4 ms·
How would an outside copyright enforcer know that? Well, for one, there is no such thing as "an outside copyright enforcer." The only people allowed to complai
by rhizome 15y ago
How would an outside copyright enforcer know that?
Well, for one, there is no such thing as "an outside copyright enforcer." The only people allowed to complain at all about a song's presence on a website are the people who own the copyright. That's it.
- wmf 15y agoAnd in practice copyright owners outsource their enforcement, because it isn't their core competency.
- csallen 15y agoSo you're defending the outsourced copyright "enforcers" because they can't help but be incompetent, and you're defending the people who hire them because they're too incompetent to do it either?
- rhizome 15y agoAnd in practice copyright owners outsource their enforcement Do they really? IIRC, every case of outsourced "enforcement" has resulted in failure. What successes should I be remembering?
- jleader 15y agoFor now... SOPA intends to fix that minor oversight, apparently.
- officemonkey 15y agoApparently the seizure was facilitated by a complaint and affidavit from the RIAA, even though the website kept scrupulous records of permission to post songs directly from the labels.
- rhizome 15y agoWhich tells us that processes and remedies that were effectively written entirely by the industry will still be abused by that industry.
- einhverfr 15y agoWhat makes you think this isn't entirely intentional? I mean if an industry writes processes and remedies, isn't it reasonable to assume that to any reasonable outside, they will abuse them?
- rhizome 15y agoFor whatever reason, it's good to know for the future. That is, it's probably a good thing to remember when future legislation (like today's new SOPA) comes up. I totally agree that the whole industry-written legislation Thing is lame.
- buff-a 15y agoWhich tells us that the RIAA lies to law enforcement and should be criminally investigated. If its a corporation, and since corporation are now people, perhaps we should put it in prison and allow it one phone call per week.