4 ms·
It doesn't matter if Samsung did it. It just matters if someone did it. The article clearly shows prior art for Apple's design patent.
by dpark 15y ago
It doesn't matter if Samsung did it. It just matters if someone did it. The article clearly shows prior art for Apple's design patent.
- bphogan 15y agoI would argue the prior art for that is the iPod Touch which was out a year earlier, and probably conceived earlier than that. When I heard "iPad" rumors in 2009 the first thing I thought was "a big ipod touch." So what's to say these guys didn't see the pod touch and say "Yeah. That. But big"
- dpark 15y agoThat's fine any dandy, but I believe Apple is claiming a design patent specifically on the iPad. If we take the iPod touch as prior art, it still invalidates the iPad patent.