5 ms·
“Remote learning” was a complete joke. My fourth grader is a Hermoine Granger type, very self directed, and even she would just stare out the window during Zoom
by rayiner 4y ago
“Remote learning” was a complete joke. My fourth grader is a Hermoine Granger type, very self directed, and even she would just stare out the window during Zoom school. She lost a whole year in reading.
Luckily, we send her to private school. It reopened more quickly than public schools in many areas nearby (Fairfax VA and Montgomery MD). And once we were back in person, she got 1 on 1 reading instruction every morning until she caught back up. My wife sometimes resisted the expense of private school (we both went to public) but the pandemic totally confirmed why it was worth the money.
- c048 4y agoYou did the right thing, the formative years as a child are crucial and shouldn't be squandered.
- quadrifoliate 4y ago
- PubliusMI 4y agoWe are currently living in a time when many people feel the need to dispute that rigorous education can have any meaningful impact on a child's abilities. Every chance to record and shares true facts, we should.
- quadrifoliate 4y ago> Every chance to record and shares true facts, we should. Sure, but it seems to me that we should do so in a controlled and rigorous fashion. A few questions: - Are we sure that the tests are exactly the same difficulty each year? If not, what is the falloff? - Who decides the difficulty? - How do we think about tradeoffs between grasping concepts correctly versus doing test prep? - Do the increased test scores from 2003 to 2020 actually translate into meaningfully better further education or quality of life on average? If you are making confident statements about "test scores dropped and this is bad for children", you should know the answers to all these questions. I feel like most parents handwave this sort of stuff away when it comes to children's test scores and always assume that it's perfect – but would start asking this kind of stuff very quickly, for example, if they were asked to, say, do a similar test as adults to determine what their bonus for last year should be.
- PubliusMI 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hotpotamus 4y ago> We are currently living in a time when many people feel the need to dispute that rigorous education can have any meaningful impact on a child's abilities. That doesn't sound right to me. My perception is that the value of a rigorous education is actually nearly universally valued, but how/whether children should have access to that education equitably is quite disputed.
- PubliusMI 4y agoThoughts on the current backlash against the SAT/ACT/other standardized college entrance exams? The liberal refrain is "High-scorers just had rich parents to hire them a tutor!", as if the tutor's instruction didn't actually uplift the children and make them stronger.
- hotpotamus 4y agoShould those with low standardized test scores be denied a rigorous education?
- adamsmith143 4y agoDespite the handwringing and poopooing from "liberals" there isa correlation between test performance and performance in college. Why would you send a student with sub 1000 SATs to Harvard when they likely won't be able to pass a single course?
- hotpotamus 4y agoWhy would you? Because you want them to get the most rigorous education possible I presume. I'm not saying it's a good idea, but it doesn't seem like anyone in the scenario doubts the value of education.
- adamsmith143 4y agoThe point being if you don't have some base level of preparedness the value of the education will be lost on you because you cannot complete it.
- batrachos 4y ago> I am...glad you were able to afford expensive private schooling to shield your kid from the effects of the deadly pandemic that led to more than a million deaths in the US? I'm another poster who did the same thing and I'm also very glad. > Ultimately I don't understand why so many parents keep taking potshots at remote learning a couple of years afterwards. Because, as documented in tfa, it was a disaster in terms of learning outcomes. > If you were able to throw pots of money at the problem, good for you. Meanwhile, poor parents who weren't, their kids suffered learning losses. > Can someone explain to me the logic that thinks test scores for young children at specific should keep going up? I was sympathetic to this line of argument until I looked up what good scores are generally held to be. This is a situation where the national averages are around a third proficient. Clearly a lot of room for growth. If we were in the 80s or 60s, sure, why not. We'd probably maxed things out and demaning additional gains might be squeezing blood from a stone. But ~30% proficient? We can probably do better.
- rayiner 4y ago> Meanwhile, poor parents who weren't, their kids suffered learning losses. Not even poor parents. The suburbs I mentioned (Fairfax and Montgomery) are among the most affluent in the country. Their schools were closed for two years or almost two years.
- quadrifoliate 4y ago> ...the most affluent in the country. Their schools were closed for two years or almost two years. Yes, to deal with a highly contagious virus that mysteriously seems to keep being absent from the conversation. Schools are notoriously bad about hygiene. Currently, RSV, which is completely unrelated to Covid is spreading; and stretching some children's hospitals to their limits [1]. I know that public health and education are probably two different ideas in your mind, and the narrative of incompetent people in charge of your child's education is much easier to throw around; but I invite you and other commenters to consider the case that maybe they might just be related. ---------------------------------------- [1] https://www.npr.org/2022/10/24/1130764314/childrens-hospitals-rsv-surge https://www.npr.org/2022/10/24/1130764314/childrens-hospital...
