3 ms·
An implicit point in my comment, which replies suggested wasn't clear, is that it's completely unclear what "fair" would even mean. Is it fair that my parents
by gumby 4y ago
An implicit point in my comment, which replies suggested wasn't clear, is that it's completely unclear what "fair" would even mean.
Is it fair that my parents went on an extended walkabout and so I happened to be in the US during high school and had the chance to go to amazing universities?
Is it fair that some kid with a 160 IQ grew up on a reservation with parents who desperately wanted to help the kid succeed but had no idea how, while the kid had to go to crappy schools, learn only the basics, and worry about their next meal? They would be waay smarter than I, but I would be far better prepared and would get more out of an MIT education.
Trying to diversify the student population sounds like a good thing for schools to be doing, something that in the medium term will hopefully ablate some of the second case. And if that excludes someone with high test scores, which is "fair"? Hell, if it excludes someone who diligently labored to worked the system, well, the there's a reasonable case to be made that such a person will do OK regardless while the student with less opportunity might end up with a greater benefit for society.
And, as far as "fair" goes: private universities, at least, are going to accept a certain number whom they believe will provide future donations, helping the institution survive and grow, even if they are otherwise unqualified. Is that fair?