3 ms·
No, they don't pay a fee. You pay a fee for making a purchase. Local retailers should be arguing that they don't want to be the tax collectors, so their price
by Terretta 15y ago
No, they don't pay a fee.
You pay a fee for making a purchase. Local retailers should be arguing that they don't want to be the tax collectors, so their prices would look lower too.
Either way, you, the buyer, are responsible for paying the sales and use tax, regardless of whether you bought from BestBuy or Amazon.
Again, both BestBuy and Amazon "get to do business without paying that fee", as it's not something either of them pays.
To enjoy the competitive advantage of having a local presence, BestBuy does agree to help your local government collect your taxes (and in fact gets to KEEP a percentage of the taxes they collect!), while Amazon, who is not in your local jurisdiction, relies on you to pay the tax you owe.
- storborg 15y agoSo I assume you willfully pay your tax on all online purchases?
- rdtsc 15y agoMy state had line item on the tax form asking for the amount of goods purchased online so then they can tax them. Always wondered what people put in there and if the state even did anything about it (audited people). I guess they could ask Amazon for records (threatening a lawsuit) and cross-reference with all the reported taxes based on name and address. If user bought just from Amazon more than what they reported they they have obviously owe some money + fines & late fees. (But I suppose I am making gross assumptions about the competence and general technical abilities of my state's tax collecting office).
- Terretta 15y ago> could ask Amazon for records (threatening a lawsuit) http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/10/judge-blocks-north-carolina-attempt-to-get-amazon-sales-data.ars http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/news/2010/10/judge-blocks...
- rdtsc 15y agoOh wow. I was thinking of a different state, but this is interesting. It already happened and I missed it. First it was anonymous purchase data. Then NC demanded user names and addresses but Amazon fought on 1st Amendment grounds and seems to have won: “The First Amendment protects a buyer from having the expressive content of her purchase of books, music, and audiovisual materials disclosed to the government,” I wonder if this was Zappos for example. What would have been the ruling.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- extension 15y agoLocal retailers should be arguing that they don't want to be the tax collectors, so their prices would look lower too. That seems to me to be what they are arguing. However you want to look at it, the government is forcing them to force their customers to pay more, and not forcing Amazon to do the same, for no justifiable reason.