3 ms·
Why I think an invasion of Taiwan probably means WW3
- mytailorisrich 4y ago> If China invades, it has a very strong incentive to attack U.S. bases first. And if China attacks U.S. bases, the U.S. is highly likely to respond by fighting China. Neither assertions make sense because both sides, and the rest of the world, have an overwhelming interest in avoiding a direct war. Of course, the issue here is that the scenarios considered does not include the most realistic and probable one, should the PRC decides to invade Taiwan. China is not going to attack the US or US bases in the region. They obviously know that this would be a Pearl Harbor moment and WWIII. But the US are not going to do nothing, either. They have been supplying and helping Taiwan for decades and would continue. See what's happening in Ukraine but probably much more extensive in terms of supplies and intelligence and a range of international sanctions. On the other hand the US are also not going to attack China, for the same reasons as China is not going to attack the US. What is quite clear is that the PRC cannot afford to launch an invasion and lose or being dragged into a long war. Therefore they need overwhelming superiority first, which they don't have at the moment. Then, there's of course the economic and political cost, which is up to the PRC to weight. If they think that this the way for the Party to survive and remain in power they IMHO would probably be willing to pay that cost.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoThe results are extremely sensitive to the totally arbitrary payoffs assigned.
- a0-prw 4y agoStopped reading when he used "CCP".
- fomine3 4y agoIs it politicized?
- ananiochita 4y agoDespite saying he is visiting Taiwan, he doesn't seem to know much about Taiwan itself, or the Chinese way of thinking, ( or what part Japan and other countries have to play in the area -- I don't know this person, but he seems not to know much about Asia at all ) which makes all his speculative calculations moot. China won't even start to contemplate renouncing "reunification", not while Xi is in power and a couple other leaders after him have come and gone, at the very least, but at the same time, China does not want to destroy Taiwan. And as things are now and will be for some time yet, there's absolutely no scenario in which China, whatever it does, and whoever gets involved or not, takes Taiwan in a swift hit, without leveling the island, killing massive amounts of people, stripping it of anything that makes it valuable, and destroying also the world's economy in the process, way before WWIII even starts, which means the only invasion possible now makes no sense at all to China itself, and that's not going to change in a couple of years. Edit : Taiwan is not Hong Kong, which is ... Obvious, for anyone in the area.
- dirtyid 4y agoOverlooking admittedly crude / uninformed payoffs to illustrate a point, why is PRC and US fightng "WW3" when it could just be confined to a peer power war. Maybe US can rope in JP and AU, but SKR/PH, ASEAN, NATO/EU unlikely. Most actors fine with being neutral observes to see how the primacy game will shake out.