" to fear that within a decade Mao would starve to death ten times as many innocent people as the Kuomintang had ever murdered, particularly since such a large democide had never happened before in history. Then, it happened.