7 ms·
Antirez makes the point that linux has won the SW deployment war. And, really, it hasn't, with the possible exception of web startups. A lot of software isn't s
by skrebbel 15y ago
Antirez makes the point that linux has won the SW deployment war. And, really, it hasn't, with the possible exception of web startups. A lot of software isn't standard SaaS web stuff, and a lot of software won't for a long time, for all kinds of practical reasons.
Antirez, if you could try and imagine how Redis could be used in different environments (inside devices, as a component in 'end-user' business software, and so on), you might see why 'deployment' and 'servers' and 'the cloud' is not at all the only area where Redis might shine. It's your project so your choice, but don't neglect industries and areas simply because those involved in it aren't so represented among your twitter followers!
- slig 15y agoHow dare he neglect the poor industrie? He really should stop the development of new features and start worrying about porting and maintaining his software to range of different environments.
- joelthelion 15y ago>Antirez, if you could try and imagine how Redis could be used in different environments (inside devices, as a component in 'end-user' business software, and so on), you might see why 'deployment' and 'servers' and 'the cloud' is not at all the only area where Redis might shine. It's your project so your choice, but don't neglect industries and areas simply because those involved in it aren't so represented among your twitter followers! This is how you go from a great, focused project to a buggy and bloated one-size-fits-all project that gets gradually abandoned and replaced by a new fad.
- regularfry 15y agoWhat, like SQLite?
- regularfry 15y agoIt would be interesting to know why that comment merited a downvote.
- lreeves 15y agoProbably because it's just snark without providing any evidence that SQLite has become buggy and bloated. You added nothing to the discussion.
- regularfry 15y agoI was making the reverse point: SQLite provides an excellent experience on Linux, OS X and Windows, and has consistently done so for as long as I can remember. It is, as far as I'm concerned, the perfect counterexample to joelthelion's argument.
- lreeves 15y agoOh okay, maybe the downvote was because you didn't make that clear :-)
- drzaiusapelord 15y agoErr, the point is that you can have Win32 ports without becoming "bloated and buggy." I run Apache on Win32 all the time. Is that bloated and buggy? As well as php (well, no worse than on linux) and mysql. Postgres runs on windows as well. Then of course we have crossplatform darlings like Firefox, Libreoffice, etc.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- beagle3 15y agoIt's been my experience recently that there are a lot more downvotes, some of them seemingly random; I hope we haven't enter redditesque territory, where people downvote everything except their own post, giving themselves an effective initial +2 score. For the record, I've +1 your original comment, even though I disagree with it: SQLite is awesome, really really awesome. It is also not a good example -- part of the reason Redis works so well is that it capitalizes on Unix process management (in a way that was apparently intended when Unix process management was evolved, but has for some reason been unpopular and long forgotten). SQLite was never in that position.
- buff-a 15y agoHe perhaps should have said Posix, or "not-windows". "Redis is written in ANSI C and works in most POSIX systems like Linux, BSD, OS X and Solaris without external dependencies." [1] So I think if you stack IBM, Oracle, HP, and everyone else Redis runs on without modification, his point stands. [1] http://redis.io/topics/introduction http://redis.io/topics/introduction And, really, it hasn't, with the possible exception of web startups Hello!!! You are posting this comment where??? And have you heard of this little web startup named facebook? They use linux apparently. Zynga? Linux. Oh, yeah, Google, they use Windows, right? Amazon. And the largest company in the US, Apple, they use windows too, yeah? Oh. You mean those other, giant, windows-using companies we're reading about daily in the Wall Street Journal.
- wulczer 15y agoYeah, those other companies like Walmart, UPS, Boeing... you know, the ones based outside of Silicon Valley, deeply entrenched in the real world.
- lreeves 15y agoWhat is the incentive to the Redis developers in expanding their target audience to include enterprises, which generally demand a vastly different feature set?
- thinkdevcode 15y agoI totally disagree as I work in a large enterprise that is a Microsoft shop and I would love to run Redis for some of our up and coming projects.
