37 ms·
Massive solar storms are fascinating to me. They seem to be quite common in the scale of "catastrophic disasters", there is a chance it would completely destroy
by sph 4y ago
Massive solar storms are fascinating to me. They seem to be quite common in the scale of "catastrophic disasters", there is a chance it would completely destroy the modern life we are used to, yet compared to other catastrophes, the damage to human life would be minimal.
Sure, someone really depends on an electrical gizmo to survive, but most of us would wake up to a world without machines that we rely on daily, yet everything we actually need to survive is intact. There are fruit on trees, water is still flowing and drinkable, boars still roam the forests.
It would be like waking up to a very familiar, yet completely alien world for the vast majority of us.
- dan_mctree 4y ago>yet everything we actually need to survive is intact. Unfortunately we now rely on our machines to survive. If they'd suddenly disappear, we'd have a bit of a massive problem. We just wouldn't do very well without our heavy agricultural machines, our food and fuel supply systems, our water pumps, our fertilizer plants, etc. We're not going to feed 7 billion people without machines anymore, so we'd better fix them fast or risk losing a lot of us.
- i386 4y agoSadly being proactive about these issues is not incentivized in our society until something very bad happens. Recent events come to mind.
- mjburgess 4y agoThis view always facinates and alarms me. Don't we know that at 7bn people this hasnt been true for millenia? We're talking c. 5,000 apes in a jungle last time this made sense. Don't we know that the earth isnt just provided by god designed for human life? We have been nearly extinct many times, and our labour is required (via, at least, hunting) to make the world habitable for us. Don't we know that nature is a place of choas and extremes, and technology and economics exist primarily to prevent the day-to-day mass death which was common? Don't we know that half of the 100bn who've ever lived died before 20? Don't we know that famine, mass death, mass infant death, mass death in child birth (5-10%), etc. are "the default" ? This strange "nature utopianism" I have always found profoundly pesimissitic and "evil-projecting", since it locates evil in all the solutions to the problems of nature we have struggled to create. If you think "turning off civilisation" will have us wandering around forests, you're about gauarneteed to see what people have done over the last 200k years as evil.
- mach1ne 4y agoWhile hunter-gathering is no Garden of Eden, I don't think it's as bad as you describe for the simple fact that evolution has molded us to it specifically. Earth isn't designed for human life, but human life most certainly is designed for Earth.
- mjburgess 4y agoNo, I dont think so. Would you say that to all the extinct species? There's nothing guaranteeing you don't starve. There is no design. Genes are just "random reproductive bets" with fairly high probabilities of failure over the long-run. The environment is basically guaranteed to change faster than your species can evolve, including via meteor. I dont think the rabbits who die alive eaten by foxes, and the foxes which starve from eating all the rabbits regard that cycle as "designed for them". Nor likewise, were the dinosaurs that impressed by the sky going dark. This idea that "we had a home" or "there was once Eden" in any respect is wrong. The life which we were evolved for is one in which if you survived 10, then you might not survive the lion, and if you survive that, not the volcano, and so on. Your body is just a bet made over millions of years, and not one any conservative gambler would take.
- mach1ne 4y agoExtinct species become extinct because there is some change in their environment to which they are not successful at adapting. Generally speaking, neither the human genome or the wilderness of Earth has changed since we built our first huts. You're correct in your regard for exceedingly high child mortality, though it bears no weight on the survival of humanity as a whole in a technology-breaking event. The human body is indeed a bet, and one that has paid off for ~300,000 years and about 12,000 generations, if we start counting from Homo Sapiens. I'd very much take that bet any day.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wiredfool 4y ago
- keewee7 4y ago>yet everything we actually need to survive is intact. There are fruit on trees, water is still flowing and drinkable, boars still roam the forests This is completely wrong. The natural biomass is not enough to support 7.8 billion people. Without modern industrialized food production the vast majority of people are going to die.
- causi 4y agoYes. Even rolling agricultural technology back a hundred years would require killing off fifty percent of the population.
- dotancohen 4y ago> rolling agricultural technology back a hundred years would require killing off fifty percent of the population. Only 50 years! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_rice https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_rice
- _0w8t 4y ago[dead]
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoWhat machines were you planning to plant and harvest that wheat with?
- _0w8t 4y agoAnother example is farmers in Belarus during WWII. Often the whole villages together with tools and machinery if it was any were burned down due to heavy fighting. People survived by living in dugouts and planting potato’s by hands. Potato in especially suitable in such situations. It brings more calories per area than even rice while one still can harvest it using basic sticks. While it cannot be stored for years after the harvest as wheat, it still can last for couple of years.
- 4y ago
- pronlover723 4y agoAs someone that once lived without running water for just 5 days because the electric pump to my apartment was broken I can say pretty confidently that that minor experience was enough to make it clear to me, most of us can't survive without "modern life". If there's no electricity there's no running water. That means no more flushing toilets. No more water to drink. If there's no electricity that means no more gas pumps so no trucks to deliver food. No refrigeration to store the food. It also means no communication to coordinate anything. I'm sure I'm only covering the tip of the iceberg. A large percentage of the planet would die from an event like this.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> Sure, someone really depends on an electrical gizmo to survive, but most of us would wake up to a world without machines that we rely on daily, yet everything we actually need to survive is intact. There are fruit on trees, water is still flowing and drinkable, boars still roam the forests. That would be true for like, 15 minutes. Then the realization hits: we eat it all, and there's no more left until the next growing season or whatever, meanwhile we'll be hungry tomorrow. No. The fate of humanity, were the machines to suddenly stop working, is most of it dead within first couple weeks. Not only the nature cannot support 7 billion humans without technology to make it, not only we're not tooled out for doing agriculture the "old-school" way, but also most people now live in the cities. Cities do not produce food. If you live in a city, and the machines disappear, or the economy collapses, you will starve to death, unless someone kills you first.
- jobs_throwaway 4y ago>If you live in a city, and the machines disappear, or the economy collapses, you will starve to death, unless someone kills you first. This is hyperbolic. Plenty of economies have collapsed without everyone starving to death or being murdered. Will it be pretty? No, but not as hopeless as you're making it out to be.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> Plenty of economies have collapsed without everyone starving to death or being murdered. Not in the last 50 years, not at the scale I'm talking about. Not to the point food stops being made, stored or transported, and there is no "outside" (such as international aid) to help. Closest to that would be warn-torn zones, where people in fact do starve and die. There's hardly any hyperbole here. With the entire food sector operating just-in-time, at any given moment a modern city has enough food to last a week or two, and that's with refrigeration running. In case of global economic collapse or even global power outage, that's all you'll get in the city. There will be no more food coming after that.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y ago
- belorn 4y agoIt seems very unlikely to me that any electric magnetic event could simultaneously destroy modern life while at the same time cause minimum damage to human life. One of the biggest concerns with massive solar storms is that they will cause firestorms in things connected to the power grid. If its not strong enough to do that, then it is unlikely to have the penetrating power to reach all electrical systems.
- LargoLasskhyfv 4y ago> water is still flowing and drinkable When did you last drink free flowing water from the outside, unfiltered, unboiled, or otherwise untreated? Got a clean spring? Lucky you!