7 ms·
Anti-Xi protest spreads in China, worldwide as Chinese leader begins third term
- 3qz 4y agoWhat’s the point of protesting when they don’t even have elections? Why can’t the government just ignore the protesters with no consequences?
- dontbenebby 4y ago>What’s the point of protesting when they don’t even have elections? Because people who aren't sociopaths experience psychic distress at the idea of violence. (That's absolutely an Always Sunny reference, BTW.)
- brundolf 4y agoEven authoritarian regimes have to think about civil unrest. The people under them still have some power: they have the power to revolt. Dictators are terrified of this possibility. And a protest is a way of signaling "hey, the temperature is rising buddy". A democracy by comparison functions as a gradual release valve: smaller amounts of unrest can affect smaller changes, without overthrowing the entire system.
- alexvoda 4y agoThe feedback loop is slightly more complex. Dictators are also afraid of betrayal. And rising temperature creates opportunities for underlings to decide betrayal is profitable.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agowhat’s the smallest protest in china that would actually stand any kind of chance of successful revolt/revolution?
- HWR_14 4y agoYou really have to define successful. Get Xi to change a single policy? Get someone else to take over as Chairman of the CCP and Secretary General of the Politburo? Put a democracy in place? Those are all different goals. Similarly, and as an analog, concerning Russia some people talk about Russia pulling out of Ukraine, some people talk about a coup deposing Putin and some people talk about new, real, elections.
- brundolf 4y agoAlso, "revolt" doesn't have to mean "completely overthrowing the government". Social unrest can eg. make for a less-cohesive society, harder-to-govern citizens, less-effective economy, etc. These things are valuable to those in charge; a leader would have to be really dumb to not factor them in at all in their calculations. So it's all about tradeoffs: what it would take to appease people vs what would be the social costs if you don't. Finally- protests signal to fellow citizens too, not just the people in charge. They can be contagious. All of which is just to say their impact is never zero, even if it's small
- thot_experiment 4y agoAIUI, and i'm no expert, it would have to be absolutely massive. When someone put up a banner and burned some tires in Beijing the other day the CCP was blocking the word "beijing" itself on social media for a time. Their level of control is unrivaled.
- origin_path 4y agoIs that evidence of awesome control or lack of it? Seems like blocking a word like Beijing because of a single event is over-blocking on a staggering scale; it communicates absolute terror of the populace that results in astonishingly over the top decisions.
- katari_v 4y ago
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y ago<< What’s the point of protesting when they don’t even have elections? Huh? Elections just happened. They were not direct elections, but within the party system they were elections. If I were to compare Chinese elections, I would maybe compare them to UK House of Lords. As to your general point, "why do anything when you have no right to do it"? Well, we are humans. Not all of us just roll over when we are told to.
- matthewmacleod 4y agoIf I were to compare Chinese elections, I would maybe compare them to UK House of Lords. … the UK House of Lords which is famously unelected?
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI think we are arguing over semantics here[1]: colloquial elected vs appointed. define - assign a job or role to (someone). elect - choose (someone) to hold public office or some other position by voting I chuckle at the very notion that any power circle would allow election of a power to a position as influential as HoL without some sort of quiet approval vote taking place by 'appropriate decision makers'[2]. You say it is not elected. I am saying it is elected by a very small group of people. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Lords https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/House_of_Lords [2]https://www.parliament.uk/business/lords/whos-in-the-house-of-lords/members-and-their-roles/how-members-are-appointed/ https://www.parliament.uk/business/lords/whos-in-the-house-o...
- matthewmacleod 4y agoIt is not semantics. The House of Lords is not elected - there is no voting process, which is a necessary prerequisite for an “election”. It is not “elected by a very small group of people” - it is explicitly appointed, with terrible appointees frequently being rewarded for personally closeness to the prime minister. Several of the positions are literally hereditary.
- 4y ago
- rasz 4y ago>Why can’t the government just ignore the protesters with no consequences? Worked for Macron in France.
