4 ms·
> in population decline So? It's not the most populous groups that dominate, quite the contrary. The world had half the population just 50 years ago.
by seydor 4y ago
> in population decline
So? It's not the most populous groups that dominate, quite the contrary. The world had half the population just 50 years ago.
- godelski 4y agoYeah I find the conversations about population decline quite odd. We've seen the results of population explosion, and I don't think many agree that the results were great. But they also weren't that bad. I think people miss the point that (if you're a fellow Millennial) that when your parents were born there were less than half the number of people on the planet than there are today. I don't think rapid decline will be a good thing (just like rapid increase wasn't) but I don't think it is an existential crisis either. World population: (1804) 1 billion, (1927: 123yrs) 2 billion, (1960: 33 yrs) 3 billion, (1974: 14 yrs) 4 billion, (1987: 13 yrs) 5 billion, (1999: 12 yrs) 6 billion, (2011: 12yrs) 7 billion, (2023: 12 yrs) 8 billion.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI think the reason for it is that those conversations tend to focus on local community as it relates to society's ability to support its existing retirement model. This conversation is then repeated across multiple countries with varying degrees of intensity, urgency and political backing. In the old country ( Poland ) for example, in 2016 ruling party introduced a stipend for each kid[1]. The official results don't seem to support the approach though[2]. I guess my point is that it may be existential crisis for some communities more than others. Naturally, it does not help that discussion of it almost invariably brings a question of overpopulation and all the baggage that brings. [1]https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?langId=en&catId=1246&newsId=9104&furtherNews=yes https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?langId=en&catId=1246&ne... [2]https://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/poland-population https://worldpopulationreview.com/countries/poland-populatio...
- oneoff786 4y agoWhen the population is growing quickly the ratio of young:old people is high. When the population is shrinking, the ratio becomes very small. A society with many old people and few young people will suck
- rabuse 4y agoI imagine the homeless numbers of elderly are going to skyrocket over the next few decades because of this.
- wizofaus 4y agoBut is there a significant difference between how much support very young (pre-adult) people and how much support elderly (post-retirement) people need? At some point during rapid population growth there were a lot of the former, and we managed OK. Now there's a lot of the latter, and not so many of the former. As it is, many of the costs for elderly people seem to be about medical inventions to (arguably artificially) prolong life. I'd suspect that will become increasingly expensive, to the point that expectations around how much it's reasonable to spend on such treatment may change. As it is, COVID caused quite a significant increase in mortality among elderly populations - it was undoubtedly pretty awful for those directly involved, but society as a whole seems to have adjusted since.
- rayiner 4y ago> But is there a significant difference between how much support very young (pre-adult) people and how much support elderly (post-retirement) people need? Compare the cost of elder care to child care.
- wizofaus 4y agoThat's what I'm asking - both are very expensive. But we see supporting pre-adults as "investment" (education etc.), whereas it's hard to see it that way for the elderly - the selfish view would be that it's more like an insurance policy to give you confidence that society will still consider it important to care for the elderly when you join their ranks.
- oneoff786 4y agoYoung people are cared for in large groups via schools. They have no wealth or political power. Old people can be very expensive, can still vote, and most will have a economic power for this specific generation. In the past when you were a working couple with kids, you hoisted your kids into your grandparents to help raise and there was no opportunity cost. There’s no converse here. Good luck passing legislation to reduce care for the old while they’re the largest chunk of the population.
- rayiner 4y agoAmerica's population advantage over Europe gave it a significant edge over Europe during the 20th century. That aside, it is axiomatic that any functional culture should be able to maintain a fertility rate around the replacement rate.
- JetAlone 4y agoMinorities can disproportionately succeed by having extreme in-group preference and solidarity, and something approaching a monopoly on some sort of highly profitable racket. They will end up in a position where they are despised, but protected. Where their in-group solidarity is called out as subversive hate, and they are attacked for this preference, pogroms ensue. I'll just out and say it, a lot of Whites are concerned their children will be treated the same way some of their medieval ancestors treated Jews.