3 ms·
Unfortunately, this misses the point. Apple's argument is based on the design patents (and "Trade Dress") they have. Design patents aren't like normal patents,
by nl 15y ago
Unfortunately, this misses the point.
Apple's argument is based on the design patents (and "Trade Dress") they have. Design patents aren't like normal patents, nor like trademarks.
They are more typically used to protect something like a car or dress design, and the test for infringement is "would this other product be mistaken for the subject by a normal person"
It's things like the radius of the rounded corners, the location of the button, and the width of the bevel that will be argued here, not how obvious the design is.
http://www.theverge.com/2011/04/19/apple-sues-samsung-analysis/ http://www.theverge.com/2011/04/19/apple-sues-samsung-analys... explains this pretty well.
(IANAL, and I think design patents are stupid, but this is the law as I understand it. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_patent#Comparison_to_utility_patents http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Design_patent#Comparison_to_uti... for more).
- pyre 15y ago> the location of the button Do you really think that a 'normal person' would say, 'oh, the location of the button is different. this is obviously not an Apple product!'. I find that doubtful. Being first-to-market and the best-selling tablet to date, most 'normal people' will see any tablet within the same size range wonder, "Is that an iPad?"
- juiceandjuice 15y agoIf the radius is formulaic based on the overall dimensions, should it be patentable? In my opinion, a lot of these claims for the design patent are obvious. The width of the bezel isn't so different than the width of the margins of of the wide ruled spiral bound notebook sitting next to me on my desk. The lab style notebook next to me, which also is almost the same dimensions of the iPad, has almost the exact radius of the corners of the iPad, which feels "right". Not because it's novel, but because humans like rounded corners and the radius is large enough to not be sharp but small enough to maintain a relatively constant distance from the corner of the screen, thus maintaining a feeling of continuity. So, I'd argue that this form factor is obvious because it mimics the design of objects (notebooks) which humans use in a similar way. Seriously, they even took half the name of a notepad and put it in the name of the device! A home button in the center is obvious too. If someone told me to draft a device that looked like a notepad and had exactly one button, I can't imagine a design much different than the iPad, or the touchpad, or the samsung. If they told me to put two buttons, they'd probably both be equidistant from the center.
- fpp 15y agoFrom the Wikipedia article you cited: "...Design patents can be invalidated if the design has practical utility..." Besides that this is a "natural evolution of design" and using key design formulas some known since more than 2000 years (e.g. golden ratio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_ratio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_ratio), this (practical utility) IMHO is a similar and one of the strongest arguments against these Apple patents here. The radius of the corners is given from the size of the screen and the width of the bevel, the width of the bevel by the size of an average person's thumb size, the location of the button generally how you hold the tablet and so that you can easily reach it (upright & sideways).