2 ms·
The talk mentioned in article is ignoring one thing, the people who buy that stuff and want to build "just some compute" want to have a black box to talk to, se
by ilyt 4y ago
The talk mentioned in article is ignoring one thing, the people who buy that stuff and want to build "just some compute" want to have a black box to talk to, send their IO requests and get their data back in.
Now that's not to say that part shouldn't be open, but really integrating it into "one OS" isn't that beneficial. Making that open would result in majority (sans GPU and maybe DSP) of the system still run "a tiny piece of code that provides interface for the bigger OS to do its job". About only place where user wants the integration is between compute elements (GPU/CPU/DSP) and even that is mostly just "provide API to the applications", OS can't abstract away interface to make work happen seamlessly, the best it can do is to pass it to the userspace app in consistent way.
I think "just" the open part would be enough honestly. Then the OS stops being limited to interface baked into closed blob and the open driver can innovate on that together with the OS.