4 ms·
Elon Musk plans to cut 75% of Twitter workforce
- Comevius 4y agoIt's totally not going to chase advertisers and their audiences away when the platform will be full of Russian propaganda, hate speech, beheading videos and those Japanese cartoons with 1000 years old dragons pretending to be 8 years old girls. I like controversial content as much as the next man, but we do live in a society. You can cause a lot of real-life harm, to real people and communities. Not so much with the cartoons, or the beheading videos, but with the propaganda and hate speech. Facebook caused an entire genocide in Myanmar, they even apologized for it.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoIt is important to recognize that things we disagree with are not exclusively propaganda. This has been a knee-jerk reaction lately. We find something offensive, repulsive, and anger-inducimg and instantly we apply subjective label and everything that goes along with it. Instead we should strive to be objective and not demand that others see things through soley our perspective or yet suffer the consequences of labels, or worse. The gripes you had are mostly covered by the legality question: Is a platform really for free speech if it only permits one side of the discourse to occur? If language is not illegal, who are we to censor it? The last point is this - nothing about language is violence. Violence is violence. Words are just words and they have fixed meaning. The distinction is critical and not bound by subjective reasoning in a civilization that hopes to last.
- Comevius 4y agoIt's not really a question of free speech, it's a question of consequences. We don't want people to die just so you can have every side of the discourse represented equally. Not all sides are equally factual, and representation of the facts matter. Vaccine denial and climate change denial are a good example, if you give them equal representation, if you keep repeating lies people start believing them, which causes a lot of harm. It's called a false balance. Facts matter. The same goes for the marginalization of minorities, for example transgender people. Giving intolerance a platform makes it socially acceptable. Indeed, violence against transgender people is frequent. Just look what Russia achieved in the United States alone using social media. Media is power, social media is power on steroids. You have to wield that power responsibly.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoLots of words to say you're smarter than everyone else and only your desired outcomes should be permitted for humanity.
- Comevius 4y agoMore than 1 million American people died from COVID-19, half of them didn't have to, they did because assholes made a lot of money of their corpses, on ad-enabled or political platforms, promoting a hysteria against vaccination. My desired outcome is people not dying in agony and fear if we can help it, and we can. I also prefer people like Alex Jones not getting rich from manufacturing controversies. He accused the parents of the Sandy Hook victims of being crisis actors, just because his analytics showed that calling a school shooting hoax makes more people watch him. Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequences.
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoTechnically none of them should have died, but the incompetence of the Chinese Communist Party and the NIH under Dr. Fauci ensured another outcome. Nobody's businesses needed to shut down. Kids didn't need to be banned from schools. Churches should not have been locked up. Governors completely screwed us with what we now know were fully arbitrary rules made solely for compliance. Nobody needed to lose their job over a "vaccine" mandate that functioned more like Tylenol than a vaccine. As such, nobody needed to lose their house or live in their car, or relocate their entire families in search of new work. Finally, the only immunity the vaccine produced was given to the pharma companies, who up until March 2020, were the devil incarnate. "I also prefer people like Alex Jones not getting rich from manufacturing controversies." But you'd be fine with CNN enriching themselves doing the same thing, because that's what they do, just to a different audience and different tactics, yet the same outcome (revenue). Who made you arbiter of truth? "Freedom of speech is not freedom of consequences." This is beaten to death and it doesn't really mean anything. It is a way for you to say, my way or the highway. It is not constructive. The very purpose of free speech, free association, and free press is to say what you think without consequence. Our respective feelings matter very little and factor even less into the equation.
- cyanydeez 4y agoIt's not about disagreeable messages, it's about the total inauthenticity of those messages. Having ten bots reproduce your messages makes it apparent that your message can't stand on its own and needs to use a dark pattern against human cognitive bias. In the case of bots, that's repetition.
- legitster 4y agoI mean, he's probably talking out of his butt here. But I do often wonder - Twitter has never turned a profit and basically never releases new features or products - what do most of the engineers there actually do all day? Keeping all of the servers on and finding unsuccessful ways to monetize the site surely can't take that much staff?