- buff-a 15y agoWhy? Why don't you use Microsoft SQL Server? I mean, your company decided that for sound economic reasons, Microsoft is the way to go. You did read all those reports that even though linux is free, it has a much higher TCO than Windows. Why do you think the same is not true of Redis? I think you are one of those malcontents that is not aware of economic reality. Sure, Redis can probably do on one box what will take months of tuning several SQL Server boxes. But that's the great lie of linux. It just looks easier to begin with. Much better to just pay Microsoft, and have a technology monoculture. It keeps staff costs down too.
- Duff 15y agoI think that outside of larger enterprises with EA's, Microsoft is losing traction. So it's broader than just web startups. But inside of many big corporate and government environments, Windows rules the roost. I think there's a good reason for that -- Microsoft enterprise stuff usually works. In big orgs, Linux/Unix is associated with "big iron" , "big dollar" nightmares from Oracle, CA, etc.
- Mavrik 15y agoHuh... you're kinda wrong. Microsoft has never been stronger in server market and it's one of the platforms where their penetration is growing.
- llambda 15y ago> Antirez, if you could try and imagine how Redis could be used in different environments It's this shortsightedness in the leaders of open source endeavors, of all kinds, that can be a deterrent to outsiders. Not that it's wrong or bad to do something the way you want because it's your project and needs to fit your needs, however that said if it's to see wider adoption you have to look beyond what it is now. If a project is to be more than a personal project then it needs to take into account needs that are more than your personal needs. If the best course of action is to develop two independent projects, then so be it, but it would be foolish to dismiss the whole Windows ecosystem if one wants to see a project more widely adopted (although maybe that isn't any kind of priority, it depends on your perspective and harkens back to the frustration some people have with one personality leading a project).
- skrebbel 15y agoIn all honesty, I think antirez is a great example when it comes to open source developers who take into account needs that are more than his personal needs. In fact, the linked article even underlines this: he perceived a user need for a Windows port, took it very much into account, and carefully wrote a blog post about why he chose not to go down that path. I may believe that some assumptions in that blog post are too strong, but I very much think that even writing the blog post shows that antirez cares very much about stuff he's not personally helped by. So calling antirez "short sighted" because of this is, well, IMHO, a bit beside the mark.
- beagle3 15y agoCould you help me imagine how Redis can be used inside devices, or as a component in 'end-user' business business software? (unless it employs a "server"). Redis does one small thing and does it amazingly well -- an in-memory database with persistence and some very useful operations (such as FIFO lists) that do not need roundtrips. That does not make sense inside a device unless you have ridiculous amounts of RAM to spare (which has never been the case in my experience). Similarly, it makes very little sense in an "end-user" business software, unless there are _multiple_ processes needing access to the same in-memory data. And that (to me) means a "server" is going to appear sooner or later. Really, unless you run it on a "server", then sqlite with properly set cache parameters is almost surely a better choice, and works on Win32 since 2002 or so. Where it makes sense to deploy Redis, looks to me like antirez is right and Unix has won. And even though Redis likely works on iOS and Android out of the box, it makes no sense to do so, at least not at this point.
- regularfry 15y agoIt might make sense for end-user business software if that software ever has to be run offline.
- bad_user 15y agoThen Redis is not a good option anyway.
- regularfry 15y agoIt may have looked like it was from the initial requirements. Requirements change.
- beagle3 15y ago>> Really, unless you run it on a "server", then sqlite with properly set cache parameters is almost surely a better choice, and works on Win32 since 2002 or so. > It might make sense for end-user business software if that software ever has to be run offline. I'm sorry, I'm entirely unimaginative -- but I can't think of a use case for an "end-user" offline Redis server (regardless of O/S) that is better served by redis' sweet spot than by a local sqlite or postgres install. Can you help me here?
- skrebbel 15y agoI said "linux" where I should've said POSIX. Sorry about that mistake.