- Philorandroid 4y agoIt's not a pot-shot to say that remote learning is ineffective for children. If an environment tailored for education isn't effective, how could a home environment filled with distractions sans any full-time adult motivation be considered an upgrade? Plus, once-in-a-100-years or not, a substantial portion of a generation of kids spent their formative years in a world that enforced physical separation, covered faces and general agoraphobia for a world bearing an unseen, airborne and contagious horror (with a fatality rate between 0.001 and 0.003 for ages 0-19, established since late 2020[1]). Children born during the pandemic have already demonstrated decreased IQs, and that's just in the short-term. We're probably going to see an upward trend in childhood neuroses and maladaptive social behavior in the years to come. [1] - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2918-0 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-020-2918-0
- quadrifoliate 4y ago> It's not a pot-shot to say that remote learning is ineffective for children It's not remote learning that is being discussed here, it's remote learning during a pandemic. That's what repeatedly keeps being ignored. We have never had a proper experiment with remote and in-person learning side-by-side when, you know, there weren't headlines about the number of deaths in the paper every day. > Plus, once-in-a-100-years or not, a substantial portion of a generation of kids spent their formative years in a world that enforced physical separation, covered faces and general agoraphobia for a world bearing an unseen, airborne and contagious horror (with a fatality rate between 0.001 and 0.003 for ages 0-19, established since late 2020[1]). Children born during the pandemic have already demonstrated decreased IQs, and that's just in the short-term. We're probably going to see an upward trend in childhood neuroses and maladaptive social behavior in the years to come. Yeah, this is all fair and should be discussed – I just don't understand why a 2% decrease in average scores during a pandemic is considered the gold standard of evidence for it.
- confidantlake 4y agoI have no strong feelings either way but presumably the students need to be taught be teachers who are going to have a much higher fatality rate than the .001 number.
- AntiRemoteWork 4y ago
- mardifoufs 4y agoSchools were open in most of the world, even during the pandemic. So that's not shielding their children from the effects of a deadly pandemic; it's shielding them from a uniquely bad policy that was completely self-inflicted and unjustified. My province had a curfew (another bad idea, to be fair), and even then we still kept schools open (after the first 2 months of the pandemic, and that was longer than a lot of other places). Keeping them closed for more than a year had nothing to do with keeping people alive, or we would have seen massive differences between children death rates in the US vs. the rest of the world.
- trbleclef 4y agoChildren are far from the only humans occupying a school building.
- mardifoufs 4y agoSure, but teachers weren't dying in droves either. I'd like to know if there are any statistics showing a higher teacher mortality rate outside of the US due to schools not closing.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 4y ago"you have to work and we will pay you little. Also sorry, you might die if you go to work" doesn't sound very appealing for teachers
- mardifoufs 4y agoIt worked for most of the planet.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 4y agoWe had a lot of churn for those roles at school, from my understanding
- 4y ago
- helpfulclippy 4y agoThere are a lot of reasons for continued irritation here. First, you phrase this as being about something that was temporary. That's partly true. But there's no going back to 2019 -- everyone has seen remote work now, and they have opinions. Many administrators are looking at the numbers and saying, gee, if we could send kids home for X days a week, we could free up facilities and reduce costs and liabilities, and engage support staff from a wider geographical area. The missing piece here of course is that instead of kids seeing their friends and learning in a classroom, they're trapped in video chat purgatory. These effects simply do not enter the conversation unless measured into quantities that schools actually feel pressured by. Hence why test scores are an attractive subject here. Another reason is that the conversation about schools centered heavily on "well, people are dying." That's true -- people died, and continue to die. In many regions, this was used as a blank check to dismiss a lot of very serious issues in risk management. Closing the schools was not some sort of ethically-unambiguous decision. It was a substantial transfer of risk -- COVID deaths and other long-term consequences affected everyone, but the disease impact slanted VERY heavily towards older people and away from children[1]. This is a highly relevant, highly significant fact in the risk management of COVID in schools that, in my opinion, was frequently lost sight of. These closures represented a substantial generational transfer of risk from older people to younger, in which we somewhat extended life expectancy and reduced ongoing loss of health for a substantial number of older people, in exchange for severely degrading education and socialization of kids for 1-2 years. We should expect criticism of pandemic-era policies for as long as the effects remain relevant -- which will be for decades. Now, why do people WANT to take potshots at schools in the first place, if these policies have now ended in most districts? I can't speak for everyone who does so, but I can point to one thing I see a lot: we're fed up with the system. There are a LOT of people for whom this is not working. These problems existed long before COVID, but distance learning and other COVID policy has turned out to be a lightning rod because it allows a lot of families with very diverse frustrations to pinpoint a specific issue that upsets all of them. It's not JUST the distance learning -- it's the entire way districts relate to families and the manner in which they feel trapped and without a voice. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/1191568/reported-deaths-from-covid-by-age-us/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/1191568/reported-deaths-...