- PM_me_your_math 4y agoHe will keep engineers that agree with his vision. He will dump most of the moderator team, who are mostly toxic and unlikely to share his vision of free speech up to the line of legality. He will also replace support staff and most middle management, save for those who share the vision.
- jleyank 4y agoSlander and libel can be legal but expensive. Free speech has consequences. Can’t make people stay on the platform.
- abudabi123 4y agoGet on board the Superapp metatrain and recurse virtuous accelerated new economy activity. I think that is the vision.
- psychphysic 4y agoI hate Twitter with a passion, how did it become so big and not just useless but outright toxic to society? Hot take let's not give the richest man alive keys to such a thing?
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoWho should have the keys if such a thing is permitted to exist? And if such a thing should not exist, why is it only a problem at the moment someone you don't like is about to get the keys?
- psychphysic 4y agoI missed this reply earlier and expect you'll miss mine now! No one. Twitter should position itself effectively in line with allowable speech in an ideal liberal democracy. But it doesn't it's extremely opinionated around what is and isn't allowed. And in some topics much more restrictive than any countries law, and in others more tolerant. Basically get banned for transgressions around gender but not for violent threats.
- DLA 4y ago… Zuck and the vastly bigger toxic disaster that is FB? He’s very rich and largely controls FB.
- rdtwo 4y agoI bet you could theoretically do it but idk how you can practically cut 3/4 of the staff and not get rid of some critical folks by accident. Plus who wants to stay on and be the last 25% not your best performer they well quit on their own before you fire them
- prirun 4y agoIMO he's saying this now hoping a bunch of people will quit and not get severance.
- metadat 4y agoOr if they quit preemptively now, he gets to recoup the value of their invested stock. In this case it's a Win-Win-Win for Mussk either.
- DLA 4y agoI’m wondering what the heck 7500 people at Twitter actually do. Ok so a few hundred for engineering and DevOps. Their financial performance has been relatively poor prior to the Elon takeover saga. They don’t make their own hardware like Google and FB do. They don’t make consumer HW. They run a giant message queue with some ads. 7,500 people is way too many.
- cyanydeez 4y agoProbably global brand management, language adaptation, marketing etc. If you assume it's a global product, almost everything geometrically multiplies. After that you need your managers, hr, etc
- DLA 4y agoThose are really good points. So let’s make a country team: brand, localization/UX, marketing & sales, talent/HR, a few managers - say 50 staff. Twitter careers list some 23 counties (28 cities). Let’s round up to 50 so that’s 50 locations * 50 staff = 2500. (No way it’s this richly staffed in each city). Plus the 500 for engineering, DevOps, security and another 1000 for managers, PMs and all the other supporting/corporate roles. Grand total: 4500. Current staffing of ~7500 still seems partly unexplainable to me, for what the product is.
- jensgk 4y ago4500 + 50 location * 60 local moderators = 7500
- Nomentatus 4y agoElon tends to expand into businesses that can leverage tech his companies have already developed; for example I believe the tunnel company leverages metallurgy trade secrets mostly from SpaceX, but perhaps also from Tesla. In this case, I think he must believe Tesla AI is ready to do a whole lot of moderation; perhaps in a hybrid model with some high-skill human moderators. That's an approach a previous company he was part of, PayPal took re spotting fraud - a task that's not that different than rooting out bots and nation state actors. I don't doubt his sincerity with regard to safeguarding free speech; but he may also have been sizing up the AI application to moderation angle for some while.
- DLA 4y agoHey while we’re at it here, anyone hear about Jack’s new thing? BlueSky Social [0] which will use something called authenticated transfer protocol (AT Protocol) to create a distributed “Twitter killer” decentralized social media network [1]. Seems interesting in principle. [0] https://bsky.app/ https://bsky.app/ [1] https://ssaurel.medium.com/jack-dorsey-unveils-bluesky-social-the-decentralized-twitter-killer-cc6eec0c56e5 https://ssaurel.medium.com/jack-dorsey-unveils-bluesky-socia...