I strongly disagree. People who are experts in field X are self-selected people who agree with the assumptions that define the field. There should not be discu

I strongly disagree. People who are experts in field X are self-selected people who agree with the assumptions that define the field. There should not be discussion forum on the website if there is a belief that smart people (who have read plenty of books on clinical psychology and neurology) can't ask questions about something they haven't personally worked in.