3 ms·
> For those saying that can't happen, think Ukraine in 2012 or 2018. Russia? Invading? Can't happen? No one paying even a little bit of attention thought “can’
by dragonwriter 4y ago
> For those saying that can't happen, think Ukraine in 2012 or 2018. Russia? Invading? Can't happen?
No one paying even a little bit of attention thought “can’t” since the invasion of Georgia in 2008. In 2012 they would have thought “has no reason to at the moment”, much as they would about Belarus today; what was unexpected in 2014 was the Maidan Revolution tossing out the Russia-aligned government, to which the invasion was an immediate response.
And in 2018 the likelihood of further invasion was widely discussed, while the scale and precise timing may have been unpredictable in 2018, that further invasion was likely, especially an attempt to seize the Donbas, where Russia has been supporting proxy forces since the 2014 invasion, was not.
> For Taiwan, China, invading? Can't happen.
That’s... Not at all the general thought.
- TillE 4y ago> No one paying even a little bit of attention thought “can’t” Maybe that's true in the abstract, but how did those in power act based on this obvious threat? Europe completely refused to even begin to diversify its natural gas sources until this year, even though that obviously should have happened after the annexation of Crimea at the very latest. They invited catastrophe by relying on Russian energy. In practice, they didn't take the threat seriously. They thought it wouldn't happen, they gambled quite a lot on that outcome.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Maybe that's true in the abstract, but how did those in power act based on this obvious threat? Again, it wasn’t an obvious threat, not because Russia lacked capacity or will but because it already controlled Ukraine via a puppet government. That changing, and very quickly from the emergence of a significant protest movement, was the unpredicted wildcard. > Europe completely refused to even begin to diversify its natural gas sources until this year, Baltic Pipe, a major component of the diversification effort, was identified as an EC interest in 2013, completed a feasibility study in 2016, had capacity agreements in place in 2018, and went online this September. Infrastructure isn’t something that pops into place when you snap your fingers.
- baryphonic 4y agoAll of that being said, I wrongly predicted that Russia wouldn't invade, because I rightly predicted the invasion would be a disaster for Russia. A CCP invasion of Taiwan would be even more disastrous for the PRC. They would need to conduct an amphibious assault, gain air superiority against "the quad" (no easy task), and would be unlikely to gain control of TSMC.[0] I think my reason for miscalculating the Russian invasion had to do with reasons unrelated to the actual military campaign: Putin felt that Russia's culture was existentially threatened by the West, its ability to invade was monotonically decreasing, and believed that a largely ineffectual, predictable US administration that appears to follow the mantra "speak loudly and carry a paper straw" wouldn't resort to extreme measures to stop Russia. In other words, invasion made total sense from a certain political-cultural calculus. I'm much more worried about the CCP, who have become increasingly ultra-nationalist, including concentration camps and racial-superiority indoctrination in schools (including something like a "stabbed in the back" narrative). The political crackdowns have become quite severe, and the Chinese financial is in bad shape, so an attempted invasion of Taiwan may increasingly be the thing the Party sees as bolstering their position domestically. The invasion would still be a disaster, and I have a feeling that the US & Taiwan already have plans to relocate the personnel from Taiwan's TSMC facilities to the US in order to use their specialized knowledge in order to keep producing superior chips. [0] https://www.jonstokes.com/p/why-a-chinese-invasion-of-taiwan https://www.jonstokes.com/p/why-a-chinese-invasion-of-taiwan
- yamtaddle 4y ago> > For Taiwan, China, invading? Can't happen. > That’s... Not at all the general thought. Indeed. AFAIK the general sentiment is that the only way they don't invade some time this century is if they manage to Hong Kongize them to transition them toward full annexation, through soft power.