5 ms·
AWS buys 100 diesel generators and that's just for Irish datacenters
- metadat 4y agoWhy go the petrol route rather than invest in batteries + a huge solar array or wind farm? Are economies of scale not there yet for Amazon's data center power requirements?
- xfitm3 4y agoReliability trumps all else in datacenter workloads.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- singron 4y agoThese are just backup generators. Cheap to buy and own but not cheap to run. A sufficiently large pv/battery array would probably be huge.
- jonatron 4y agoThe price of gas and electricity is so high that diesel looks relatively cheap.
- metadat 4y ago@ChuckNorris89 wrote: > huge solar array > Ireland Yeah, I figured there could be land mass availability issue.. maybe better to beam it from outer space or across the ocean from a different *-land? I love the idea of a self-sustaining data center, hopefully someday we'll crack it in real life.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoCapacity factor is still 12% in ireland. 7% on a mostly clear week in mid winter. Your solar array has to be about 30x as big as the floor area to cover net daily energy on most days. Maybe down to 20x with bifacial modules and relying on grid or backup for a few hours a day during bad days in winter. Eyeballing some photos in the US, including the parking and setbacks you might be able to cover 10% of the power in winter or 15% year average In some areas you can probably put up a 3MW wind turbine or three. That would substantially lower the cost and size of storage. Max density for an entire area is only 10W/m^2 though so it's only another 4% assuming the available land looks like some random amazon datacenter I glanced at. Still, 15% ish net annual is a dent for doing the extremely energy intensive thing without expanding the land use (assuming it's a good wind site). I wonder if in some future where 70% efficient five junction panels are available whether it would make it easier to cool. You'd effectively be taking the sun heat and putting it inside so the outside would be cooler.
- fragmede 4y agoI love that idea. I bet Amazon could plunk one down somewhere sunny, like in Arizona, US if they wanted to.
- up2isomorphism 4y agoThink high level, and review in low level. Battery’s energy density is not nearly closed to fossil fuels. Question like this particular in a tech forum shows how much trouble we are in when actually dealing with environmental challenges.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paxys 4y agoSolar farms and batteries are a 5-10 year project. Diesel generators are for powering your data center tomorrow.
- hedora 4y agoReally? They're equally difficult for a homeowner to get installed.
- padraic7a 4y agoThe data centres are being located in the built up East of the country, near Dublin the capital city. Land for solar farms would be expensive and to be honest I'm not sure if the sunshine here would make them viable. I don't know why data centres are nt being located in more remote regions of the small island, presumably there are network / technical reasons.
- fragmede 4y agoIt's financial. Land gets cheaper the further away you go but the resources (like people) get more expensive the further away you go, so it's a balancing act. Some will be in the build up parts, and some will be in the remote regions. Take a look at Sweden, there's expensive DCs in Stockholm, but there are also remote DCs way up north in Luleå.
- postalrat 4y agoHonestly what would be better for the environment? A lot of batteries that rarely if ever get used but still need to be replaced? Or storing a bunch of fuel in a tank? The backup generator should rarely be used. The resources that went into the construction of the generator and tank is probably much less than would go into all those batteries.
- hedora 4y agoI'm sure you're correct, but I'd love to see numbers to back this up. The union of concerned scientists has done this for electric vehicles, which is really useful. I'd also like to see it for low-hour-usage stuff, like tractors, lawnmowers, chainsaws, etc. (Though, honestly, electric chainsaws are way, way better than medium sized gas ones, CO2 footprint be damned.)
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe CO2 for the fuel is pretty easy to calculate. It's the 2-4kg or so per litre (depending on where it's sourced). We'll call the carbon footprint of a generator negligible as it's mostly Aluminum (20kg CO2e/kg new or 1kg/kg recycled and steel (2kg/kg), it's maybe 10kg/kW so max 200kg. It will be lost in our error for the dirty fuel source once we use 50kg or so of fuel. The carbon cost of keeping some fuel out of circulation is hard to quantify, and tanks are essentially free so I will call the capacity cost 0. ~3kg/kg for fuel is really convenient because when combined with ICE efficiency, it's about 1kg/kWh This https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/how-much-co2-emitted-manufacturing-batteries https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/how-much-co2-emitted-manufac... says every kWh of NMC causes 2-16t of emissions. I'm sceptical this applies in 2022 given that $130 only buys 5t of coal, but we'll use it as indicative. So for our generator we have 200P + 4E + 0C where P, E and C are power, total energy used and hours of capacity respectively. If we assume 2C charge rate and 4000 cycle life, our battery is 2400 * max(P/2, C) + 2400/4000E So E = 600C + 6/40E Assuming P is small compared to C, then any capacity used less than ~550 times in the 8 or so years it lasts is better off as a generator. This is a function of the carbon intensity of battery though. At 200kg (https://spiral.imperial.ac.uk/bitstream/10044/1/79316/2/Revised%20Manuscript%20%28clean%29.pdf https://spiral.imperial.ac.uk/bitstream/10044/1/79316/2/Revi...) it's about 50.
- jhoelzel 4y agoI really do believe that there have been millions of generators and solar panels sold, just because there "might" be a power outtage. Like for instance here in Germany, they warned us of sad winters and blackouts all around and as it stands right now, there is nothing going to happen to either power nor gas supply. So I think these have been bought under fomo and will most likely not be needed and sold again. Solar in Ireland is going to be difficult, but wind is not. Its just a bigger investment that takes more space for something that "might" happen.
- pjc50 4y agoIf you've bought the panels, presumably you'd use them?
- mwint 4y agoOften, utilities and laws make it irrationally difficult to use solar and grid at the same time. You'd need a grid tie system (if permitted), or loads that you can run off solar alone (not connected to your home wiring). I can totally see the rationale for buying panels, and an inverter, such that I could feed into my home if the power went out - but not going through the mess of permitting, just planning to hook it up if the apocalypse does occur.
- hedora 4y agoAssuming you want to use solar and grid at the same time, how would you avoid using a grid tie system? You definitely need to match phase with the grid, or bad things will happen, and you definitely need it to not back-feed current into downed lines. Is there some other expensive thing the grid tie is doing, or are you proposing some other setup?
- Schroedingersat 4y agoYou could have both grid and solar feed into something less regulated with no back feed. A stupid but easy to think of example would be Solar-battery + inverter for your load with a DC grid powered charger when batteries are low.
- c_o_n_v_e_x 4y agoThe title/article is clickbait-y. Data centers normally have diesel backups. The article is portraying information that is completely normal as exceptional due to ongoing circumstances. It'd be far more interesting to learn that Amazon DCs do not have diesel back ups as that'd be a huge deviation from the norm. Most DC's I've worked on have back-ups that are roughly 2-ish megawatts per gen-set so AMZN is buying enough gensets for 200-250 MW of load.