4 ms·
If I'm not mistaken, 4 actually very much does follow from the preceding points. The code is brought into existence. Code is observed to be capable of being mo
by angersock 15y ago
If I'm not mistaken, 4 actually very much does follow from the preceding points.
The code is brought into existence. Code is observed to be capable of being modified into working on Windows (i.e., nothing radically platform-centric about it). Microsoft provides the grunt work to accomplish a patch that proves this observation true.
Very much, by definition, users can reasonably expect a Windows port. The capability exists. The code exists. The patch functions. If Windows User Clippy says "I expect that redis will be ported to Windows, given these facts", Clippy is not being unreasonable.
I'm sorry, but to claim otherwise is merely being obtuse.
Your points about IIS7 and Transmit are correct, as those rely on specific OS functionality that is unique--the constructs Redis uses are not, and again code has been written to show this fact.
Now, there very much is something to be said for Salvatore (antirez?) not having to do this work for free. Indeed, VMWare may be spending a good chunk of change paying for his services ( http://antirez.com/post/vmware-the-new-redis-home.html http://antirez.com/post/vmware-the-new-redis-home.html ). I do not wish to suggest that he go uncompensated.
What I do wish to suggest is this:
VMWare: this dude you are paying to develop a widely-used and respected project has (seemingly arbitrarily) turned down code submitted from other practitioners in the field. He has suggested they fork the project (diluting the quality of the Redis brand and potentially removing resources that could improve mainline Redis). He has suggested that the project is too difficult to make cross-platform; I'm sure that you folks might have a different opinion on how important cross-platform support is.
Pay him more to make a better project (with help from people in the community!). Or acknowledge that he is correct in his assessment that this is somehow a Linux-only problem. Or do something else to help him figure out how his goals align with the VMWare mission.
- tptacek 15y ago318 words that say almost nothing, because they are premised on the ideas that: * If someone writes a patch for your project, the burden of proof is on the maintainer not to accept it, rather than on the submitter. * If someone domiciles their open source project at VMware, they assume an obligation to all of VMware's customers. Neither statement has any truth to it. You're just throwing stuff at the wall to see what will stick, which is why your comments are turning light grey and mine aren't. Can I ask you an orthogonal question? What's the last project you used Redis on? How'd it turn out for you? What do you like about Redis?
- nknight 15y agoMost laughable is the idea that VMware would have any reason to ask him to make Redis run on Windows. They make a lot of money off enabling easy deployment of diverse operating systems.
- antirez 15y agoAbout that, VMware does a remarkably cool work to be fair with other companies (at the point I had problems understanding this behavior in the first months: in Europe competition is sensed always as something dangerous and I'm glad that VMware attitude is different), and in this specific instance I did not received any pressure about avoiding to support win32, actually I got some suggestion to be more open if the win32 port will become more reasonable/complete.
- beagle3 15y ago> If I'm not mistaken, 4 actually very much does follow from the preceding points. Then you should go back to logic school. Let me make it clearer for others reading this, as yourself appears to be a lost cause: (1) Microsoft develops web browser (2) rendering could theoretically be made standard compliant with minor changes (3) people submit style sheets and javascript files that, if included in a web page (or embedded into IE) would achieve that functionality. (4) Users can reasonably expect Microsoft to do that. Wait, what? Furthermore, your logic breaks in other places: (5) ... there is no demand for it (from article: "I don't think Redis running under win32 is a very important feature."). How does "not important" imply "no demand"? Let me give you an example that will make it clear: "Apple just said that getting Win7 apps running on the iPad is not important". You bet there's demand for that, and yet that does not make Salvatore's or this (fictional, but realistic) Apple quote wrong in any way. "important", unless otherwise qualified, is to the speaker. (6) Users have been denied functioning code because of arbitrary decision by guy. Wrong. They could just build it from source. Less convenient? Well, it takes just one person to package it and make it into an .msi. Furthermore, the decision is not arbitrary -- you may disagree with the reasoning, but he gave detailed reasoning. You sir, are either an idiot or a masterful troll -- I would pick the first, if only because it makes me feel better to think I haven't been trolled :)
- tptacek 15y agoWe shouldn't call people idiots, or, really, trolls. Berate the argument, not the commenter.
- beagle3 15y agoThat's true. And I mostly follow this. When the other person consistently ignores logic and invents their own facts and reality, I occasionally adopt the Linus strategy; but I still take care to address the argument itself. Point well taken. HN is a better place thanks to people like yourself.
- tptacek 15y agoBlah, I'm 100x worse than you are about calling people names, but for what it's worth: if you write a similarly worded comment to me, I'll try my best to thank you for it instead of getting bent out of shape. :)