7 ms·
The top comment is from a healthy smoker of 65. People always love to discuss how they or someone they know has smoked their entire life and never had a problem
by melling 15y ago
The top comment is from a healthy smoker of 65. People always love to discuss how they or someone they know has smoked their entire life and never had a problem. I know lots of smokers who still aren't convinced of the health issues. Seems like there's still a long way to go.
- ukgent2 15y agoIt depends on the person, I got a nan, 96, walks to town 3 times a week, still rides her bike, been smoking 60 a day for 40 years, and recently cut back to 40. If i compare her to my other nan 86 frail and pretty much falling apart, now guess which one has had the better lifestyle? the second, very well off always comfortable. At 96 i think she gets up to keep smoking, and if that keeps her alive then keep doing it.
- isamuel 15y agoThis is like saying the dangerousness of Russian roulette "depends on the person," because you have a grandmother who's played a bunch of times and didn't die.
- nsxwolf 15y agoThat's probably not correct. The grandmother playing Russian Roulette is truly the beneficiary of random chance. She's still susceptible to bullets. The centenarian smoker likely was never susceptible to smoking-induced lung cancer in the first place.
- mortenjorck 15y agoThe hammer is cocked when your embryo is conceived, and you can find out if the chamber was empty a few decades later.
- xer0 15y agoUnfortunately you have to live your whole life to discover whether you're an exception or a statistic. I'll go with the statistics for my personal choices.
- nsxwolf 15y agoBut most smokers will be exceptions. Most smokers will not get cancer. They get cancer significantly more often than non-smokers, but that's not scary sounding enough, I guess.
- _delirium 15y agoTo give specific numbers, according to one study (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7895211 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7895211), the lifetime risk of developing lung cancer is: male smokers: 17% female smokers: 12% nonsmokers: 1%
- nsxwolf 15y agoWhich backs up what I said. It's really unusual to see anyone talk about the actual lifetime risk. It's not as scary as saying "your chances are X times greater"... greater than what? If those numbers are accurate, and entirely due to the effects of smoking (not just other lifestyle behaviors more common with smokers, like drinking) that's easily reason enough to quit. But even in the worst case, the fact remains, most smokers will not get cancer.
- xer0 15y agoI'm not sure where your argument leads. Are you justifying smoking as a choice, based on the numbers? Are you attempting to explain why people choose to smoke, based on the likelihood of cancer? Something else? Regardless, smoking increases your overall risk pressure along with all of the other risky choices you can make. It's cumulative with the rest of life's choices.
- lincolnq 15y ago
- vijayr 15y ago60 a day, at 96 years old???!! wow, that is unbelievable
- DevX101 15y agoSusceptibility to lung cancer due to smoking is at least partly genetic. If you have certain variants of a specific gene (don't have time for the lit search right now), smoking won't significantly increase your chances of lung cancer. The problem is not everyone has this gene variant, and you probably don't want to be playing Russian Roullette with your health.
- itmag 15y agoDoes this mean a person can potentially get tested for this, and find out that they have a free pass to smoke as much as they want?
- vijayr 15y agoThat would be a very interesting scenario. few hours of testing, and we get a report like this "Here bob, you can smoke these (a, b, c) but you can't smoke these (d,e,f). Also you can drink everything, except these (1,2,3). Now go have fun"
- pbourke 15y agoSmoking also causes heart disease, lung problems, etc.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- DrPhish 15y agoDon't forget that, even if the health-care costs are zero, the financial costs of smoking are non-trivial. In addition to the costs of the cigarettes themselves, there is associated wear on one's home, car and clothes. You can also make arguments for the opportunity costs of time spent smoking, but that's harder to measure.
- anamax 15y agoDon't forget that there are significant benefits to smoking as well. Yes, even for people who it will kill. (In fact, that's probably one of the benefits for some.)
- mechanical_fish 15y agoIf only it were easier to find the blog comments of the 65-year-old smokers who died of lung cancer at age 57.
- Lost_BiomedE 15y agoA lot of the problem is that too many organisations shy away from harm reduction. They will make villains of much safer alternatives like snus or e-cigs. Many people who smoke are self-medicating. Reducing the risk to nicotine exposure from smoke exposure would go a very long way.