3 ms·
Putting them in GEO means that if you have more than 3 in total, you have to ask "can a malicious actor make more than one beam focus on a chosen target?" And
by ben_w 4y ago
Putting them in GEO means that if you have more than 3 in total, you have to ask "can a malicious actor make more than one beam focus on a chosen target?"
And you do have to care about malicious actors, not just accidents, on this scale.
You can only guarantee to avoid this if you put them in lower orbits so that no more than one is over anyone's horizon at any moment (bonus: saving on antenna mass), and with a phased array that's basically fine; but the lower they get, the more often they're in Earth's shadow.
(I really need to blog this with pictures, I don't want a repeat of last time this came up).
- DennisP 4y agoSeems pretty clear. That's a decent point. According to the book, the beam spreads out a lot if you don't have the ground signal, but it didn't quantify that. And there's always the possibility of some sort of covert action putting a transmitter in the target area. If the malicious actor is hacking the satellites that power the victim's country, then the repoint gets a double whammy by cutting off power to the areas it was supposed to go.