- strix_varius 4y agoWas the comment you're responding to heavily edited? Either we're reading quite different texts, or you're severely straw-manning their point of view. > I am...glad you were able to afford expensive private schooling to shield your kid from the effects of the deadly pandemic that led to more than a million deaths in the US? Protecting your children from external risks is one of the most essential qualities of a parent, yes. I'm not sure what you're trying to convey here. > Ultimately I don't understand why so many parents keep taking potshots at remote learning a couple of years afterwards. If you were able to throw a ton of money at the problem, good for you. Meanwhile, children and adults were both greatly affected by the pandemic and many were worried about, you know, being alive tomorrow. People lost their families. Yes, precisely. This is an important issue that the parent commenter was raising: "Remote learning was a complete joke." The well-off are able to shield their children from this, but the average person isn't. Are you suggesting that it should be taboo to discuss how this will widen the class divide? > Trivializing the knock-on effect of this once-in-100-years thing over some standardized test scores that are back to 2003 levels [1] makes no sense to me. In what sense was the parent commenter "trivializing" the pandemic? Would you agree that your comment trivializes the concerns that less-affluent parents might have that their children will be at a marketplace disadvantage compared to two decades of graduates preceding them?
- quadrifoliate 4y ago> Protecting your children from external risks is one of the most essential qualities of a parent, yes. I'm not sure what you're trying to convey here. I perceived the parent as bragging that their expensive private school was better than the public schools that other people send their kids to, by claiming that the option available to regular people was "a joke". There was no mention of anything like "I wish this was an option for everyone". > Yes, precisely. This is an important issue that the parent commenter was raising: "Remote learning was a complete joke." The well-off are able to shield their children from this, but the average person isn't. Are you suggesting that it should be taboo to discuss how this will widen the class divide? Not at all, class divides are important to investigate! But you should have proper evidence and data. I am suggesting that the "evidence" here (a 2% decrease in standardized test scores that are not well-controlled) is not particularly significant compared to the evidence that Covid was a deadly public disease which necessitated school closures and remote learning. > In what sense was the parent commenter "trivializing" the pandemic? By saying that "remote learning was a joke". To me, this is like saying "earthquake-related evacuations were a joke, because normal kids' scores dropped 2% during the earthquake. Oh, and mine didn't, because I had a private plane!". > ...their children will be at a marketplace disadvantage compared to two decades of graduates preceding them? My comment is simply saying that you don't have data to suggest anything of the sort; so you should stop simply insisting that they are true and calling reasonable public health procedures "a joke" as a result.
- zozbot234 4y agoYou don't have to pay for expensive private lessons. You can homeschool, especially if your job has been put on furlough due to said deadly pandemic. (Of course paper-pushing kinds of jobs could easily be done 100% remotely, but many jobs aren't like that.)
- listless 4y ago> Keep taking potshots at remote learning These are the trade-offs. They need to be reckoned with. The death toll from the pandemic is only the beginning of the fallout and as one of the only countries to keep schools closed as long as we did, we now have to deal with that. And to dimiss it outright as being trivial is to cast aside the most vulnerable who were NOT able to afford private school.
- quadrifoliate 4y ago> as one of the only countries to keep schools closed as long as we did This is poorly-informed repetition, typically caused by news cycles about Sweden, a country with a population comparable to Ohio. At least in terms of population, the two biggest countries in the world with a population greater than the US are China and India. I know for a fact (having family there) that schools in India were closed for longer than the US. Chinese schools are still closing sporadically [1], so presumably they were doing so during the thick of the pandemic as well. If you are that worried about get your kids the education to enable critical thinking, it is probably wise to implement some yourself when discussing these issues. ---------------------------------------- [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-10-12/shanghai-quietly-shuts-down-schools-gyms-bars-as-covid-returns https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-10-12/shanghai-...
- listless 4y agoI should have clarified with “Western”. Although I think your point that our only company in regard to school closures is China and India doesn’t frame us in the best light in terms of pandemic response. Also, I seem to have upset you with my comment. It was poorly phrased and I do apologize for that. I don’t think that you are 100% wrong in your argument and I appreciate your position.
- sershe 4y ago"I am...glad you were able to afford expensive private schooling to shield your kid from the effects of the ~~deadly pandemic that led to more than a million deaths in the US?"~~ misguided public policies that are even more unreasonable than already-not-so-reasonable, much shorter school closures in e.g. Europe, and are correlated with power of local public sector unions much more than the local severity of the pandemic impact. FTFY
- trieste92 4y agoI would've done the same thing had I been in your situation