3 ms·
Solar-powered smelting would be great but this is not it. This is melting metal, not smelting it, which means reducing non-metallic ores to metal and is the cr
by kragen 4y ago
Solar-powered smelting would be great but this is not it.
This is melting metal, not smelting it, which means reducing non-metallic ores to metal and is the crucial technology that allows people to use metals in the first place (other than copper). See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smelting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smelting:
> Smelting is a process of applying heat to ore, to extract a base metal. It is a form of extractive metallurgy. It is used to extract many metals from their ores, including silver, iron, copper, and other base metals. Smelting uses heat and a chemical reducing agent to decompose the ore, driving off other elements as gases or slag and leaving the metal base behind.
Likely the most effective way to reduce iron or copper from ore with solar power at a human scale would be electrolytic metal reduction: hydrometallurgy or electrometallurgy rather than pyrometallurgy.
Pyrometallurgical processes at human scale are painfully inefficient; see Christopher Roy's documentary "From iron ore to iron hoe: smelting iron in Africa" or John Plant's more recent experiment "Primitive Technology: Iron knife made from bacteria", both available on YouTube for the time being. These are both charcoal-powered rather than sun-powered, but I think the higher temperatures attainable by solar power will only increase the process's efficiency modestly.
The false claim is original to Jelle Seegers (see https://archive.fo/qk3dZ https://archive.fo/qk3dZ), not introduced by Kris De Decker, but you can be sure that De Decker will not correct the error. He is consistently enthusiastic about continuing to promulgate his false claims even after they are pointed out.
- tinco 4y agoNot sure if it's a false claim per se, as "smelten" is Dutch (Jelle being Dutch also) for melting. A device that melts things in Dutch would be called a "smelter". Of course, in his description he does use the English word melting correctly, but he also describes what it does correctly, so maybe he's just being artistic about it.
- kragen 4y agoMaybe it's just an error due to a false friend? I didn't know "smelten" in Dutch meant "melting". Etymonline says English actually got the word from Dutch: > smelt (v.) mid-15c. (implied in smelter), from Dutch or Low German smelten, from Proto-Germanic *smelt- (source also of Old High German smelzan, German schmelzen "to melt"), from PIE *smeld-, variant of PIE root *mel- (1) "soft." Thus the word is related to melt (v.). Related: Smelted; smelting. As usual, once the word was adopted into English, it started rapidly changing in meaning.
- vanderZwan 4y agoTo add, Kris de Decker is Belgian and speaks Flemish natively so is also likely to fall for the same mistake
- kragen 4y agoThank you!