22 ms·
>I soon discovered that all the books leaned on the same central argument: value is an inherent consequence of scarcity. My rebuttal to that was simple: it’s an
by coldtea 4y ago
>I soon discovered that all the books leaned on the same central argument: value is an inherent consequence of scarcity. My rebuttal to that was simple: it’s an exception, not a rule. My kids’ doodles are scarce, but in a gallery, they wouldn’t fetch much
Well, how about "value is an inherent consequence of scarcity with respect to demand"?
- yason 4y agoOr to generalise, where supply and demand meet is called value.
- viridian 4y agoThe intersect of supply and demand is necessarily the price equilibrium. Value is only equal to price if the buyer and seller both have equal information and neither is operating under any sort of constraints that force certain market behavior. Your generality may often be true in certain contexts, but increasingly, one should operate under the assumption that the seller has a significant informational advantage over the buyer, and this advantage will be used to capture additional value.
- svnt 4y agoAuthor seems to understand supply and demand — they are making the point that the NFT perspective doesn’t include a rationale for demand.
- coldtea 4y agoDemand doesn't need to have a rationale (in the sense of "real needs" or "utility value" or something of the like) to work in raising value. It just needs to exist!
- svnt 4y agoYes, but if the demand doesn’t establish itself in some other context that serves a narrative (whether cultural, material, tax shelter, or other) the dynamics of the underlying market tend to be in the realm of tulips and postage stamps.
- PebblesRox 4y agoOr maybe “scarcity is a multiplier of value.”