5 ms·
I'm always amazed at how people in the US/Canada shower, with the water running constantly. It not only seems like a waste of hot water, but how do you even soa
by stavros 4y ago
I'm always amazed at how people in the US/Canada shower, with the water running constantly. It not only seems like a waste of hot water, but how do you even soap yourself up when the water is just washing everything away immediately?
Where I'm from, we take Navy showers[1], where you only use water to rinse things off. Basically:
1. Run water on you so you get wet everywhere, turn the faucet off.
2. Apply body wash and shampoo.
3. Turn the faucet on and rinse everything.
4. Done.
The actual water-using portion of this is less than a minute.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navy_shower https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navy_shower
- benj111 4y agoThe UK shower like that too. Gas boilers with long pipes means you need to wait for the hot water to come through, and if you stop it again you then have a load of cold water just waiting to take you by surprise.
- stavros 4y agoIt only takes you by surprise once in your life, after that you just run the water away from you for a second while the warm water comes in. Since we have handheld shower heads (another thing I can't believe the US lacks), it's no problem at all.
- benj111 4y agoYes but if you're waiting 20 seconds for the hot water everytime it makes it not worth it to switch the shower on and off.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThe water in the hot water pipe will not have gone cold during the short time it takes to clean one’s self.
- benj111 4y agoNo but the boiler takes time to come on so at some point it's going to run cold because cold water is flowing through the pipe before the boiler turns on. I suppose you could time when the cold water is going to arrive an step out of the shower for it to flow through, but my point still stands, it's a pain and just easier to leave the shower on.
- samatman 4y agoI miss handheld shower heads! Europe was so great. Cutlery too. The United States doesn't have kitchen knives, we have to tear meat and bread with our hands, it's terrible.
- edflsafoiewq 4y agoThere are shower heads that you switch to a trickle for this reason. You still save a lot of water but the trickle keeps the hot water coming through.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoThe water in the pipe won't get cold in the 2 mins it takes to soap your body.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoThat sounds much more efficient, but it also sounds like a great way to freeze in the middle, when you're all wet but don't have hot water to warm you back up. Maybe in warmer climates?
- stavros 4y agoWe use shower curtains or enclosures, the steam does a very good job of keeping you warm for the few minutes of waterlessness.
- gnicholas 4y agoHow does this work if you're only using water for a minute, per your original comment? Does it generate enough steam to keep you warm for the few minutes of waterlessness?
- stavros 4y agoYeah, the shower cabin/curtained bathtub is a fairly small space, so you don't need the entire bathroom to steam up. It's comfortable for many minutes afterwards.
- gnicholas 4y agoInteresting, maybe I'll try this in my smaller shower. My challenge is that (1) we have a low-flow showerhead, so there's not much coming out even when it's on, and (2) our showers are far from the water heater, so it's the least-hot receptacle in the house. We set our water heater temperature pretty low, and by the time it gets to the shower it's less hot and not so steamy. I wish there were a unit we could attach right at the nozzle that would give it a little boost!
- stavros 4y agoHm, yeah, that doesn't sound ideal :(
- 4y ago
- scottLobster 4y agoYou lean/step out of the water to apply stuff and then lean/step back in. Are your showers the size of coffins or something? I get the efficiency of Navy Showers, but water is cheap where I'm at. Would be a lot of extra effort and discomfort for negligible savings. Maybe it makes sense if you live in a desert or, as the name implies, you're on a ship
- stavros 4y ago> Are your showers the size of coffins or something? No, we just don't like wasting water/heating. I don't know how much extra effort it is to turn the tap off when you're done with it. It definitely doesn't feel like effort to me, and having the water run while I'm trying to avoid it so I can soap myself up is very annoying. > water is cheap where I'm at. You are in a thread where people are installing heat pumps to reclaim the wasted heat. Is saying "how about you don't waste the heat in the first place" really that crazy?
- scottLobster 4y agoIf it's a micro-optimization that produces no real value, then perhaps it isn't crazy, but is irrational if the goal is to save meaningful amounts of money. You can also compress/save used aluminum cans and periodically sell them to a scrap metal dealership for money. Quick check shows scrap aluminum cans are selling for a national average of $0.45/lb, and it takes about 32-35 12 oz cans to accrue 1 lb of aluminum cans. Assuming you go through a 24 pack of cans per week, enjoy your ~$1.30/month savings for hours of effort!
- stavros 4y agoYeah, well, to the millions of people for whom that's just "how one showers", your way seems needlessly wasteful, like heaping food on your plate only to throw most of it away. At least food is cheap, I guess!
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI remember the push for showers over bathtubs to be based on the argument that they're X% more water-efficient. I would imagine this refers to "Navy"[0] style, as not turning off the shower for the entire duration will easily waste a few bathtubs' worth of water. How cheap is water in your place you'd consider this a micro-optimization? In my country, unless you're tech-salary-equivalent-or-above, not doing it - and doubling or tripling your hot water (or water + gas) bill - would noticeably cut into whatever discretionary spending money you have. Micro-optimization would be "grey water reclamation" with a bucket placed in a sink, to reuse hand-washing water for flushing the toilet. Which is something my wife and I started to do a while ago, and while we don't need to do it, the drop in utility bills for near-zero effort is impressive enough that we continue anyway. ---- [0] - Or should I say "Standard Showers", as I literally can't think of anyone who doesn't turn off the water for soaping after being made aware that water and heating both cost money.
- zo1 4y agoNo thanks, I'm not a poor animal struggling to survive during my brief existence on this world. I don't see why we should feel guilty as if we're wasting something. All that water goes back to the environment, hopefully through your garden instead of municipal sewage, and for those really self-conscious about energy use, most of the heat to make that shower water warm was renewable. Municipal sewage is one of the main things we need to focus on atm. We essentially mix black water with grey water, turning the whole concoction into black water that needs to go through sewage treatment. Woohoo, government screwed us over yet again. Instead, we should re-use grey water in the garden or at least have a separate municipal dump for grey water.
- danans 4y ago> , and for those really self-conscious about energy use, most of the heat to make that shower water warm was renewable. That's highly dependent on location and time. And even if it's renewable, it isn't necessarily cheap, and the people in this article are mostly motivated by high energy prices, not renewability.
- jpadkins 4y agocan you really use soapy water in the garden? Won't that harm bacteria and the microbiome?
- pookha 4y agoGrateful I live in the US and not one of these places where people can't take showers. Good lord.
- kipchak 4y agoIs it still wasteful if I enjoy taking hot showers? There might be some health benefits too, but I also just enjoy them as part of waking up in terms of loosening up my chest and relaxing muscles. My total yearly spend on showers is about $100 a year, and there's lot of things I'd give up before that to save $100, in dollar or energy use terms. https://www.omnicalculator.com/everyday-life/shower-cost https://www.omnicalculator.com/everyday-life/shower-cost
- mxuribe 4y agoI've never heard of this handy omni calculator site, especially the "every day" section. Seems like a neat set of utilities! Thanks for sharing!
- fho 4y agoAlso great for debunking basically every "cool new urban wind turbine" based on the amount of energy in the wind alone: https://www.omnicalculator.com/ecology/wind-turbine https://www.omnicalculator.com/ecology/wind-turbine
- ars 4y agoI can't do this - it takes me several minutes to adjust the shower water temperature to the correct temperature after turning it off. (The difference between boiling and freezing is like 1 degree of rotation, I'm only slightly exaggerating.) Eventually I'll get a new valve, but right now changing the water flow also changes the temperature.