4 ms·
> …Facebook parent company Meta says Canada’s proposed Online News Act falsely presumes that it “unfairly benefits from its relationship with publishers.” Grea
by CharlesW 4y ago
> …Facebook parent company Meta says Canada’s proposed Online News Act falsely presumes that it “unfairly benefits from its relationship with publishers.”
Great, I hope the Online News Act passes and this is tested. Facebook built a for-profit Skinner box on the backs of commercial and user-generated content that they paid virtually nothing for, and now they're simultaneously threatening countries over proposed legislation while telling news organizations that "most people do not come to Facebook for news"¹.
¹ https://www.theverge.com/2022/7/28/23283078/meta-facebook-news-tab-paid-publishers-is-over https://www.theverge.com/2022/7/28/23283078/meta-facebook-ne...
- Spivak 4y agoThis shit is way more nuanced than news good facebook bad. This is news organizations who bet the farm on social media as distribution platforms not realizing that it completely devalues them and then making a big fuss that somehow search engines and social media platforms should pay to allow their users to link to news sites as if that makes any sense at all. These are the gasps of a dying industry trying to have their cake and eat it too. I would ban links to news sites entirely if this passed too. News orgs realizing that individuals don’t pay for news are just reaching for anyone with deep pockets.
- kennend3 4y ago> This is news organizations who bet the farm on social media as distribution platforms not realizing ... which news agency in Canada did this? Don't they all have their own sites? https://www.cbc.ca https://www.cbc.ca https://nationalpost.com https://nationalpost.com https://www.thestar.com https://www.thestar.com Some do use facebook's "comments" function, but even that is not a universal lock.
- hairofadog 4y agoThey didn’t bet the farm on social media, they crawled onto it like rats onto a… floating thing, or however the hell that metaphor goes. Social media set their business models on fire and then the rats swam from over here to over there, squeaky-like
- jimmaswell 4y agoYou want to have to pay the owner to be able to have a link and snippet to any publicly visible webpage? Wouldn't this be a disaster for the Internet Archive?
- iso1631 4y ago> "the Online News Act compels online platforms like Facebook and Google to share revenue with the publishers they aggregate their news from" Does internet archive aggregate news? Does it have revenue from that aggregation?
- jimmaswell 4y agoOnce news outlets establish that they can squeeze money out of the entities that send anyone to their websites in the first place and shift the window to their crazy world view, it's not a stretch that they'll start whining about deserving money from the Internet Archive et al too.
- CharlesW 4y ago> You want to have to pay the owner to be able to have a link and snippet to any publicly visible webpage? I want Facebook to pay for building a predatory and privacy-eroding monetization machine around access and engagement related to that link and snippet. > Wouldn't this be a disaster for the Internet Archive? How to avoid splash damage should be seriously considered, for sure. It's worth noting that Internet Archive is in a much different position as a non-commercial entity that hosts content.
- jimmaswell 4y agoIt sounds like you essentially want to pick favorites based on your feelings about the company's virtues. Either you can have a link, a basic right of the internet, and a small snippet, something covered under fair use for all of copyright's history, or you can't. The second is the beginning of the end of fair use.
- 4y ago
- zxcvbn4038 4y agoI believe that it’s actually the news organizations that are benefiting more from Google and Facebook then the other way around. Both should block all news from their platforms until laws are passed requiring news publishers to fairly compensate Google and Facebook distributing their content. Because everyone reads news, but ad blockers skew those numbers, the rate can instead be based on total population and adjusted yearly by either census or projected population change.
- mccorrinall 4y ago> Facebook built a for-profit Skinner box on the backs of commercial and user-generated content Like reddit, youtube, tiktok twitter, google any many more? Anyway, if I was big tech, I would just ban all domains from those publishers who demand part of my revenue and watch them quickly die.