3 ms·
Why only cash buyers? Even if I am borrowing money to pay for something, I would rather pay less than more.
by lotsofpulp 4y ago
Why only cash buyers? Even if I am borrowing money to pay for something, I would rather pay less than more.
- ltbarcly3 4y agoThis is correct, you will pay more to service the loan but only until you can refinance it. If you pay more in a low interest rate regime you have no way to improve your situation, and no way to sell if you need to.
- _huayra_ 4y agoYes, I would rather pay usurious rates with a commensurately low price. Even though it would be terrible basically having the vast majority of my monthly payment going purely to interest for a long time, it's possible to: - refi at a lower rate in the future - sell the house without having to take a huge loss compared to low-% bagholders
- mminer237 4y agoBecause you would theoretically be paying the same amount, just paying it as interest instead of principal. It's not practically that big of a deal, but it does mean you would have less equity. If you had to sell it, you would get much less back, and you might have more taxable gain if you don't qualify for §121 exclusion.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> If you had to sell it, you would get much less back, and you might have more taxable gain if you don't qualify for §121 exclusion. This is a separate calculation of how much one can sell their house for relative to purchase price, unrelated to preferring low interest rate/high purchase price or high interest rate/low purchase price. But based on decades of interest rate history, it would seem prudent to bet the Fed will lower rates again in a few years and you can refinance to a lower interest rate.
- mminer237 4y agoIf you buy a $225,000 house at 7%, you pay $45,000 down and $1,200/month. If things stay like that and you move after five years, you'll have about $169,500 left on your mortgage and thus get about $55,500 back out, $10,500 more than your down payment. If you buy a $410,000 house at 2%, you pay $82,000 down and $1,200/month. If things stay like that and you move after five years, you'll have about $286,000 left on your mortgage and thus get about $124,000 back out, $42,000 more than your down payment.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoYou would have to account for the difference in down payment and opportunity cost of investing the $37k difference in down payments for the same period. So in the 7% scenario, you have $37k + investment return + $10.5k. In the 2% scenario, you have $42k.
- mminer237 4y agoI guess that's true. Assuming you yourself also get 7% interest, that would be another $15,000 you'd get, making you only lose $16,500 more.
- BuckRogers 4y agoYou can win like a cash buyer if you pay a 2nd payment every year. If you plan on paying the minimum though, you definitely lose at 7% vs 3%. You are correct. As long as someone drops that extra payment monthly or yearly, depending on the amount and if you ensure it all applies to the principal with your lender.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> If you plan on paying the minimum though, you definitely lose at 7% vs 3%. I do not agree with this, because the lower downpayment needed for lower purchase price means more of your money can be invested. The option is not pay a low price for home and get 3% mortgage. The option is pay a high price for home (and high downpayment) and get 3%, or pay a lower price for the house, and get 7%, and I would bet you can then refinance this 7% to something lower in the coming years.
- BuckRogers 4y agoThe refi is an unknown and incurs closing costs again. That's a big gamble, and if it were guaranteed to work out, everyone would get an ARM. I view those statements as a "put your money where your mouth is, get an ARM", but few do. I agree with you if the lower downpayment is proportional to the cost difference incurred between 7 and 3%. It hasn't been so far, not even close. I've run the numbers for my own purchase and 7% over 30 years is completely insane compared to 3. I highly doubt at 7% with minimum down you can beat the interest payment by investing in the market. Even if not, there's risk that you won't gain off whichever investment is chosen. While paying off a home early (no matter the interest rate) is guaranteed to pay off financially. From both the reduced interest payments and freeing up your income sooner.
- lotsofpulp 4y ago> It hasn't been so far, not even close. Yes, it will take a little time for the supply and demand curves to adjust. And, of course, popular/richer areas may not adjust down as much as less popular/poorer areas. > Even if not, there's risk that you won't gain off whichever investment is chosen. This is political, but if the US government lets its stock market indices fall/stagnate over the long term (5 to 10 years), we probably have bigger problems to worry about. > Even if not, there's risk that you won't gain off whichever investment is chosen. While paying off a home early (no matter the interest rate) is guaranteed to pay off financially. FDIC guaranteed savings accounts are offering 2.5% to 3% these days. I presume a higher mortgage rate means higher guaranteed savings account rates.