- chatterhead 4y ago
- dontbenebby 4y ago> Xi is quickly becoming the Chinese FDR. FDR just interned the Japanese and Italians, Xi is on another level with how he mistreats people who are the wrong shade of white on the West Coast.
- twelve40 4y agoXi is mistreating people on the West Coast? wtf does that even mean?
- dontbenebby 4y ago>wtf does that even mean Did you just use the f word? (Purposeful ambiguity, my boy.)
- GekkePrutser 4y agoAlso, an important difference was that there was an actual world war raging at the time.
- imiric 4y agoNaive rhetorical question: is there any chance that China could change to be a force of good in the world? It's deeply unsettling that the most populated nation on Earth is ruled by one of the most corrupt governments on Earth, and that its culture is deeply xenophobic, irreverent of the environment, and any living organism other than their own. As China becomes more powerful, is there anything other nations can do to make this transition more positive for everyone? I don't mean economically, but on an existential level.
- dustymcp 4y agoIm afraid not, revolt has to come from within to change something like that unless you like the war option..
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI am trying to take this comment at face value. Do you really think other governments are that much better in terms of values you described? There are differences and not small ones between major nation states, but, well, factors listed are not unique not China.
- imiric 4y agoAh, the inevitable whataboutism whenever China is discussed. Other countries are not the topic here. But I'll engage: other countries and governments have similar issues, but the combination of factors I mentioned are unique to China.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI personally find that line of defense amusing. In order to discuss trend, one should be able to establish a baseline. In this case, other countries ( and respective factors mentioned by parent including corruption ) must be compared in order to draw a conclusion as to whether that statement is even true. Otherwise, it is just a claim. Still, I am not here to defend China. Tell me how China is that much more unique than say.. Russia ( which one could argue has similar problems with factors listed )?
- vagrantJin 4y ago
- typon 4y agoI have been "warned" for asking similar questions here, tread carefully.
- oneoff786 4y agoAuthoritarian government, blatant IP theft, hostile takeover of Hong Kong, hostile threats towards Taiwan, orders of magnitudes more censorship, etc.
- odshoifsdhfs 4y agoI'm not American, but it isn't only America that has this distrust/hate. China's government isn't compatible with (what we think) western democracy. Just this week a video was released (Manchester I think?) of China's Embassy guards trying to drag protestors inside the embassy while exerting violence (which they have no mandate to do) and if not for a British cop, the protestor would faced a worse fate. There is documented instances of Chinese 'police stations' in various capital cities that exert pressure/violence in these cities at the whim of the ccp. Industrial espionage is reported and just about expected from the Chinese companies/ccp here in Europe. Pressure on politicians, public institutions, professors, etc for saying something that is sensitive to the ccp/Xi. And these are just in our European soil (among many other things). If we go on about how China deals with Tibet/Taiwan, muslims, zero covid, etc etc, it is just a style of government that is in direct opposition with what we expect, and the fact they try to make us bend the knee of them, makes a lot of people not like any kind of Chinese influence in their turf.
- thot_experiment 4y ago[flagged]
- imiric 4y ago> First off "China" in this context means "the CCP", not the Chinese people, not the Chinese culture. At the risk of sounding xenophobic myself, I'd like to push back on this often mentioned excuse whenever "China" is criticized. I really think there are major issues with Chinese culture, which of course implies its people. Whether this comes from decades of brainwashing by their government, lack of education, or something else, I can't say, but we must be able to criticize "wrong" actions by people, without dumping it all on the government (which has issues of its own, and is likely responsible for most issues the country is currently facing), or fearing to be labeled xenophobic. Are there good people in China? Absolutely. But there's a widespread culture of xenophobia, abuse of the environment, and disregard for animal, plant and human life that just shouldn't go unnoticed. China is an enormous country, so I can't say whether this comes from a majority or not, but it absolutely exists in many places. I do concede the possibility that I've been brainwashed myself by western media, so I'm open to counterpoints to anything I've said.
- my_city 4y ago