4 ms·
>Perhaps the best way to prevent pollution of the environment with plastics is to ban the export of plastics as garbage. Strong disagree. There was a recent ou
by gruez 4y ago
>Perhaps the best way to prevent pollution of the environment with plastics is to ban the export of plastics as garbage.
Strong disagree. There was a recent ourworldindata.org article that discusses this. It concludes:
>I estimate that a few percent of ocean plastics could result from trade from rich countries. A figure as high as 5% would not be unreasonable.
While 5% of ocean plastic waste isn't nothing, there are surely better ways to reduce overall plastic pollution than trying to target 5%. For instance, investing in better waste management systems in developing countries.
https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-waste-trade https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-waste-trade
- L0stLink 4y agoIt is not just about ocean plastic. Garbage is burned as fuel too in less developed countries. Stopping dumping of garbage in 2nd and 3rd world countries by developed/first world countries is going to benefit the environment in more ways than just reducing ocean plastics. We need to hold waste producers accountable. We need a systemic change, more push to reuse and recycle, better laws to limit production of single use plastics and a push towards repairability to limit production of e-waste.
- sigstoat 4y ago> Garbage is burned as fuel too in less developed countries. Stopping dumping of garbage in 2nd and 3rd world countries by developed/first world countries is going to benefit the environment in more ways than just reducing ocean plastics. what do you expect they'll burn for power if we stop paying them to take stuff to burn?
- gruez 4y ago>It is not just about ocean plastic. Garbage is burned as fuel too in less developed countries. Stopping dumping of garbage in 2nd and 3rd world countries by developed/first world countries is going to benefit the environment in more ways than just reducing ocean plastics. But if only 2% of plastics worldwide is traded (source: same article I linked in my previous comment), and most of that is traded within the same region, how much waste could possibly end up getting shipped to less developed countries and burned? You'd still be better off trying to reduce domestic garbage production/burning in those countries.
- smileysteve 4y ago> Garbage is burned as fuel too This is ideal, at least in arc and high temperature, scrubbed plants (because plastic recycling takes more energy than burning it cleanly.) But you likely intended burned less as fuel and more as a disposal method.
- rjmunro 4y agoGarbage is burned as fuel in developed countries too, e.g. https://www.viridor.co.uk/energy/energy-recovery-facilities/ardley-erf/ https://www.viridor.co.uk/energy/energy-recovery-facilities/... I don't know of good figures on how much worse it is to burn plastic rather than wash and reuse it.
- fomine3 4y agoSince every country still burn fossil fuels, burning oil (but used as plastic) should be not bad.
- DoingIsLearning 4y ago> For instance, investing in better waste management systems in developing countries. How about we stop wasting tax payers’ money to pick up the tab of the externalized costs from all these companies selling single-use packaging? At the end of the day these companies will gaslight you saying customers love plastic but the reason they do plastic packaging is because it reduces packaging and shipping costs (at a high cost for the environment, water cycle, and humans). _Ban_single-use_plastic_, except for medical or lab applications. That was the original proposal in the EC before the lobbyists watered it down to this farce of the ban on q tips and straws.
- Retric 4y agoI personally like a lot of single use plastic. What’s the cheap alternative to keep food in an air tight seal from the factory to your home? There is a lot of greenwashing around packing that’s more environmentally harmful to create because they decay when left outside. Except if both products are sent to the landfill then they don’t provide any advantages.
- DoingIsLearning 4y ago> What’s the cheap alternative to keep food in an air tight seal from the factory to your home? Why do you need a tight seal? You can safely transport meat, fish, seafood from source to home with basic hygiene measures.
- gruez 4y ago>You can safely transport meat, fish, seafood from source to home with basic hygiene measures. You can, but it doesn't last nearly as long, which means more food waste due to spoilage. At my local supermarket meat that has been packaged in airtight bags have best before dates of 2-3 weeks. Meanwhile meat that's wrapped with non-airtight plastic wrap have best before dates of a week at most. The meats I get from the butcher counter do even worse.
- 4y ago
- flakeoil 4y agoYou just picked some random sentence from that article. I can pick some other sentences from that article and give another picture: "Most of the plastic that enters the oceans from land comes from rivers in Asia.1 More than 80% of it. Only a small amount comes from rivers across Europe and North America. Together, these regions contribute just 5% of the global total. This would suggest that the world’s richest countries don’t contribute much to the problem of plastic pollution. But, these numbers only look at the plastic that is emitted domestically. They don’t consider the fact that many countries export plastic waste overseas." Overall I would say that article contradicts itself and makes no sense.
- aetherson 4y agoUh, dude. The article is pointing out that: 1. Most ocean plastic enters the ocean from East Asia (80%) 2. Only about 5% of its enters the ocean from North America or Europe 3. But some plastic waste is exported form North America or Europe to Asia. 4. So is it plausible that the true waste share of NA and Europe is higher? 5. It concludes, yes, North America and Europe contribute as much as 5% of ocean plastic directly and then up to a further 5% via waste export. It doesn't contradict itself, your parent poster didn't "just pick a random sentence from the article," and you should maybe read more carefully.
- gruez 4y ago> You just picked some random sentence from that article. It's literally the bolded conclusion to the section named "How much do rich countries contribute to plastic pollution through their exported waste?". Given that the parent comment was talking about banning plastic exports, I think that's very relevant to this discussion. Saying that it was a "random" sentence is an extremely unfair characterization. >I can pick some other sentences from that article and give another picture: "Most of the plastic that enters the oceans from land comes from rivers in Asia.1 More than 80% of it. >Only a small amount comes from rivers across Europe and North America. Together, these regions contribute just 5% of the global total. This would suggest that the world’s richest countries don’t contribute much to the problem of plastic pollution. >But, these numbers only look at the plastic that is emitted domestically. They don’t consider the fact that many countries export plastic waste overseas." >Overall I would say that article contradicts itself and makes no sense. What exactly is contradictory here?