6 ms·
From the article: > Such efforts could crush research “critical for human survival and empathy,” says Bertha Madras, a neuroscientist at Harvard who has conduc
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
From the article:
> Such efforts could crush research “critical for human survival and empathy,” says Bertha Madras, a neuroscientist at Harvard who has conducted brain imaging studies of monkeys for decades but doesn’t work directly with Livingstone. “If we’re going to understand how the brain functions, we’re going to have to do experiments that generate visceral reactions,” she says. “We have to be looking at the greater good.”
I'm definitely wary if the best argument for continuing this research is that it supports "the greater good". I could fully understand that the line between, for example, what is an acceptable research protocol, and what crosses the line to cruel, inhumane treatment, is sometimes gray. But I think it's morally wrong to be ok with cruel and inhumane treatment of intelligent, social creatures by just arguing that it "is for the greater good".
That line of thinking has been used as a defense for nearly every horrific undertaking by man for the past couple of centuries.
- civilized 4y agoI am wary too, but of something a little different. I worry about people passionately drawing very sharp, red, punitive moral lines on things that are pretty subjective and that different people will have different opinions on. We're going to be in a bad place if we all draw slightly different lines on various issues, then condemn and work to punish each other for crossing our lines. I think this ideology of moral maximalism - "everything I object to morally should be punished harshly" - has been pretty disastrous for the human race, if you look at history. However passionate people are about primates and their resemblance to humans, I don't see how you can draw an objective line that condemns this research but sanctions all the horrible things we do to, say, rats, for the greater good of medical science. Who can claim to have the objective view of how moral obligations to non-human animals increase with their resemblance to humans? We don't agree on this stuff, and it isn't objective. Can we all find something better to do with our lives than try to punish each other for not toeing the exact line of our individual moral opinions? Let's calm down, stop taking our moral emotions as legitimate universal prescriptions, and put moral maximalism behind us.
- ziddoap 4y agoThis reads like "since the line might be fuzzy, we should never have lines, move on". Surely there is a middle-ground to be found between your extreme and the other?
- civilized 4y agoI'm not saying we should never have lines, I'm saying we should not automatically turn all of our moral intuitions into bright red lines which we enforce punitively.
- ss108 4y agoWe shouldn't do it to rats either. The thing is, your view of this is too anthropocentric. Saying this: "I worry about people passionately drawing very sharp, red, punitive moral lines on things that are pretty subjective and that different people will have different opinions on. We're going to be in a bad place if we all draw slightly different lines on various issues, then condemn and work to punish each other for crossing our lines." ...doesn't take into consideration the experiences of monkeys and other animals. So you're going to have to morally justify why we shouldn't care about them. The argument you are making sounds reasonable if applied to, e.g., cancel culture or something, but it's rather willfully oblivious and glib in this context, IMO. "Can we all find something better to do with our lives than try to punish each other for not toeing the exact line of our individual moral opinions?" Wouldn't by definition many moral opinions necessitate that one try to get them enforced in some way? You're kind of just downplaying morality overall, arguably. Again, I'd be sympathetic to what you're saying in a lot of contexts, either where humans are the only creatures involved or the human actions simply don't directly infringe on anyone else. So, abortion, cancel-culture, gay marriage, etc. This way of thinking could be usefully applied to a lot of hot-button issues where the conduct really doesn't actually harm anyone else, human or otherwise. But if it comes to animal experimentation, genocide (see China), various forms of oppression and discrimination within societies (whether racial or like caste-based, whatever), etc., people are going to become indignant, and if they didn't, we'd all just be amoral and compassion-less in a very dystopian way.
- 4y ago
- jcampbell1 4y agoThe logic of weighing cost and benefits is sound, but the PR blunder of saying “the greater good” is astounding. The only correct thing is to talk about the human suffering that you hope to alleviate. Let the listener operate their own moral balance. The idea that the greater good is a singular knowable thing and she represents it is patently offensive.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> The logic of weighing cost and benefits is sound I disagree, though that's obviously been a central question in philosophy since Aristotle. Is the logic of weighing costs and benefits sound if they had been experimenting on human babies instead of monkeys? I think most people would argue not. So if it's that you're arguing that because they're monkeys that's different, and that might be OK, but the whole reason they've chosen monkeys here is precisely because they believe their brain and neurological systems are close enough to our own that they would react similarly, for example, to having a child stolen from its mother. Honestly, I think trying to defend this in a morally consistent framework requires some mental gymnastics I'm not capable of.
- jcampbell1 4y agoIf it is consistency you are after, then join PETA. The logic of weighing cost and benefits is always sound, but there are cases where it is so one sided that it is offensive to pose the question. Experimenting on babies falls in that category. I suppose at this point my personal opinion on this issue is relevant to you. I am personally okay with Neuralink because it isn’t implausibility far from someone walking from a wheelchair. This specific research miles apart both from the welfare side (it requires emotional harm to the monkeys) and the benefits are far less tangible. I think this research should be put up for review and if I were a reviewer I’d start from a position that this needs to stop. I suppose my meta point is that it is okay to have red lines and argue them, but peppering the discussion with arguments against logic unnecessarily makes your commentary less persuasive to me.
- bambax 4y ago> So if it's that you're arguing that because they're monkeys that's different, and that might be OK, but the whole reason they've chosen monkeys here is precisely because they believe their brain and neurological systems are close enough to our own that they would react similarly, for example, to having a child stolen from its mother. Exactly this.
- lupire 4y ago> research “critical for human survival and empathy,” If Bethda hasn't figured out empathy yet, I doubt she ever will.